Here’s the thing most people in the jewelry industry won’t tell you: there’s no universally right answer, but there is a right answer for your situation. And figuring that out is a lot simpler than the diamond industry would have you believe.

We’re Scott’s Custom Jewelers, a fourth-generation family jewelry store in Dublin, Ohio. We’ve been making custom engagement rings in the Columbus area for over 99 years, and for the past nine years, we’ve worked extensively with both lab grown and mined diamonds. We know our stuff!

So here’s the honest, no-marketing-spin breakdown of what you actually need to know before you buy any diamond.

Are Lab Grown Diamonds Real Diamonds?

Let’s start here, because this question still causes confusion. Yes, absolutely, a lab created diamond is a real diamond. Not a simulant, not a fake, not a “diamond alternative.”

Lab grown diamonds are chemically, physically, and optically identical to diamonds mined from the earth. That’s not a marketing claim – it’s the position of the Federal Trade Commission, which updated its guidelines in 2018 to reflect that lab diamonds are, in fact, real diamonds. The only difference is their origin: one formed underground over billions of years, and one was grown in a highly controlled laboratory environment in a matter of weeks.

Can a jeweler tell if my diamond is lab grown or mined?

Short answer: no. Without a very expensive piece of equipment, no jeweler can tell the difference between a lab grown diamond and a mined one by simply looking at it. Both lab and mined diamonds are graded using the same 4Cs — cut, carat, color, and clarity.

But, some mined diamonds, and most larger lab diamonds now also carry a laser-etched certification number on the girdle of the stone (it’s teeny tiny!) that does show the lab where it was graded, and will identify if it’s mined or lab created. A jeweler can easily look up that number and identify the origin.

Think of diamonds this way: a tomato grown in a greenhouse and a tomato grown in a garden are both tomatoes. The greenhouse version is often more consistent in quality (and usually costs less) because the environment is controlled. The garden version has a longer, more unpredictable story behind it. Yet, both are real tomatoes. Same with diamonds.

How Much Cheaper Are Lab Grown Diamonds Than Mined Ones?

This is where the numbers get interesting. Lab grown diamonds currently cost somewhere between 80 and 90% less than mined diamonds of comparable quality. That’s not a small difference.

Consider this: a well-cut 2-carat mined diamond that is graded at F/VS might run about $18,000 to $25,000. But a lab grown 2-carat diamond of equivalent quality only cost $1,800 to $2,000. Yikes! That’s money that can go toward a house, a honeymoon, or a much more elaborate custom ring setting than you thought you could afford.

At Scott’s, we consistently see couples who come in with a modest budget leave with significantly larger and more dramatic stones than they expected, simply because they’re open to lab grown diamonds. And the rings are stunning, btw.

Let’s Talk About Resale Value — Honestly

This is the question everyone dances around, and we’re not going to do that. Here’s the honest truth on lab diamond vs. mined diamond resale value:

Lab grown diamonds do not hold resale value well. Most will retain somewhere between 10 and 20% of their original purchase price in the secondary market. That sounds harsh until you compare it to mined diamonds, which also only retain 10 to 20% of their retail price. The reality is that diamonds have long been marketed as investments. But they really are not!

The math that most people miss: if you buy a $20,000 mined diamond and are able to sell it for 20% of value, you get $4,000 back, but you’ve lost $16,000 of your investment. But if you buy a $2,000 lab diamond and resells for $200, you’ve only lost $1800. In absolute dollar terms, the person who bought the lab diamond almost always comes out ahead. And that’s why people come to us to restyle their old diamonds into new pieces!

Unless you’re purchasing rare investment-grade colored diamonds or exceptionally large, flawless stones, no diamond – mined or lab grown – is a reliable financial investment. Jewelry is not a savings account. It’s a symbol.

If you’re buying an engagement ring because you love each other, because the ring means something, because you want it to be beautiful and meaningful, lab grown diamonds, or a family diamond that is repurposed, is a financially smart choice that sacrifices nothing in quality or beauty.

If you have a strong personal or sentimental reasons to prefer a mined stone, that’s also a completely valid choice. We offer conflict-free mined diamonds too, and we’ll help you find something extraordinary at either price point.

What Is the Quality Difference Between Lab and Earth-Mined Diamonds?

In most practical senses, there isn’t one. Both types are graded on the 4Cs. Both can have excellent cut, high color grades, and minimal inclusions. If anything, lab diamonds tend to be more consistent because production is controlled. You rarely see the wide quality variances that can show up in mined stones.

One technical distinction: GIA recently announced it will use a simplified two-tier grading system (Premium and Standard) for lab diamonds rather than the full 4C scale. This reflects the fact that about 95% of lab diamonds have the same high quality grades, a testament to how precise and consistent the growing process has become.

By the way, there are two techniques to produce lab diamonds – HPHT (High Pressure High Temperature) and CVD (Chemical Vapor Deposition). Both methods produce genuine, gemstone-quality diamonds.

At Scott’s, we are all about sustainability. All of the lab diamonds we source come from companies that use solar power in their production process and pay livable wages to their employees because this ethical decision is something many of our clients care deeply about.

How to Pick a Lab Diamond That Sparkles as Much as Natural

The secret to a firecracker of a diamond is almost entirely in the cut. A well-cut diamond will always outperform a poorly cut diamond, both lab and mined. We tell our customers to always prioritize cut quality first — then color and clarity.

For a round brilliant diamond, look for an Excellent or Ideal cut grade. For fancy shapes (oval, pear, cushion, radiant), you’re going to need some professional advise, so work with a jeweler you trust and evaluate the gemstone in person. This is one reason we always encourage clients to visit us in Dublin — looking at diamonds in person, in good lighting, tells you more than any certificate will.

