10 Reset Engagement Ring Before & After You Have to See


Do you have an old diamond engagement ring you are holding on to, but never wear? Maybe it’s super sentimental but beyond repair, or simply just isn’t your style anymore? Don’t let it gather dust—check out these reset engagement ring before and after pictures for some inspo! 

Resetting a ring is the perfect way to bring those pieces out of the jewelry box and into something one-of-a-kind. We have seen a ton of restyles in 24 years, but here are 10 reset fine stone and diamond engagement ring before & afters that you just HAVE to see!

Emerald stick pin
Before – an emerald stick pin
Transformed into a custom emerald engagement ring reset before and after
After – a custom emerald engagement ring

1. A One-of-a-Kind Pendant

Before – a small diamond from mom’s engagement ring
Diamond from mom's engagement ring reset into tanzanite and diamond pendant before and after
After – a custom tanzanite and diamond pendant

The original diamond from mom’s engagement ring became part of a gorgeous, two-stone pendant. Adding a pop of color with tanzanite lets the heirloom diamond shine, especially in the sleek white gold setting. Now the stone and all it’s memories can live close to the heart!

2. A Restyled Rose Gold Wedding Band

Before – original diamonds from J.’s first wedding set
Restyled rose gold wedding band reset engagement ring before and after
After – a wider, more updated style.

J. brought in two rings that were wearing thin and needed a refresh, along with some other, small, additional diamonds. We came up with this wider wedding band featuring a delicate, open vine style center nestled between 14k white gold bands.

Using her larger center stone and side accents, we created something unique and strong enough for everyday wear. She loved it!

3. The Perfect Good Luck Charm

Before – a princess cut diamond
Princess cut diamond reset into a custom horseshoe ring before and after
After – a restyled good luck charm!

This princess cut diamond ring from a previous wedding ring had it’s lucky day as the center of this cool, custom horse shoe style ring! Setting fancy cut stones on their side like this princess cut diamond can give your ring a super modern feel, with only a simple change.

4. A Pear Shaped Diamond that Makes a Statement

Before – a pear shaped diamond beauty
Pear shaped diamond restyled into a custom wedding ring reset before and after
After – restyled into a stunning custom wedding ring

This pear shaped diamond took on a whole new life in this wedding ring upgrade! The wide band used accent diamonds from old, unworn jewelry in a split design that helps balance out the top.

Reusing an old piece of jewelry is a great way to repurpose earrings, random accent stones from a band, or stones from a pendant, creating a new jewelry story.

5. This Unique Take on a Three Stone Ring

Three-stone ring reset engagement ring with diamonds from mom and grandmothers before and after
After – diamonds from mom and both grandmothers make up this cool three-stone ring.

This three stone ring started as a few separate pieces from our customer’s family. The center stone from her mother, the top and bottom from both of her grandmothers.

S wanted to combine these diamonds into one piece, without leaning into the traditional three stone engagement ring style. By using a vertical layout, this ring goes from bridal and classic to a modern statement piece!

6. A Piece Combining Family History

Before – random jewelry that wasn’t worn any longer
Family history jewelry reset into a custom right-hand ring before and after
After – a beautiful, family history ring!

This ring came to life from multiple family pieces! We blended the diamonds from two old wedding rings and a few diamond earrings to create this one-of-kind, custom, right hand ring. Another great example of a seamless design made from a collection of heirloom pieces.

7. This Criss Cross Statement Ring

Before – we used small diamond accents from the band (the center diamond was used in another piece)
Crisscross diamond ring reset engagement ring design before and after
After – a cool, criss cross ring!

This cool, criss cross design is a true showstopper! The cascade design of this old ring was straight out of the 80’s, but the diamonds were still in great shape.

We pulled this ring back into the future with a more modern setting, and added a small round diamond that belonged to her grandmother. It turned out spectacular! As a bonus, the squared design of this ring keeps it from turning on her finger, too.

8. Tennis Bracelet Made Into A Pave Band

Broken tennis bracelet reset into a pave diamond wedding band before and after
Before & After – an outdated, broken tennis bracelet is transformed into a classic pave diamond band

This broken, outdated tennis bracelet gave us so many diamonds to work with that our options were truly endless. We made the switch from yellow to white gold and created a beautiful pave diamond wedding band from all those heirloom stones.

Plus, we recycled the old gold towards the price of the new piece. It was a win/win for everyone!

9. From an Unworn Ring to a Favorite Necklace

Before – a traditional wedding set
Traditional wedding ring reset into custom wedding necklace before and after
After – a new, wedding necklace

Rings not your style? They weren’t our customer’s style, either. She loved the three stone look of her wedding set, but felt like she never wore them (she works with her hands, and didn’t want them to get damaged).

So, we converted them to an amazing custom necklace that mimicked her rings with center stones and diamond accent stones, but that she could wear more comfortably. (Hint, this is a great way to wear your original bridal set after a well-deserved upgrade!)

10. Combining Old Jewelry to Create Something Special

Before – family jewels from a pin and necklace
Old stick pin and necklace reset into two-tone diamond statement ring before and after
After – a two-tone diamond statement ring

This necklace and stick pin wasn’t worn anymore, so we combined into something more in line with our customer’s style. Keeping the piece two-tone makes it super wearable too. Also: two tone jewelry is really trending this fall!

Don’t feel boxed in with jewelry design. Heirloom pieces can be anything with enough imagination.

Ready to Reset Your Original Engagement Ring Into Something You Love?

The moral of the story is that old jewelry doesn’t have to sit in a jewelry box anymore. With a little imagination, a reputable jeweler, and Scott’s cool custom design technology, old jewelry can be reset into new engagement rings, filled with history and personality!

We hope you were inspired with these 10 reset engagement ring before and afters that you just HAVE to see!

Want to see what you can do? Set up your custom appointment (in person or via ZOOM)!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Top