And at Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Columbus, Ohio? You can also try it on!

We know that designing a custom engagement ring from scratch can feel a little nerve-wracking. I mean, it’s one of the most sentimental pieces of jewelry you’ll ever buy, and the idea of not seeing it until it’s finished is enough to make anyone break out in a sweat. And that’s exactly why we built our whole custom design process around making sure you’re never left guessing.

What’s our secret? A 3D printed model of your ring. And it’s one of the coolest parts of what we do.

What Is a 3D Printed Engagement Ring Model?

Here’s how it works at Scott’s.

After our initial consultation, our CAD (computer-aided design) team will work up your ring design based on your ideas, photos, and inspiration and will send you hi-resolution photos of the piece using specialized jewelry design software.

Then, we take that digital design and print it. Literally. Our 3D printer creates a physical replica of your ring in a resin material that’s identical to the finished piece. We can even set the gemstones into place.

You get to hold it. Try it on. Look at it in the mirror. Show it to your best friend.

And if something’s not quite right – maybe the band feels a little too wide, or the setting sits a little higher than you’d like – we make those adjustments right then and there. At no extra charge.

Only when you’re completely in love with the model do we cast your ring in gold or platinum and set the real stones.

Why This Matters More Than You Might Think

“I’ve been looking online for weeks and I still can’t picture what I actually want.”

We hear this every.single.week. Shopping for a custom engagement ring is exciting, but it can also be overwhelming. Pinterest boards are full of gorgeous rings. Instagram reels show them from the most flattering angles. AI creates jewelry that isn’t physically possible (more on that in another post!) But none of that tells you how a ring will actually look on your hand, with your stone.

But a 3D printed model does.

And for couples who want to design their ring together, which is becoming more and more common, this step is everything. You’re not trusting a sketch. You’re holding the real thing. (Well, almost the real thing.)

The Full Custom Ring Process at Scott’s: Step by Step

If you’re new to the idea of designing a custom engagement ring, here’s a simple look at how our process works from start to finish:

Step 1: The design consultation

We start with a conversation. In person at our Dublin, Ohio studio, or virtually if that’s easier. You bring your inspiration – photos, pins, sketches, a grandmother’s ring – and we start mapping out what you love. No pressure. No sales scripts. Just a real conversation about what you want.

Step 2: The CAD design

Our in-house CAD designers build a precise digital model of your ring. You’ll receive rendered images so you can see the design from every angle before anything physical is made. We’ll go back and forth with you on the details until it’s exactly right.

Step 3: The 3D printed model

This is the step most people don’t expect (and the one they love the most.) We print a physical model of your ring so you can try it on. This is where it becomes real. You’ll see the proportions, and can make any final tweaks before we cast in in our on-site.

Step 4: Casting and finishing

Once you’ve approved the model, our jewelers will cast your ring right here in our Columbus-area studio. We set your diamonds or gemstones – whether that’s a stunning lab-grown diamond, a family heirloom stone, or a mined diamond of your choice – and finish every detail by hand.

Step 5: You pick it up and fall in love

Seriously. This part is our favorite. There’s nothing like watching someone see their finished ring for the first time!

How Long Does This Take?

Great question! The custom process typically takes 4–6 weeks from first consultation to finished ring, depending on the complexity of the design. Because we design, print, cast, and set everything in-house, with three CAD operators and four jewelers on staff, we can generally move much faster than chain stores that outsource their work.

Can I Use My Own Stones in a Custom Ring?

Yes! In fact, that’s one of the things we do best. We love repurposing family diamonds and gemstones into brand new custom pieces. Your grandmother’s diamond. Your mom’s sapphire. A stone from a ring you no longer wear. Our CAD technology lets us design the new piece to fit your exact stone perfectly, and the 3D model means you’ll see exactly how it’ll look before anything is touched.

And yes — you can even trade in old gold toward the cost of your new ring. It’s one of the ways we help couples get more ring for their budget.

What About Lab Grown Diamonds?

If you haven’t heard about lab grown diamonds yet, here’s the short version: they’re chemically, optically, and physically identical to mined diamonds plus they cost 80–90% less.

That price difference means many of our clients are able to go significantly bigger on the center stone than they originally planned. A 2-carat lab diamond that might have been out of reach with a mined stone is suddenly very possible. And with our 3D model process, you can see exactly how that stone size will look on your hand before you commit.