So here are some tips when working with your jeweler:

• Prioritize Excellent or Very Good cut grades
• For colorless appearance, color grades D–G are ideal (H–J are often eye-clean and more budget-friendly when you are choosing a mined diamond)
• VS1 or VS2 clarity is typically the sweet spot and most lab diamonds fall in this category. Again for budget reasons, SI or SI1 clarity is somewhat clean to the naked eye and affordable for mined diamonds
• Look for an IGI or GIA certificate for any lab diamond over 0.75 carats
• Ask your jeweler to show you the stone in natural light, not just under display lighting

The Conflict-Free and Sustainability Angle

Lab grown diamonds are inherently conflict-free. There’s no supply chain to trace back to a mining region. For many couples – especially those with ethical concerns about the traditional diamond industry, this is a significant factor.

At Scott’s Custom Jewelers, we guarantee that all diamonds we provide, whether mined or lab grown, come from conflict-free sources. And we only use recycled, purified gold in our casting process. In fact, we’ve never needed to purchase newly mined gold, sustainable gold.

Also, when we first started offering lab grown diamonds to our customers, we make a decision to give back to the community even more, so when you purchase a lab grown diamond from Scott’s, we make a donation to the Dublin Food Pantry as part of our community commitment. It’s a small thing, but it means something to us.

So, Are Lab Grown Diamonds Worth Buying for an Engagement Ring?

For the overwhelming majority of couples we work with in Columbus and Dublin, the answer is yes. You get an identical stone in every way that matters visually and emotionally, at a fraction of the cost, with full ethical peace of mind, and more budget left over to put toward a more impressive custom design.

But this isn’t a one-size-fits-all answer. If you want a mined stone for personal, traditional, or investment reasons, we fully support that too. The best decision is the one that fits your values, your priorities, and your budget. If you’re trying to figure out which direction is right for you, the best thing you can do is come in and look at both side by side. We have lab grown and mined diamonds available, and our team is genuinely good at helping you find your style without pressure.

Ready to see what your budget can really do? Schedule a free design consultation at Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Dublin, Ohio — in-person or virtually. We’ll show you exactly what’s possible.

Book your appointment here

Why? Because oval shaped diamonds check pretty much every box. They look bigger than other shapes of the same carat weight, they’re elegant but still modern, and they flatter literally every hand.

It’s the perfect mix of timeless and trendy.

Why Oval Engagement Rings Are So Popular

There’s a reason oval engagement rings are everywhere right now. It’s actually pretty simple.

They look bigger! I mean – size does matter when it comes to diamonds

Oval diamonds naturally have more surface area too, so they appear larger than round diamonds of the same weight.

They’re timeless but fresh.
Oval engagement rings have a classic feel, but still stand out from traditional round diamonds.

They work with every style.
Solitaire, hidden halo, three stone, yellow gold, platinum – oval diamonds look good in everything.

Hidden Halo Engagement Rings Are a Close Second

The second most popular engagement ring style we’re seeing is the hidden halo engagement ring.

A hidden halo adds a small circle of diamonds underneath the center stone. You don’t see it from the top, but from the side, it adds extra sparkle.

It’s subtle, custom, and makes the center diamond pop.

Read more about custom design:
https://scottscustomjewelers.com/custom-engagement-rings-in-columbus-ohio-everything-you-need-to-know/

Lab Diamond Engagement Rings Are Now the Most Requested Option

Most of our customers in the Columbus area are choosing lab diamond engagement rings, especially for oval shapes. (Those Buckeyes are smart!) And for good reason.

Lab diamonds:

• Give you a bigger look for the budget
• Are identical to natural diamonds chemically, optically and physically
• Are eco-friendly, sustainable and ethically sourced
• Perfect for custom engagement ring budgets

In fact, most people can afford a bigger carat size without increasing their total engagement ring budget.

Learn more here:
https://scottscustomjewelers.com/lab-grown-diamonds-lp/

The Most Popular Engagement Ring Style Overall

If we had to sum it up, the most popular engagement ring style right now is an oval lab diamond engagement ring with a hidden halo in yellow gold. Total perfection!

It’s modern, timeless, and completely customizable.

But the real trend? Custom engagement rings designed specifically for the person wearing it.

Because the best engagement ring isn’t just popular — it’s personal.

Ready to Design Your Own Engagement Ring?

We’ll help you design a custom engagement ring in Columbus that fits your style, your budget, and your story.

Schedule a consultation here:

And not just okay, it’s actually one of the most meaningful things many of our clients do.

Here at Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Columbus, Ohio, we’ve helped generations of couples redesign, refresh, and restyle their rings. I mean, we’ve been in the “love business” now for close to 100 years! And almost every time someone asks this question, it comes with a little guilt.

“I still love my ring… I just want to update it.”
“It feels sentimental… but it doesn’t really fit my style anymore.”
“Is it wrong to change it?”

The answer is simple: your ring is a symbol of your life together — and your life grows and changes. Your ring can too. We always say, styles change, gold wears away and fingers change. What was perfect years ago now can use a little update!

Why People Upgrade Their Wedding Rings?

There’s no single “right” reason. Some of the most common ones we hear in our Columbus showroom:

• An anniversary or milestone (10, 20, 25 years together)
• A change in style
• A ring that no longer fits (it happens to all of us!)
• Wanting to incorporate family diamonds or gemstones into the ring
• Or simply… “I’m ready for a refresh”

Your marriage didn’t stop growing on your wedding day. Neither did you.

Does Upgrading Your Ring Mean You Didn’t Love the Original?

Oh my gosh, not at all! In fact, we see upgrades as the opposite.

Your original ring represents where your story started.
Your updated ring represents how far you’ve come.

Many of our clients keep their original stones and build around them, preserving the sentiment while improving the look, comfort, or style.