Curious about whether a lab diamond is right for you? We wrote about that here → Is a lab grown diamond a real diamond?

Why Columbus Couples Choose Scott’s for Custom Rings

Scott’s Custom Jewelers has been a Columbus-area institution for almost 100 years and we’re now in its fourth generation as a family business. Scott, his wife, Beth and their sons Jacob and Nicholas have combined old-school craftsmanship with some seriously impressive technology to create a process that most national chain stores simply can’t match.

Here’s what makes us different:

• Everything is done in-house. Design, 3D printing, casting, and setting – all in our Dublin, Ohio studio.
• No pressure, ever. Our team works together with your vision, not a sales quota.
• You see it before we make it. The 3D model step isn’t optional. It’s standard in our process.
• You can bring your own materials. Old gold, family stones, broken jewelry you no longer wear. It all can become something beautiful.
• We’re proud to support our community. When you purchase a lab grown diamond from us, Scott’s makes a donation to the Dublin Food Pantry of $100 per carat of diamond.
• We’re also sustainable in other ways. We only use purified, recycled gold in our castings. And we’re also earned accredited retailer status with SCS-007 Jewelry Sustainability Standard for our practices.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can You See Your Engagement Ring Before It’s Made?

Yes! Our 3D printed model is an exact physical replica of your design. You can put it on your finger, look at it in real life, and make changes all before we cast in metal.

Does seeing a 3D model cost extra?

Nope. It’s part of our standard custom design process. We believe you should never have to trust a sketch when you’re making a purchase this important.

How do I get started?

Easy. Book a free design consultation in person at our Dublin, Ohio studio or virtually from your couch. We’ll talk through your ideas, look at inspiration, and give you a realistic estimate. No obligation, no pressure.

What if I don’t know exactly what I want yet?

That’s honestly where we shine. Bring us a vague idea, a Pinterest board, or just a feeling. We’re great at helping people find their style, and the design process is collaborative the whole way through.

How long does it take to make a custom engagement ring in Columbus?

Most of our custom rings are completed in 4–6 weeks. Because everything is done in-house, we can often move faster than that depending on the design complexity.

Ready to See Your Ring Before It’s Made?

Come visit us at Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Dublin, Ohio — right in the Columbus area. Or if you’d rather start from home, we offer virtual consultations too.

Book your free design consultation here: Schedule your appointment

Bring your ideas. Your inspiration photos. Your grandmother’s ring. Your questions. We’ll take it from there. And we promise, you’ll leave knowing exactly what your ring will look like before we ever touch a piece of gold.

When you inherit a gemstone or an older piece of jewelry, you inherit a story. But often, that piece of jewelry doesn’t quite fit your life or your style. Maybe it’s too big, too small, too vintage, too worn, or not you.

Restyling heirloom jewelry allows you to keep the memories, update the style, and create something you’ll actually wear every day.

Explore your options anytime here:
https://scottscustomjewelers.com/restyling

Why Restyle Old Jewelry? (Some Background)

Heirloom gemstones and inherited jewelry often sits in drawers for years—not because they’re unloved, but because they’re just not wearable any longer. They may have broken prongs, or are missing a gem. But restyling old jewelry allows you to make something old, new again!

Restyling brings together the best of both worlds. You get to keep your family’s history, incorporate your style and even save some money.

So how can you can transform vintage pieces into fresh, new jewelry:

• Turn Grandma’s diamond into a modern pendant
• Take parts of a vintage ring and incorporate them into a new engagement ring
• Transform gemstones from an antique brooch into stackable bands
• Repurpose old jewelry into new heirlooms for the next generation

It’s sentimental, sustainable, and surprisingly budget-friendly.

How to Design Jewelry With a Family Gemstone

Designing custom jewelry with heirloom stones is smoother than most people expect—especially with Scott’s modern tools and personal guidance.

Step 1: Bring in the Gemstone

Loose gemstone? Old engagement ring? Broken diamond necklace? A tiny envelope you’re afraid to open? Bring it all!
We’ll evaluate the stones to ensure they’re strong, authentic, and safe to reset. Then we’ll get to work.

Step 2: Share Your Vision

Not a designer? No problem.
Just give us some ideas. Do you love modern solitaires? Vintage-inspired halos? Slim gold bands? We’ll help you translate that vision into something beautiful and wearable with the gemstones.

We’ll discuss:

• Metal color
• Setting style
• Band width
• Diamond or gemstone accents
• Everyday wear vs special occasion

Step 3: Create the Design

This is where your heirloom stone becomes your style. Using computer aided design (CAD), over 99 years of jewelry experience and modern technology like 3D printers, we’ll help you create a new design with your old jewelry.

We’ll send realistic CAD photos in different views for you to evaluate. We can even offer different color gold options. Here’s where you’ll get to make any changes and fine-tune the image.

This step alone sets custom stores apart. We design with you, not for you.

Step 4: Try on the 3D Printed Model

Before we craft your real piece in gold or platinum, we’ll create a precise resin model and even set the gemstones in place, for you to try on.

This is an important step. Here you’ll be able to adjust anything that doesn’t feel perfect.

Customers LOVE this part – it takes away all the scary guesswork!

Step 5: Casting Your New Jewelry

Our on-site, high tech jewelry department, with expert jewelers and goldsmiths will then set your family gemstone with precision and care.

Here we’ll cast the metal, set the gems, polish every detail, and bring your new design to life! It’s our favorite part.

The result?
A meaningful, modern heirloom you’ll treasure for decades.

Is Restyling Expensive? Not at Scott’s.

Here’s the secret big jewelry chains don’t advertise:
Custom restyling is often more affordable than buying a new piece.

Why?

• You’re repurposing gemstones you already own
• You can recycle your old gold towards the price of the new piece
• You’re not paying for big-brand marketing
• You can add super affordable lab grown diamonds to your piece at a substantial savings

We like to say “Custom doesn’t mean expensive. It means you get exactly what you want!”

Why Choose Scott’s Over a Mall Store or Online Jeweler?

Restyling heirloom jewelry is an art. It requires jewelry knowledge, technical ability, and vision.
Here’s why choosing a true custom jewelry store in Dublin like Scott’s Custom Jewelers over a mall or online store matters:

1. We Handle Your Family Gemstones With Care

Many mall jewelers or online retailers often won’t set heirloom stones because it’s risky and requires expertise. But at Scott’s we’ve made restyling jewelry our main focus and have safely reset thousands of family diamonds and gemstones.

Your gem isn’t “just another job”, it’s someone’s history and we honor it.

2. You Work Directly With Experienced Designers

At Scott’s, you work with actual jewelry experts who’ve seen it all and can design and craft your piece with care. We all work together as a team, problem solve and really listen to the customer’s wants and vision. And, since all the work is down in-house, there’s no middlemen. The person working with the customer is involved in every step of the process.

Just real jewelers who know how to work with older cuts, fragile stones, and sentimental pieces.

3. We Use Advanced CAD Technology

Here’s a secret. Most mall and chain stores send their jewelry design projects to third parties. And online stores make you choose from pre-set templates. It’s like playing the child’s game, telephone. The initial message is usually NOT what you hear at the end!

We design YOUR piece in-house, in real time, with:

• Custom CAD technology
• 3D printed resin models you can actually try on
• State-of-the-art jewelry tools
• 99 years of experience in custom jewelry design

4. Higher Quality Craftsmanship

We see it all of the time. Customers come in with broken jewelry because other store’s use lightweight settings, mass-produced parts, and outsourced labor.

Scott’s custom makes every setting to fit your gemstone securely and beautifully—because heirloom stones deserve better than mass production.

5. Personal Service You Can’t Get Online

No more guessing from photos or hoping the return policy is kind. At Scott’s, you’re working with real jewelers who treat your gemstone like family.

We guide you, listen to you, and make the process fun and stress-free.

6. Transparent Pricing—No Surprises

Online stores upsell.
Mall stores overcharge.

We give clear, honest pricing so you stay in control of your budget.

FAQ: Design Jewelry With a Family Gemstone

Can all gemstones be reset?

Most can. We’ll inspect your stone for chips or structural issues before resetting.

What if I want to add diamonds or gemstones?

Absolutely—you can enhance your family stone with new diamonds or gems no problem!

Can you reuse old gold?

Old gold can be traded in towards the price of the new piece. In fact, at Scott’s, we encourage our customers to clean out their jewelry box and recycle their old gold!

How long does the process take?

Usually 3–6 weeks, depending on complexity.

Do I have to know what I want?

Nope! Many customers start with zero ideas. We help every step of the way.

Ready to Restyle Something Meaningful?

Your family gemstone deserves to shine—not sit in a drawer.