Easy (and Affordable) Ways to Upgrade Your Wedding Ring

So now that that’s settled, what’s the next steps? Upgrading doesn’t have to mean starting over — and it definitely doesn’t have to mean breaking the bank.

Here are some of our favorite ways to refresh a ring.

Add a Diamond Halo

One of our favorites! A halo can make your center diamond look bigger or even change the shape of the original stone. Halos also add tons of sparkle and can completely transforms the look without replacing your main stone.

Depending upon the structure of the original wedding ring, adding a halo is one of the most cost-effective visual upgrades we do.

Add Stacking Rings or Anniversary Bands

We love a good stack! Adding stacking rings is a trendy, sentimental way to tell your life’s story. Plus, you can add one at a time over the years, making it an affordable option.

Stacking bands are perfect for commemorating significant milestones in your life. Anniversaries, birthdays, big milestones, even a ring to represent a child – your wedding stack can make your original ring feel brand new again.

Upgrade the Center Stone (Hello, Lab Diamonds!)

With today’s affordable lab grown diamonds, upgrading your center stone is more accessible than ever.

Adding a new lab diamond center stone let’s you go bigger or change the shape of your wedding ring at a bargain because they are 80-90% less than natural diamonds!

Lab grown diamonds are real diamonds, and they’ve opened the door for so many clients to finally get the ring they’ve always dreamed of. So many of our customers have upgraded their rings with bigger, higher quality lab diamonds, then set their original stone into a pendant, that they can wear close to their hearts.

(We explain lab diamonds more here → Is a lab grown diamond a real diamond?

Use Family Diamonds or Gemstones

One of our favorite things to do at Scott’s is blend generations together. Adding a family stone to your wedding ring – maybe in a trendy Toi et Moi or Three-Stone design – is so meaningful!

Suddenly, your ring isn’t just jewelry — it’s a family story you can wear every day.

Why Winter Is the Perfect Time to Upgrade or Restyle Your Ring

After the holidays, we see an upturn in wedding ring restyling at our store. Winter is rough in Columbus, Ohio, but it’s our favorite season for ring redesigns — and here’s why:

• You’re indoors more, scrolling reels and Pinterest
• You’re thinking about fresh starts and spring cleaning
• Jewelry tends to come out of the drawer this time of year
• And there’s less rush than during engagement season

We like to call it “Spring cleaning your jewelry box… before spring even gets here.”

It’s the perfect time to bring in your old pieces, remove the stones and recycle that gold (another cost saving move) and turn forgotten jewelry into something you’ll love again.

Is It Expensive to Redesign a Wedding Ring?

It doesn’t have to be. Redesigning your wedding ring lets you reuse your gold and stones, so you preserve the memories. And, with sustainable, affordable lab diamond options, we can design around your budget.

Most people are surprised by how affordable restyling can be compared to buying something brand new.

Our Philosophy at Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Columbus, Ohio

My mom, who worked in the family business with my dad, used to say, it was sinful for jewelry to sit in a drawer. Wear it! And we couldn’t agree more.

We believe jewelry should be worn, adored, and fit the life you’re living now.

And after four generations in the jewelry business, we can tell you — some of the most emotional, meaningful pieces we create are upgraded and redesigned rings.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it okay to change my wedding ring?

Absolutely. Many couples upgrade or redesign their rings to celebrate milestones or match their current style.

Should I keep my original diamond?

If you love it — yes! We often design around original stones to preserve the sentiment.

Can I upgrade my ring on a budget?

Yes. Using lab diamonds, halos, stacking bands, or your existing materials keeps costs very reasonable.

Can you use my old or family jewelry?

We specialize in that. It’s one of our favorite parts of custom design.

Thinking About Upgrading Your Wedding Ring in Columbus?

Whether you want a simple refresh, a bigger center stone, a more modern look, or a meaningful family redesign., we can help.

Make your appointment (in person or virtual) here:

Or stop into Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Columbus, Ohio and let’s take a look at what you have, and what it could become.

So let’s talk honestly about the question we hear all the time in our custom jewelry showroom:

“What are the disadvantages of lab grown diamonds?”

Lab grown diamonds have become incredibly popular in Columbus (actually, they’re popular in the entire country!) and we totally get why. I mean, they’re beautiful, affordable, and check off all the sustainability boxes. No wonder they’ve become the hottest selling gemstone for a custom engagement ring!

Here at Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Columbus, Ohio, we work with both lab grown and natural diamonds every single day. We also specialize in reusing diamonds and gemstones that you already own in your designs (another nod to sustainability). We don’t believe in pushing one gem over the other, and work with you to help you make the right decision for you.

First Off: What Is a Lab Grown Diamond?

A lab grown diamond is a real diamond. Same sparkle. Same hardness. Same chemical structure. The only difference is where it’s grown. We have been following lab grown diamonds for over 10 years now, and when the Federal Trade Commission said they were exactly the same chemically, physically and optically, we started offering them to our customers.

Here’s what they are:

• Natural diamonds grow in the earth over billions of years
• Lab diamonds are grown in a lab in a few weeks using advanced technology

Also, lab diamonds are not fake and not cubic zirconia. In fact, if a jeweler says they can tell a lab diamonds from a mined diamond without special equipment, they’re lying.

(We explain this more here → https://scottscustomjewelers.com/lab-grown-diamonds-lp/)

The Disadvantages of Lab Grown Diamonds

We’re all about transparency! There are a few things you should absolutely know before choosing a lab diamond for an engagement ring or custom jewelry piece.

1. Lab Grown Diamonds Do Not Hold High Dollar Value Like Natural Diamonds

This is the biggest difference, but it comes with an explanation.

Lab diamonds:

• Are not rare
• Can be produced in unlimited quantities
• Continue to drop in price as technology improves

Because of this, lab grown diamonds do not retain or increase in value like natural diamonds sometimes can. Now for the explanation: Natural diamonds are also not “rare” but rather the amount available to the public is controlled by the mining companies, kind of like fossil fuels.

And even more importantly, natural diamonds may have higher worth, but unless you’re a diamond wholesaler, you won’t get the full value of either a lab or mined diamonds if you need to sell it. At best, you’ll get 20% of it’s worth if you have to sell your diamond to a pawn shop.

Simple math time. Say you spend $10,000 on a natural diamond and you need to sell it. You’ll most likely get $2,000 for it, but will have lost $8,000. Ouch.

Same situation, but with a lab grown diamond. You spend $1,000 on it (because they’re about 90% less expensive than mined stones) and need to sell it. You’ll get about $200 for it at a pawn shop, but will only have lost $800! That’s a much better scenario!

Why many Columbus buyers are still okay with this:

Most people aren’t buying an engagement ring as an investment. They’re buying it to celebrate a relationship, and they plan on wearing it everyday. Lab diamonds check off those boxes!

And lab diamonds let you get a bigger, more impressive diamond because they are 80-90% less than diamonds mined from the earth. Plus, they are sustainable and conflict free.

2. Lab Diamond Prices Keep Dropping

Yes, just like electronics and appliances, this is true. Lab diamond prices have come down a lot over the past few years, due to more companies getting into the market, but those prices now seem to have stabilized.

The upside for you:

With a much lower cost than natural diamonds, you can invest more of your budget into the design and craftsmanship of the ring, giving it even more meaning!

We see this every day in our Columbus custom design studio.

3. Lab Grown Diamonds Are Not Rare

Some people love the idea of a diamond formed naturally over billions of years. That story matters to them, and that’s completely valid. But then again, natural diamonds aren’t as rare as they’ve been marketed to be. It’s supply and demand!

The romance of a mined diamond is pretty cool. And, as sustainable jewelers, we absolutely LOVE to reuse diamonds and gemstones from family pieces, because of the stories associated with these stones!

And that brings us to a super important point:

What actually makes your engagement ring unique:

It’s all about the story. At Scott’s Custom Jewelers, your ring is unique because YOU call the shots! We’ll work with you to create a piece that fits your style, your hand, your story!

The design and the meaning associated with the piece, is what makes it special.

See some of our custom jewelry projects

Pros and Cons of Lab Grown Diamonds (Quick List)

Pros

• Cost 80-90% less than natural diamonds
• Bigger or higher quality diamond for your budget
• Real diamond (same sparkle, same durability same material)
• Excellent for everyday wear as a custom engagement rings
• Great option for an anniversary upgrades and statement rings
• No mining required, no social conflicts
• Consistent quality and availability

Cons

• Do not hold or increase in value
• Prices continue to drop over time
• Limited resale or trade-in value
• Not rare or finite

Why So Many Columbus Couples Choose Lab Diamonds

That’s the big question. We actually sell more lab diamonds at our Columbus store than any store in Ohio! Customers have chosen lab diamonds because they check so many boxes:

• More affordable, so they can have a bigger center stone
• High quality lab diamonds offer better quality, clarity and color for the price
• Able to afford a more detailed custom setting for their engagement ring
• Or all the above!

We regularly hear in our Columbus showroom, “I never thought I could afford something like this.” That’s one of our favorite things about lab diamonds.

Our Honest Opinion at Scott’s Custom Jewelers

We love them all!

• Lab diamonds
• Natural diamonds
• Family diamonds
• Vintage diamonds
• And everything in between

They’re just different tools for different goals.

Our job is to educate you, show you the real differences, and help you choose what fits your priorities and budget.

Frequently Asked Questions About Lab Grown Diamonds

Are lab grown diamonds real diamonds?

Yes. Lab grown diamonds are chemically, optically and physically identical to natural diamonds.

Do lab grown diamonds look different than natural diamonds?

No. Even gemologists need special equipment to tell them apart.

Are lab diamonds cheaper than natural diamonds?

Yes. Lab diamonds typically cost 80–90% less than natural diamonds of the same size and quality.

Do lab grown diamonds lose value?

They don’t “lose” value — but they don’t hold value or appreciate like natural diamonds might.

Are lab diamonds good for engagement rings?

Absolutely. They are durable, beautiful, and perfect for everyday wear.

Should I buy a lab or natural diamond?

That depends on:

• Your budget
• Your priorities
• Whether size, value retention, or tradition matters more to you

We help Columbus clients compare both every day in our showroom.

Thinking About a Custom Engagement Ring?

Whether you’re considering lab grown diamonds, natural diamonds, or a combination of both, we’d love to help you design something that fits your style, your budget, and your story.

Make your FREE custom jewelry appointment (both in person and virtually) here

Or stop into Scott’s Custom Jewelers and let’s design something amazing together.

Short answer? Yes.

Long answer? Well, let’s break it down realistically, without the jargon, without the hype, and with the almost 100 years of perspective we’ve gathered and shared here with our customers.

What Are Laboratory Diamonds, Really?

Laboratory diamonds (also called lab-grown or lab-created diamonds) are definitely real diamonds. They have the same chemical composition, crystal structure, sparkle, and hardness as mined diamonds. The difference is where they’re formed—not what they are.

Instead of growing underground over billions of years, lab diamonds are created in controlled environments using advanced technology that replicates natural diamond growth.

The diamond “rough” or crystal is then graded by the same gemological laboratories, cut by the same artisans, and set into fine jewelry just like mined diamonds.