Let’s bring it back to life together.
Schedule your custom jewelry appointment (in person or via ZOOM here:

Or stop into Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Dublin, Ohio for personal, friendly guidance and a design you’ll love forever.

That’s why the trend now is to choose a local jeweler in Dublin, Ohio for those pieces that celebrate love, family, and important milestones.

At our store, jewelry isn’t just our business – it’s our family legacy. As a 4th-generation jeweler, now working alongside two of our sons, (we have six kids!) we’ve seen firsthand how meaningful it is to build relationships that last longer than a single purchase.

But here are the real benefits of working with a local jeweler and why it makes all the difference for everyone.

Personalized Service You Won’t Find Online

When you walk into a local jewelry store, you’re not greeted by a script or, even worse, a bot.

Instead, you’re greeted by people who want to for connections and understand who the jewelry is for, what it represents and how you want it the person to feel when it’s worn. You know, personal stuff!

Whether you’re shopping for an engagement ring, an anniversary gift, or a piece “just because,” a good local jeweler will take the time to listen. That personal attention allows us to guide you toward pieces that truly fit your style, lifestyle, and budget. And more importantly, will make the wearer smile!

A Family Legacy Built on Trust

We’re proud to be a 4th-generation, family-owned jewelry store, and even prouder to have our two sons now working alongside us, learning the craft, the business, and the responsibility that comes with it. Grandpa would be so proud!

And multi-generational connection actually matters. It means:

• We stand behind every piece we sell
• Our reputation isn’t temporary—it’s decades in the making
• We’re here for the long haul, not just the transaction

When you choose a local jeweler with deep roots in the community, you’re working with people who plan to be here for your next milestone and hopefully even for your children’s milestones! How’s that for legacy

Expert Guidance From People Who Truly Know Jewelry

Local jewelers don’t just sell jewelry, they actually understand the science and history behind the gemstones, and can guide you towards the best options.

From natural and lab-grown diamonds to colored gemstones, metals, and settings, you have access to real expertise. We explain the differences clearly, help you compare options honestly, and make sure you feel confident—not confused—about all of your choices. And let’s face it, there are a LOT of options out there!

Plus, if you ever have questions down the road, you know exactly where to find us. Seriously, do you know how many times we see customers in the grocery store and are asked to “check this prong – it’s been snagging lately”.

Custom Design & Jewelry Repairs You Can Trust

One of the biggest advantages of working with a local jeweler is access to custom design and professional repair services. A quality store will have an on-site bench jeweler or goldsmith on staff to set gemstones and do jewelry repairs.

At Scott’s, we specialize in:

• Designing one-of-a-kind custom engagement rings with mined and lab grown diamonds
• Restyling inherited or outdated jewelry
• Combining family stones into new pieces
• Resizing, repairing, and restoring heirloom jewelry

Because jewelry often carries tons of sentimental value, it deserves skilled hands and careful attention to details. Things that don’t always happen when it’s shipped off to an big repair location like mall stores.

Better Value Through Honest Pricing

Online jewelry prices can look appealing – so many options! – but they don’t always tell the full story. And, what you see as a AI-generated image isn’t always what you get.

A good local jeweler helps you understand the difference in metal and gemstone quality. They’ll explain how you can save money without sacrificing beauty and quality. And, they can show you how to upgrade your existing piece, instead of buying something new.

Now, with options like lab-grown diamonds, custom CAD technology and 3D designs, local jewelry stores like Scott’s can help customers create something more meaningful, and more affordable, than mass-produced alternatives.

A Relationship That Lasts Beyond the Sale

That’s probably the best part of being a local jewelry store. The relationships! Most of our customers don’t just come in once. With almost 100 years of service, we’re seeing multiple generations of customers. And we are here for it!

There’s nothing better than hearing that a new couple came to us because their parents got their wedding bands from grandpa’s store.

That ongoing relationship is one of the greatest benefits of working with a local jeweler. We remember your story, your style, and the significance behind each piece.

Supporting Local Means Supporting Your Community

Another benefit when you shop local, is that your purchase stays local. Buying from a small business means that you are supporting:

• Skilled craftspeople in the area
• Local jobs and families
• A small business invested in the community

Choosing a local jewelry store helps preserve these services that big chains, with their out-of-state corporate offices, simply can’t replicate.

Frequently Asked Questions About Working With a Local Jeweler

Is working with a local jeweler more expensive?

Not at all! Local jewelers often offer competitive pricing, custom options, and better long-term value—especially when service and care are included.

Do local jewelers sell lab-grown diamonds?

Yes. Many jewelers offer both mined and lab-grown diamonds. And they can help you choose the right stone based on your values, budget, and design preferences.

Can a local jeweler create a custom engagement ring?

Some do. Custom engagement rings are one of the biggest advantages of working with a local jeweler and are often more affordable than expected. It’s just important to ask the question first.

What about repairs and resizing?

Many local jewelers offer in-house or trusted repair services, so your jewelry is handled with care and accountability. Again, ask the question before you leave your pieces, just to be sure.

Why choose a family-owned jeweler?

Because your jewelry is special and it deserves attention, honesty, and a jeweler who will still be here years from now.

Jewelry Is Personal—Your Jeweler Should Be Too

At its heart, jewelry is about connection – between people, generations, and special moments in time.

As a 4th-generation family jeweler, we take that responsibility seriously. Every ring, necklace, and redesign we create is done with the understanding that it may one day become part of someone else’s story.

So, if you’re looking for expertise, trust, and a truly personal experience, we’d love to welcome you into our store—and into our family tradition. Remember, custom jewelry doesn’t mean expensive. It just means you get exactly what you want!

So stop in (or make an appointment) and say hello, and let’s make something beautiful, together.

The best part? Custom isn’t expensive. In fact, with the popularity of lab grown diamond engagement rings in Columbus, Ohio, you can often design something one-of-a-kind, and high quality, at a cost similar to buying a mass-produced ring from a chain store.

Why choose a custom engagement ring in Columbus?

A custom engagement ring in Columbus, Ohio from Scott’s Custom Jewelers means you’re part of the design process from the very beginning. Isn’t that cool! Instead of picking out a mass produced style from a case of boring rings, you can:

• Work with a local jeweler face-to-face (or ZOOM to ZOOM)
• Choose the diamond shape, size, and quality that fits your budget
• Add meaningful touches like hidden gemstones or engraving

Learn more about our custom jewelry design process at Scott’s Custom Jewelers.

Are lab grown diamonds right for me?

Lab grown diamond engagement rings are quickly becoming one of the top choices for couples in Columbus. These diamonds have the same sparkle, durability, and brilliance as mined diamonds—but they cost up to 80% less.

That means you can afford a larger carat size or higher quality without breaking your budget. Plus, if sustainability matters to you, a lab created diamond engagement ring in Columbus, Ohio from Scott’s Custom Jewelers is one of the most ethical choices you can make.

Lab diamonds are exactly the same as diamonds mined from the earth optically, physically and chemically. And without special equipment, no one can tell the difference.

Learn more about lab grown diamonds.

Isn’t custom jewelry more expensive?

One of the most common questions couples ask is: “Is a custom engagement ring more expensive?” The answer is a huge no!

A custom engagement ring from Scott’s Custom Jewelers is often similar in cost to buying something pre-made. Custom jewelry just means you pay for only what you want, not extra features that you don’t like. And, because you’re not paying for national branding, you’re investing in craftsmanship and materials chosen specifically for you.

How long does the process take?

Designing a custom diamond engagement ring in Columbus at Scott’s usually takes 4–6 weeks. Some designs can be completed faster, depending on complexity. If you’re planning a holiday or special proposal, it’s always best to start the process early.

What if I don’t know what I want?

That’s the beauty of working with a local jeweler. You don’t need to know every detail before you begin. They’re the experts! Of course you can bring inspiration photos, Pinterest ideas, or even sketches, and Scott’s Custom Jewelers will help you turn them into a reality.

Meet in Person or Virtually

Whether you’re local or planning from afar, you have so many options when starting your custom design. You can schedule an in-person appointment at Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Columbus or meet with us virtually via Zoom consultation. Either way, you’ll get one-on-one guidance to create your perfect ring.

Schedule an appointment at Scott’s Custom Jewelers here.

Final Thoughts

If you’re searching for:

• Engagement rings Columbus Ohio jewelers
• Custom engagement rings with lab grown diamonds
• Affordable custom diamond engagement rings in Ohio

…then Scott’s Custom Jewelers is the smartest choice. It’s personal, meaningful, and surprisingly affordable.

Schedule your in-person or Zoom consultation at Scott’s Custom Jewelers today and let’s design your dream ring together.