We like to compare lab diamonds to babies… I know, but hear me out! Some babies are conceived a couple of ways. One way is with a little help from a lab. Another, is the old fashioned way But people don’t identify them as a “test tube baby” because they are simply, a baby!

Just a note though: Lab diamonds are significantly less expensive than mined diamonds. The same can’t be said for IVF conception!

A Short History On Lab Diamonds

Lab diamonds aren’t new, even if they feel like a modern day trend.

Scientists first successfully created diamonds in laboratories in the 1950s, initially for industrial uses. They were used on cutting tools because of their strength. Over time, technology improved dramatically, and by the early 2000s, gem-quality lab diamonds entered the fine jewelry world.

In the last decade though, lab diamonds have truly come into their own, offering beauty, transparency, sustainability and value that today’s couples and jewelry lovers care deeply about. We’ve watched this shift firsthand and have shared the evolution regularly on our blog as education and consumer awareness have grown. In fact, we were one of the first jewelry stores to offer lab grown diamonds in Ohio!

So… Are Laboratory Diamonds Worth Anything?

Absolutely—but it’s important to understand how their value works.

Lab diamonds hold value as fine gemstones and as wearable luxury. What they don’t promise is speculative or investment-style appreciation. And honestly? That’s true for most diamonds, mined or lab-grown.

In fact, unless you are in the diamond wholesale business, jewelry as an investment is not lucrative, no matter what the big jewelry cartels’ companies say.

Here’s an example. Say you have a 1ct mined diamond engagement ring that you paid $10,000 for ten years ago. Now you want the cash. Your main option, is a pawn shop, where they’ll give you, generously, 20%, or $2,000. You’ve just lost 8K on your investment.

Now you have the same situation with a 1ct. lab diamond ring that you paid $1000 for. Again, best option is a pawn shop and 20%, so you get $200. But… you only realized a loss of $800. Big difference! That’s really the reason people restyle their jewelry instead of selling it. They don’t lose monetary value, AND they keep the memories!

Affordability: More Diamond for Your Budget

One of the biggest reasons people choose lab diamonds is simple: you get more bling for your money.

Lab diamonds typically cost significantly less (80-90% less) than comparable mined diamonds. That means they can afford:

• A larger center stone
• Higher color or clarity
• Room in the budget for custom design or upgraded settings

We often see clients choose lab diamonds so they can design the ring or piece they really want—without compromise. It’s one of the reasons lab diamonds have become such a popular topic on our blog and in our custom design conversations.

Sustainability & Conflict-Free Peace of Mind

Another major reason lab diamonds are worth it? How they align with modern values. Today’s engagement ring couples are well-versed in environmental issues and human rights violations, and they want a gemstone that reflects their values.

Lab-grown diamonds offer:

• Conflict-free choices
• Avoid the environmental impact of traditional mining on the earth
• Greater transparency in sourcing

For many couples and gift-givers, this peace of mind is priceless. You know exactly where your diamond came from, and that the impact on the environment is minimal.

Frequently Asked Questions About Lab Diamonds

Are lab diamonds real diamonds?

Yes. They are chemically, physically, and optically identical to mined diamonds.

Do lab diamonds sparkle the same?

Absolutely! Sparkle comes from cut quality—not whether a diamond was mined or grown. A skilled diamond cutter makes the difference in the brilliancy of the stone.,

Will a lab diamond last forever?

Yes. Lab diamonds are just as durable as mined diamonds and perfect for everyday wear.

Do lab diamonds have resale value?

Lab diamonds retain value as fine jewelry, though resale pricing differs from mined diamonds. We always encourage choosing a any diamond for love and wear-ability, not for an investment.

Are lab diamonds right for engagement rings?

Absolutely. We design custom engagement rings with lab diamonds every day, and they’ve become a favorite choice for most of our couples.

Our Take: What Really Makes a Diamond “Worth It”

At the end of the day, a diamond’s worth isn’t just about numbers—it’s about meaning, intention, and joy. Ask any couple about their engagement ring and they’ll tell you a story about how it happened.

We feel that lab diamonds give our customers the freedom to choose beautiful, responsibly sourced gemstones, while staying within budget—and that’s something we proudly stand behind.

Thinking about a lab diamond for an engagement ring, anniversary gift, or custom redesign? We’d love to help you explore the options and find what feels right for you.

Because the best jewelry choices are informed ones—and the most valuable pieces are the ones you love wearing every day.

We’ve been offering lab diamonds to our customers for about 10 years now, every since the Federal Trade Commission ruled that lab diamonds were chemically, optically and physically identical to their mined counterparts.

Whether you’re curious about ethical sourcing, modern style, or smart budgeting, here’s why lab diamonds are becoming a favorite—and some answers to the most common questions we hear from our customers.

Lab Diamonds vs. Mined Diamonds: What’s the Difference?

Q&A: Understanding the Lab Diamond Boom

Q: What exactly is a lab diamond?
A: Lab diamonds are real diamonds, grown in controlled laboratory conditions rather than mined from the earth. Chemically and physically, they’re identical to natural diamonds—they sparkle, shine, and are forever. The only difference? Their origin.

Q: Why are lab diamonds so popular now?
A: There are several reasons:

1. Ethical Sourcing: Lab diamonds are conflict-free, giving couples peace of mind that their ring supports responsible practices.
2. Affordability: You can often get a larger or higher-quality stone for the same budget compared to mined diamonds.
3. Sustainability: Growing diamonds in a lab reduces environmental impact, from less mining to lower carbon emissions.

Q: Are lab diamonds less “real” than mined diamonds?
A: Absolutely not! Lab diamonds are chemically, physically, and optically the same as natural diamonds. If anything, some people consider them even “better” because you know exactly where they came from and the conditions under which they were created. We like to say diamonds are like babies — some are conceived “the old fashioned way”, others in a lab. But they’re all babies once they’re born!

Q: How do lab diamonds look on a ring?
A: Stunning. Whether you choose a classic solitaire, a vintage-inspired halo, or a modern custom design, lab diamonds have the same brilliance and fire as natural diamonds. At Scott’s Custom Jewelers, we love showing off these stones in unique, handcrafted designs.

Q: Are lab diamonds a good investment?
A: Lab diamonds are a smart choice for personal value and ethical considerations, but they do not always hold resale value like some natural diamonds.

But the reality is that reselling diamonds is almost always a loss. Typically, you can resell any diamond for 15-20% of it’s stated value. If you spent $10,000 on a mined diamond, you would get about $2,000 at a pawn shop, resulting in a $8,000 loss. And if you had to resell your $1,000 lab diamond, you would get about $200, with an $800 loss. Much easier to handle!

That said, many couples prioritize beauty, quality, and sustainability over resale price—and lab diamonds deliver on all three.

Why Couples Are Choosing Lab Diamonds Over Mined Diamonds

More and more couples are prioritizing values alongside aesthetics when selecting a diamond. And for good reason! Here’s why lab diamonds are winning hearts:

• Ethical Assurance: Many couples want to avoid the social and environmental concerns sometimes associated with mined diamonds. Lab diamonds provide a guilt-free sparkle.
• Smart Budgeting: Couples can choose larger, higher-quality stones without stretching their budgets. They can also afford extras in their rings – like diamond details.
• Sustainable Choice: Conscious couples are increasingly concerned about their environmental footprint. Lab diamonds are seen as a modern, responsible choice that aligns with sustainable living.
• Innovation Appeal: Lab diamonds feel fresh, innovative, and modern—qualities many young couples are looking for in their wedding jewelry.

In short, lab diamonds offer couples a way to combine beauty, conscience, and individuality in one dazzling package.

Why Couples in Dublin, Ohio Are Choosing Lab Diamonds

At Scott’s Custom Jewelers, most of our couples are asking for lab diamonds when designing their custom engagement rings. Many are drawn by the combination of affordability, ethics, and customizability. And with our CAD technology, 3D printers and our 3 in-house jewelers, you can get exactly the look you want without compromising on quality or conscience.

Whether it’s a delicate oval lab diamond pendant or a bold cushion-cut engagement ring, lab diamonds let you design jewelry that’s as unique as your love story.

Thinking About a Lab Diamond?

If you’ve been wondering why lab diamonds are getting more popular, we hope this guide gives you insight and inspiration. Stop by Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Dublin, Ohio, or schedule a custom appointment to see our lab-grown diamonds in person. There’s nothing like seeing a sparkling diamond up close to understand why it’s capturing hearts everywhere.

Shopping for an engagement ring or diamond can feel overwhelming. So.Many.Questions! Between online ads, flashy sales, and opinions from just about everybody, one big question comes up again and again:
“Should I buy a diamond online or in-store?”

At Scott’s Custom Jewelers, we’ve helped hundreds of couples find (or design!) their perfect engagement ring. Whether to shop online or visit our Dublin, Ohio showroom, knowing the pros and cons of each option can make all the difference.

Buying a Diamond Online: The Pros and Cons

At first glance, buying a diamond online can seem pretty convenient — you can compare prices, browse thousands of stones, and shop from home in your pajamas! But there are some trade-offs to consider.

Pros:

• Convenience: Browse anytime, anywhere.
• Wider Selection: Online retailers may offer more inventory choices.
• Competitive Prices: Lower overhead can mean lower prices — but not always better value.

Cons:

• No Visual Comparison: You can’t see sparkle, fire, or color in person.
• Quality Uncertainty: Not all diamonds are graded equally or represented accurately.
• No Personal Guidance: You’re on your own when choosing between dozens of technical details.
• Limited Customization: Online retailers often don’t design one-of-a-kind pieces around your vision.

Buying a Diamond In-Store: Why It Matters

When you buy from a trusted local jeweler like Scott’s Custom Jewelers, (with over 98 years in the family business) you get something the internet can’t offer — a personal, transparent experience. And with so many options on-line, having a real person to interact with is a plus!

Benefits of Buying In-Store:

• See Before You Buy: You can compare diamonds side-by-side in real lighting, not on a screen. And they are different – you’ll see that when you compare them.
• Expert Guidance: Our team explains clarity, cut, color, and carat — so you understand exactly what you’re getting. And they also can guide you on the difference between mined and lab grown diamonds. (hint: lab diamonds are exactly the same physically, chemically and optically to mined diamonds – but cost up to 80%)
• Custom Design Options: Want a unique engagement ring? At Scott’s, we design and 3D print custom rings right here in Dublin, Ohio.
• Trusted Service: As a 4th generation jewelry store, you’ll always know who to call for cleanings, repairs, and future upgrades.

Buying in-store gives you confidence, education, and the peace of mind that comes from working with real experts — not just clicking “add to cart.”

The Smartest Option: Combine Both

As with most things, the best approach is often a blend of both worlds.
We suggest you begin your research online, compare styles, start a Pinterest board, and learn what you like. Then visit a trusted jeweler like Scott’s Custom Jewelers to see the difference in person.

You’ll be able to touch, feel, and compare real diamonds — and work with a family of experts who can help you design something that fits both your style and your budget.

Q&A: Buying Diamonds Online vs. In-Store

Q: Is buying a diamond online safe?
A: It can be, if you buy from a reputable seller. But even then, you can’t see what you’re getting until it arrives — and returns can be stressful. In-store, you can inspect the diamond yourself before you buy.

Q: Are online diamonds cheaper?
A: Sometimes, but not always. Many online prices don’t include services like setting, resizing, or future maintenance. At Scott’s, we help you maximize your budget with lab-grown diamonds and custom settings — often at comparable or better value.