Stud Earrings

A staple pair of studs can go with anything and there are SO many options! Studs come in all shapes and sizes and there is a pair to fit every style. Pearl studs are trending but have always been a classic!

A gold ball stud can match anything, and diamond studs are more affordable than ever with lab grown diamonds. Studs are the perfect earring for everyday and can be mixed and matched endlessly with everything in your jewelry wardrobe.

Hoop Earrings

When your studs aren’t the perfect fit, a classic hoop is a great option! Hoops are timeless staple because they can go with any look. Elevate jeans and a tee, or pair them with a little black dress. The options with hoops are endless in size and shape, even with stones and fun details to add personality.

Classic Chain Necklace

Chain necklaces are so flexible to style and can be worn with anything. Wear a chain by itself, or layer with other chains or a pendant to create a whole new look.

They come in so many styles and lengths that there truly is a chain for every occasion. Not a fan of the plain chain look? Try one with a fun detail like this pearl and paperclip style necklace!

Gemstone Pendants

A pendant is a great way to add a personal touch to your outfit. A pendant can add some sparkle with a gorgeous lab grown diamond, add a pop of color with a gemstone in your birthstone or favorite color, or can be a timeless classic like a strand of pearls. Pendants can also be a great way to restyle an old piece you no longer wear into something you can wear everyday.

A Bracelet With Some Bling!

A fun bracelet can add a touch of sparkle and bling to any look. Bracelets can dress up a casual outfit or even stack several together to create a fun, layered look. Simple chains, diamond tennis bracelets, or funky bangles – the options are endless.

How to Style Your Jewelry for Different Occasions

Jewelry can transform your outfit, making it suitable for various occasions. Here are some tips on how to style your essential pieces:

Styling Jewelry For Work

Opt for simple and elegant pieces like stud earrings, a classic chain necklace, and a minimalistic bracelet. These pieces add a touch of sophistication without being too flashy.

Styling Jewelry For a Night Out

Elevate your look with bold hoop earrings, a statement pendant, and a stack of sparkling bracelets. Don’t be afraid to mix and match different styles and textures.

Styling Jewelry For Casual Outings

Keep it chic yet casual with a pair of versatile hoops, a layered chain necklace, and a fun, colorful bracelet. These pieces add personality to your everyday look without overwhelming it.

Jewelry Care Tips

Taking care of your jewelry ensures it stays beautiful and lasts longer. Here are some tips:

#1 – Store You Jewelry Properly

Keep your jewelry in a cool, dry place. Use individual pouches or compartments to prevent pieces from scratching each other.

#2 – Avoid Chemicals

Remove your jewelry before applying lotions, perfumes, or engaging in activities that involve harsh chemicals.

#3 – Regularly Clean Your Jewelry

Clean your jewelry regularly to maintain its shine. Use appropriate cleaning methods based on the material and gemstones.

Ready To Design Your Next Jewelry Wardrobe Staple?

Finding staples that match your style is the first step in building your jewelry wardrobe. Like the LBD, signature jewelry pieces are essential for everyday wear, and always make great gifts. Find your new favorite pieces or design them yourself with us today.

While most jewelry gifts are filled with significance, such as the cross pendant your grandmother gave you for your First Communion or the opal ring gifted by your parents at graduation, an engagement ring is considered the biggest deal.

So how do you drop engagement ring hints to make sure your partner knows what style you want? We’ll help you out with that, hang tight.

Do Couples Pick Wedding Rings Together?

This is a common question that a lot of people have, and the answer is different for everyone. Long answer short, most do, or at least most start the process together, but many leave the final pick-up to the propose-er.

In fact, at Scott’s Custom Jewelers, we’re known to bend the truth a little by saying the custom engagement ring they’ve designed is taking more time than we originally thought, in order to throw off the bride and make the proposal a surprise. It’s all good though, the brides forgive us.

But, if you think your partner wants to pick out the ring on their own, we have ways to nonchalantly tell them what you want in an engagement ring.

The 4Cs Of Diamonds

First, it’s good to get some diamond education.

In the 1940s, Robert M. Shipley, the founder of GIA, Gemological Institute of America, used the term 4Cs to help his students remember the four main factors that characterize a diamond: Color, clarity, cut and carat weight. Today, the 4Cs apply to both mined diamonds and the new, lab grown diamonds.

• Color – The diamond color characteristic is based on the absence of color. A chemically pure and structurally perfect diamond has no hue, like a drop of pure water. GIA’s D-to-Z diamond color-grading system measures the degree of colorlessness of a stone.
• Clarity – Evaluating clarity means determining the number, size, nature, and position of both internal and external marks or blemishes in a diamond, as well as how these affect the overall appearance of the stone. If you are trying to determine what is the best clarity for a diamond, remember that no diamond is perfectly pure. But the closer it comes to purity, the better its clarity.
• Cut – We often think of a diamond’s cut as it’s shape (round, radiant, oval, marquise, pear), but what cut actually means is how well a diamond’s facets, or cuttings, interact with light. Precise cutting is required to fashion a stone so its proportions, symmetry and polish deliver the best return of light.
• Carat – A carat measures how much a diamond weighs. A metric “carat” is defined as 200 milligrams. Each carat is subdivided into 100 ‘points.’ This allows very precise measurements to the hundredth decimal place. A jeweler may describe the weight of a diamond below one carat by its ‘points’ alone. For instance, they may refer to a diamond that weighs 0.25 carats as a ‘twenty-five pointer.’ Diamond weights greater than one carat are expressed in carats and decimals. A 1.08 carat stone would be described as ‘one point oh eight carats.’

While the Cs are important, remember that a diamond’s beauty is very subjective. Everyone’s eyes are different, and while one person may be sensitive to a diamond’s color, another may be influenced by it’s clarity.

Grandpa used to say, “pick the diamond that winks at you,” and we still use that today!

Engagement Ring Hints

Dropping subtle hints about the perfect engagement ring can be difficult. We’re here to help you explore creative ways to make sure your dreams are heard, even if some ideas may feel a bit cheesy.

The Power Of Pinterest

Who doesn’t love a good Pinterest board? When you need to drop some engagement ring hints, making a Pinterest board really helps.

At Scott’s, not only do we create our own Pinterest boards for our customers, but we also tell our ring shoppers to peek at their partner’s board to see their style!

It’s great if you create a board with an obvious title, like ‘Engagement Ring Ideas.’ But if you don’t want to be too transparent, make sure the heading is easy to find, like ‘My Favorite Rings’ or ‘Someday…’

Window Shopping At Scott’s Custom Jewelers

Next time you go out, casually mention that you need to get your jewelry checked, then stop by Scott’s for a free cleaning. Make sure to call us prior for a heads up!

This is a perfect time to window shop the cool pieces we have in stock, or even peruse the thousands of custom engagement ring designs that scroll on our six big television screens. Be sure to point out your favorites – we’ll take the hint and make notes in your files!

You can even drool over the case of beautiful, lab grown diamonds that we have on hand and show them your favorite shape.

We’ll suggest getting your ring finger sized too while you’re there, just in case (wink wink).

Tag Them On Social Media Sites

Oh social media – you’ve got to love it! It’s a great way to give hints on what you’d like your future engagement ring to look like!

How? Try tagging your partner on celebrity engagement posts with comments like, ‘Wow, that’s a huge diamond! I would only want a 2 ct. size in that shape!’ Or maybe sharing an Instagram story when your best girlfriend gets engaged, saying, ‘I love her ring – yellow gold is my favorite, too!’

Email Or Text Funny Memes And Reels

There are so many hilarious reels of proposals that don’t quite hit the mark, or funny memes on engagement ring fails. Maybe send a couple to your partner with some well-placed comments like, ‘OMG – how embarrassing that the ring was too small when he proposed – BTW, I’m a size 6…’ or ‘I can’t believe she said she hated marquise-shaped diamonds! That is my absolute favorite shape!’

Maybe not subtle, but at least you won’t end up as a reel fail!

When All Else Fails, Hijack Their Phone!

Some say this isn’t true, but one time I said “I love cat toys, cat toys are the best. Where can I find cat toys?” with my phone in my pocket, and my ad feeds were FILLED WITH CAT TOYS! Also, I do not own a cat.

So, next time your loved one leaves their phone unattended, grab it and start talking ring styles. Repeating ‘yellow gold lab grown oval diamond with a hidden halo and pave diamonds on the sides’ over and over should bombard them with ads, and at the very least, get them thinking about the ring!

Successfully Get Your Dream Ring: Visit Our Dublin, OH Jewelry Store Today!