Q: Can I design a custom ring in-store?
A: Absolutely! At Scott’s Custom Jewelers, we create custom designs using your ideas, or even heirloom stones. Plus you’ll see a 3D model of your ring before it’s made here in our Dublin, Ohio store — so there are no surprises.

Q: What’s the advantage of shopping local?
A: Local jewelers offer personal service, ongoing care, and expertise that online stores can’t match. Plus, you’re supporting a family-owned Dublin, Ohio business that’s been trusted for decades. And the “Dad Jokes” at Scott’s are free-of-charge!

Final Thoughts

There’s no wrong answer when it comes to choosing to shop on-line or in-store — just what feels right for you. But if you want confidence, expert guidance, and a ring as unique as your love story, seeing diamonds in person is priceless.

Visit Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Dublin, Ohio to experience the difference in sparkle, service, and craftsmanship.

Schedule your custom appointment today — and let’s design the perfect ring together.

A Guide from Scott’s Custom Jewelers

When you’re ready to pop the question, one of the most common (and stressful!) decisions you’ll make is: “How much should I spend on an engagement ring?” The truth is, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer — but there are several variables to consider.

At Scott’s Custom Jewelers, we know that every love story—and every budget—is unique. The right amount to spend on an engagement ring isn’t a set number; it’s what feels right for you, your partner, and your future together.

The Truth About the “3-Month Salary Rule”

You’ve probably heard the old rule that says you should spend two or three months’ salary on a ring. Yikes! That idea came from a 20th-century marketing campaign — not from real-life couples.

Today’s couples are smarter about their money. They want a beautiful, meaningful engagement ring without the financial stress. So, whether that means spending $1,500 or $15,000, what matters most is creating something personal that will last a lifetime.

What Affects the Price of an Engagement Ring?

When setting your budget, here are the main factors that impact cost:

• Diamond or Gemstone Choice – Lab-grown diamonds, natural diamonds, inherited diamonds, — even sapphires, and rubies — all vary in cost. Lab-grown diamonds are especially popular right now — they’re exactly the same as mined diamonds chemically, optically and physically, but cost up to 80% less than mined diamonds.
• Setting Style – Solitaire, hidden-halo, name brand, or custom settings can affect both style and cost.
• Metal Type – Platinum, white, yellow, or rose gold. Depending on how much metal is in the design will affect the total cost of an engagement ring.
• Customization – A custom-designed ring isn’t necessarily more expensive than an “off-the-shelf” ring. A custom ring lets you control your budget and design every detail to match your taste.

What’s the Average Cost of an Engagement Ring?

In 2025, the average engagement ring in the U.S. costs around $6,000, but most couples spend between $2,000–$8,000.
At Scott’s Custom Jewelers, many of our custom lab diamond engagement rings fall in the $3,000–$5,000 range — proving you can have a stunning, high-quality ring without overspending.

How to Set a Ring Budget You’ll Feel Good About

1. Decide what’s comfortable for you. Focus on what fits your lifestyle and finances.
2. Talk with your partner. Some couples plan the purchase together, others prefer a surprise — just make sure you’re on the same page.
3. Compare options. Lab-grown and mined diamonds both offer beauty — see them side-by-side in person.
4. Work with a trusted jeweler. The right jeweler will explain your options clearly and help you maximize your budget.

Engagement Ring Budget Q&A

Q: Is it okay to spend less than the average on a ring?
A: Absolutely! Your ring should match your budget and your priorities. Many couples today are choosing meaningful designs that emphasize craftsmanship and sentiment over size or price tag.

Q: Are lab-grown diamonds worth it?
A: Yes — lab diamonds are chemically identical to mined diamonds, eco-friendly, and more affordable. You can often get a larger or higher-quality stone for the same price. And no one — not even a jeweler — can tell them apart without special equipment!

Q: Can I design a custom engagement ring on a budget?
A: Definitely. At Scott’s Custom Jewelers, custom doesn’t mean expensive. It means personal. We can work within nearly any budget to design something that’s uniquely yours — even using inherited gems or family stones.

Q: How do I know if I’m getting a fair price?
A: Look for transparency. We show you diamond options side-by-side and explain what affects the cost so you can make an informed, confident decision.

Final Thoughts

There’s no universal rule for how much you should spend on an engagement ring — only what feels right for you.

At Scott’s Custom Jewelers, we help you design a ring that fits your love story and your budget. From classic solitaires to one-of-a-kind custom designs, we’ll guide you every step of the way.

Ready to start your design?
Schedule your custom appointment today and discover how easy (and fun!) it is to create the perfect engagement ring — right here at Scott’s Custom Jewelers.

At Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Dublin, Ohio, we actually specialize in custom jewelry made just for you. As a 4th generation jeweler, we’ve perfected the design process and have created thousands of heirloom-quality pieces over the past 25 years. We use CAD technology and 3D printers (we currently have 3!), to design each piece, then cast them into gold or platinum and set the stones, all on-site in our store.

With custom jewelry, every design starts with your input and ideas, and ends with a sparkle that’s completely your own. Here’s what to expect — and how long it really takes — to bring your custom ring to life.

Step 1: The Design Consultation (1-2 weeks)

Your custom ring journey begins with a design appointment. We’ll sit down with you (in person or virtually via ZOOM) to talk about your ideas, budget, and inspiration. This is where the fun begins! Bring all the photos, sketches, Pinterest boards, and any sentimental piece of jewelry you’d like to reuse — like grandma’s diamonds or an old engagement setting.

This is also a great time to go through that jewelry box and recycle all those mismatched earrings, broken chains and out-of-style pieces you don’t wear anymore. We’ll remove any stones for you, recycle the gold, then credit you that amount off your new jewelry.