The more you delay, the less inspiration your partner has to work with! So stop by our jewelry store in Dublin, OH and show them the engagement ring styles you love.

What to consider when buying an engagement ring

So, how do you know what to consider when buying an engagement ring? No worries – we’ve helped thousands of couples design their perfect ring. And, we’ve even got ways for you to pull off a surprise engagement!

Guide to Buying Diamond Jewelry

First, we’ll ask some questions

So many choices!

• What shape of gemstone do you both like (we’ll show you examples)?
• Do you know her ring size?
• What color and kind of metal do you prefer?
• What type of gemstone do you want in the engagement ring?
• If you’re looking for a diamond, do you want a mined gemstone, or a lab grown diamond?

Buying an engagement ring is probably the only decision you’ll have/get to make, on your own, on your way to the altar! And many couples actually do come in together to design their custom engagement ring.

What should I expect when I come to Scott’s?

Scott and Beth will help you find the perfect engagement ring!

If you want to surprise your soon-to-be fiancé, this is what to expect when you come to design your perfect engagement ring at Scott’s.

First off, you don’t have to have all the answers when you come in. We don’t expect it! Mainly because you won’t even know the questions! But you WILL ace this test – promise!

We’ll ask questions like, what is she (or he) like? What does she usually wear? What does she do for a living? What kinds of jewelry does she wear now? Does she spend a lot of time on Pinterest – let’s look at her page!

We can usually get a good feel for the style of engagement ring she’ll want with a little digging.

Now for the details!

Now we’ll get to the specifics. Details like, do you have a family gemstone you want to incorporate into this design? Inherited diamonds not only save you money, but they add so much history and emotion into a custom engagement ring. Even re-purposing small diamonds from say, a diamond heart pendant that her grandmother gave to her when she turned 18, can be used in a custom design. Or maybe your own parents have jewelry that they want you to use in your new piece. All of that is possible at Scott’s.

Re-purposing diamonds add to a jewelry story, and saves you money!

Mined or lab grown diamonds?

So, what if you don’t have any diamonds to use. No problem! We’ll help guide you on your diamond choices too (we love them all – we’re not diamond snobs!)

Lab grown diamonds come in every shape and size. The only difference between a lab and a mined diamond is where they come from – and the price!

Do you want to use mined diamonds, or lab grown diamonds? Both are diamonds (the Federal Trade Commission backs this up Forbes.com), but depending upon your budget, a lab grown diamond can save you 20-50% over mined diamonds. Lab grown diamonds are also more ecologically sustainable than mined diamonds. Either way, we have them both!

Interested in learning more about lab grown diamonds and how they are the most sustainable (and stunning) option for your jewelry? Download the whitepaper!

Get The Whitepaper

Size matters

By using sample stones, we’ll show you the sizes and shapes of the diamonds for your engagement ring. We find that a visual is helpful. And we’ll also explain all those letters and numbers – VS, SI1, G-H – that describe diamonds. They can be confusing, but we can show you the differences.

Seeing is believing

After we figure out the center diamond, Scott’s will start searching for diamonds in your price range and with your specs, for you to see in person. We believe you need to see and compare gems to make the best decision.

Seeing is believing – you need to compare diamonds to make the best decision.

We’ll call our many diamond sources and bring in 3 to 4 gemstones. You can then see the differences and make a better determination of which stone, as Grandpa used to say, “winks at you.” And since we don’t own the stones, we aren’t trying to push a certain diamond on you, because we need to get rid of stock. That really makes a difference to your bottom line!

It’s the benefit of internet’s vast inventory, but with the guidance of a professional. Really – you won’t make a mistake this way!

Finding out her ring size

Once we have the style of the ring, and know what our main, center stone will be, we need that ring size!

Nothing is worse than dropping to your knee, romantically proposing to your beloved, then finding out the ring is too small! No matter what her size is, she’ll think she’s too big, and the moment is ruined.

So, if we don’t already know the ring size, we’ll help you be super sneaky, and get it from her. If you can’t bring in a ring that she wears on her engagement finger for us to size, we’ll have you slyly put one on your finger, and where it stops, we’ll have you take a picture, then we’ll size YOU.

We’ll take it from here

Now your work is done, and you’re on your way to a beautiful custom engagement ring that will definitely make her say, YES!

Want to learn more about buying an engagement ring at Scott’s? Call 614 336-4111 to schedule your appointment today.