From there, we’ll create sketches or CAD renderings so you can see exactly how your design will look from multiple angles, before it’s made. We can also easily give you options of on metal color or added design features.

Average time: 1–2 weeks, depending on revisions and design complexity.

Step 2: Final Design Approval (about 1 week)

Once you’ve reviewed your renderings, we’ll make any small tweaks before production begins. Most clients approve their design within a few days, but we always allow about a week to make sure it’s perfect.

Step 3: Crafting Your Custom Ring (3–6 weeks)

Here’s where our jewelers bring your vision to life. Your ring is cast, set, and polished by hand with care and precision.

• Classic solitaire or simple settings: 2–4 weeks
• Detailed or heirloom remount designs: 4–6 weeks

Each ring is crafted from the finest materials — whether you choose a brilliant lab diamond, family gemstones, or both.

Step 4: The Big Reveal

Your finished ring is carefully inspected, cleaned, and presented beautifully — ready for that unforgettable moment.

Total Timeline: 4–6 Weeks

So how long does it take to design a custom ring? From consultation to completion, most custom rings take around 4–6 weeks. If you’re planning a proposal or a holiday gift, it’s best to start your design at least two months ahead so it’s ready to sparkle when you are.

Custom Ring Design Q&A

Q: Can you make a custom ring faster if I’m on a deadline?
A: Often, yes! Simple designs and lab diamond solitaires can sometimes be completed more quickly. Let us know your timing, and we’ll do everything we can to meet your deadline.

Q: Can I use my own stones or gold in the design?
A: Absolutely. We love repurposing family stones or sentimental metals — it adds even more meaning to your new piece.

Q: Do I need a clear idea before scheduling a consultation?
A: Not at all! Bring your inspiration (even just a Pinterest board), and we’ll guide you through styles, stones, and settings that fit your personality and budget.

Q: How much does a custom ring cost?
A: With lab diamonds, you can get a stunning, custom-designed ring for far less than you might expect. Every design is quoted individually, and we’re happy to work within your comfort range.

Q: Is it too late to start a ring for Christmas or the holidays?
A: If you’re reading this — start now! Our holiday custom schedule fills up quickly, and beginning early ensures your piece will be ready to gift or propose with this season.

Ready to Start Your Custom Ring Design?

There’s nothing more special than jewelry designed just for you. Whether it’s a lab diamond engagement ring, an upgraded wedding set, or a one-of-a-kind heirloom redesign, we’ll make the process simple, personal, and fun.

Start your holiday custom design now — appointments fill fast!

Schedule Your Custom Design Appointment at Scott’s Custom Jewelers
Serving Ohio with beautiful, affordable custom jewelry since from our family since 1927.

The best part? Custom isn’t expensive. In fact, with the popularity of lab grown diamond engagement rings in Columbus, Ohio, you can often design something one-of-a-kind, and high quality, at a cost similar to buying a mass-produced ring from a chain store.

Why choose a custom engagement ring in Columbus?

A custom engagement ring in Columbus, Ohio from Scott’s Custom Jewelers means you’re part of the design process from the very beginning. Isn’t that cool! Instead of picking out a mass produced style from a case of boring rings, you can:

• Work with a local jeweler face-to-face (or ZOOM to ZOOM)
• Choose the diamond shape, size, and quality that fits your budget
• Add meaningful touches like hidden gemstones or engraving

Learn more about our custom jewelry design process at Scott’s Custom Jewelers.

Are lab grown diamonds right for me?

Lab grown diamond engagement rings are quickly becoming one of the top choices for couples in Columbus. These diamonds have the same sparkle, durability, and brilliance as mined diamonds—but they cost up to 80% less.

That means you can afford a larger carat size or higher quality without breaking your budget. Plus, if sustainability matters to you, a lab created diamond engagement ring in Columbus, Ohio from Scott’s Custom Jewelers is one of the most ethical choices you can make.

Lab diamonds are exactly the same as diamonds mined from the earth optically, physically and chemically. And without special equipment, no one can tell the difference.

Learn more about lab grown diamonds.

Isn’t custom jewelry more expensive?

One of the most common questions couples ask is: “Is a custom engagement ring more expensive?” The answer is a huge no!

A custom engagement ring from Scott’s Custom Jewelers is often similar in cost to buying something pre-made. Custom jewelry just means you pay for only what you want, not extra features that you don’t like. And, because you’re not paying for national branding, you’re investing in craftsmanship and materials chosen specifically for you.

How long does the process take?

Designing a custom diamond engagement ring in Columbus at Scott’s usually takes 4–6 weeks. Some designs can be completed faster, depending on complexity. If you’re planning a holiday or special proposal, it’s always best to start the process early.

What if I don’t know what I want?

That’s the beauty of working with a local jeweler. You don’t need to know every detail before you begin. They’re the experts! Of course you can bring inspiration photos, Pinterest ideas, or even sketches, and Scott’s Custom Jewelers will help you turn them into a reality.

Meet in Person or Virtually

Whether you’re local or planning from afar, you have so many options when starting your custom design. You can schedule an in-person appointment at Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Columbus or meet with us virtually via Zoom consultation. Either way, you’ll get one-on-one guidance to create your perfect ring.

Schedule an appointment at Scott’s Custom Jewelers here.

Final Thoughts

If you’re searching for:

• Engagement rings Columbus Ohio jewelers
• Custom engagement rings with lab grown diamonds
• Affordable custom diamond engagement rings in Ohio

…then Scott’s Custom Jewelers is the smartest choice. It’s personal, meaningful, and surprisingly affordable.

Schedule your in-person or Zoom consultation at Scott’s Custom Jewelers today and let’s design your dream ring together.