“I bought my engagement ring for my fiancé here and has a great experience. Beautiful ring. Very welcoming and kind staff. Scott sat down with me and talked through some designs and patiently described to me what I needed to know to make decisions. I knew nothing about jewelry going into this and he took the time to work with me.“
“I have taken several pieces of jewelry into Scotts Custom Jewelers to be re created into something new and exciting. Scotts team has knocked it out of the park on each and every piece we designed. Each piece has turned out absolutely STUNNING!!! I highly recommend Scotts Custom Jewelers and you will not be disappointed with their high quality work.“
“My fiancee and I were planning on visiting a few different local jewelers to find an engagement ring. But within a few minutes of going to Scott’s, we knew we had found the right place. Both Scott and Beth were very helpful in designing a ring that met our budget, and looked stunning. We weren’t too sure what we wanted, but they were very patient and explained everything. We’re extremely pleased with the ring, and couldn’t be happier. We also loved that they offered lab-grown diamonds.“
“I went into Scott’s Custom Jewelers unsure of what to expect but hoping to design the perfect ring for my fiancee. He took his time answering our questions and asking us key questions to find out exactly what it was we were looking for… before I knew it he had 3D designed the ring on his computer and a realistic rendering of what it was we wanted right there! He knows what he is doing and has been doing it for a long time. Do yourself a favor.. see Scott if you’re looking for a custom piece – you won’t regret it.“
“I couldn’t be happier going with Scott’s Custom Jewelers for an engagement ring. It is a small, family-run business that goes above and beyond in their customer service and quality of diamonds/settings to ensure you find the perfect ring. They really try to get to know you and make you feel a part of their family. I highly recommend them for any of your jewelry purchase or repair needs!”
“After walking into Scott’s Custom Jewelers, I knew that we were in the right store. Scott and Beth took wonderful care of my then-girlfriend (fiance now), and they made us feel like family. They not only took the time to get get to know us as customers but also as people. This, in turn, allowed Scott and Beth to better help me design the ring, with the perfect suggestion to round out customization. Thank you guys again for everything!“
“I wanted to thank you for the sensational job you did on my engagement ring makeover. The halo turned out better than I ever imagined. I have spent most of the weekend staring at it! My ring has always been special, but now holds so much more meaning. Thank you for being part of our story!”
“Scott took the time to go back and forth with me about what I thought I wanted and then figuring out what I really wanted and created the most perfect set. I could not be happier. THANK YOU. This ring is more than I could have dreamed of and I now can wear some heirloom stones everyday and not have them collect dust!”
A stunning oval shaped diamond surrounded with a custom halo of natural pink diamonds, and a thin, diamond band. The combination of soft, light pink and white is breath-taking! “She said yes! She is absolutely thrilled with the ring! She is in love with it! Thank y’all again so much!”
A simple oval shaped diamond bracelet in a custom bezel, is a perfect way to showcase this pretty stone. Best of all – this custom bangle can be sized to fit every wrist! “Had a great experience! I was really worried that it would not be what I wanted but it turned out better than I imagined!!! I love my new bracelet! Thank you Scott.”
“Wonderful experience! I am more than thrilled with my custom jewelry make-over. Scott’s Custom Jewelers went above and beyond with respect to the quality of work, the beauty of the design, and the incredible care given to me as they transformed an important family heirloom. Thank you so very much for preserving this piece of family history for me. I’ll be back!”
This custom cushion shaped diamond double halo ring is the perfect combination of classic and trendy. ” Thank you so much for helping us create the ring of our dreams! When M pulled out the ring and went down on his knee in the sand, I couldn’t even believe it was real!”
“Scott made my dreams come true!!!! I had a vision in my head for my custom engagement ring–he not only brought it to life, but exceeded my expectations by far! I was more than just a customer to them; they made me feel like family. I couldn’t have asked for a better experience during the happiest time in my life. I am so grateful for everything that they have done for me. Words truly cannot express my gratitude. Thank you again!”
A classic round diamond ring gets an update with a custom cushion shaped diamond halo and touches of rose gold.“Scott and Beth helped my husband and I redesign my wedding ring. They were so much fun to work with! They were professional, but yet we felt like family as we walked through the process with them. My ring turned out to be amazing!!”
“Oh Wow! This is amazing! I can’t believe how much the diamonds add the the pearl!”
Simply stunning! “Thank you guys so much for making such an amazing ring for K & I! We’ve recommended you to everyone! The “P” is my absolute favorite part”
A gorgeous chrome diopside, deep green and marquise shaped, needed a fabulous setting to show off it’s shape. We used diamonds from other pieces of jewelry L.A. wasn’t wearing anymore and made this abstract custom pendant. Best of all, by simply changing the chain to a black cord, the piece can be both dressy and casual!
“We appreciate your expertise, professionalism, service and most of all, friendship.”
“I was looking to get an engagement ring and I had never walked into a jewelry store before (as an adult at the very least). I tried the usual mall stores to get an idea, but I felt a more personable connection after a talk with Scott and Beth. After a few consultation appointments, a few cad designs, and plastic models, we finally got the right design. They were patient and the ring looked a lot better than the models. If you want a custom ring with a more personal experience, get yours here.”
The Dublin Arts Council helped design this unique custom pendant to auction off for their annual fundraiser. Using a peony topaz and diamonds, the piece contains an easel outline, and the initials of the organization!
“It was great working with you. Thanks so much for your support!”
“When I walk into Scott’s they know me and my husband by name. We talk like friends and they make us feel special regardless if we are there for cleaning or checking to make sure our jewelry is still in perfect condition. Today, I picked up my 4th new custom piece from Scott’s. I am a sucker for vintage and feminine style jewelry and most importantly custom.”
What started off as a standard diamond ring, set in a yellow gold mounting, was transformed into a new vine styled design with a custom beaded bezel top. Even better, all of the diamonds came from jewelry she wasn’t wearing!
“I love my beautiful ring! Thank you for creating it for me and for making me feel so special!”
“I had a pair of custom diamond earrings made for my wife for Christmas.
 The final product was outstanding;
 It was below the price quoted;
 It was delivered ahead of schedule
All of the people at Scott’s Custom Jewelers were very nice and helpful. Earring options were discussed as my wife can not wear pierced earring because of metal skin problems, they were very helpful and provided me many options. But most of all they are fair and trustworthy.
I highly recommend Scott’s; they are good jewelers and great people.“
“So far, I have gotten four custom pieces done from Scott. He always does exactly what I want (which is to say, the idea I ask for, but then taking into account his informative, helpful suggestions), and at a very reasonable, competitive price. Thanks again.”
“I consider Scott and Beth like family. They have designed jewelry for me and both of my daughters. They have even helped me from Columbus in picking out the perfect pair of earrings for my daughter’s graduation and shipped it to Tallmadge! Scotts is the most trusted and reliable jewelry store I have had the pleasure of doing business. Thank you so much for all our keepsakes!”
“It turned out exactly how I wanted it – and my fiance is thrilled!”
“I wanted an OH WOW ring that truly showed my style. This is it!”
“I don’t care for wearing rings, but do love necklaces. I took them a ring that I had been holding onto due to sentimental value and had the stones made into a pendant. This place is up front and honest about expectations and budget. After a few short weeks I was able to pick up my custom piece. Also got a stunning chain to wear with it. So happy I stumbled upon this place. Thank you all so much!”
Ready to make something beautiful at Scott’s?
We start every design with a conversation, pictures and a pencil. It’s an easy and fun way to find out what you like, what you want, and how much it will cost.
Not sure what you want? No sweat – we’ve got literally thousands of ideas we can show you!
Stop in and let’s create something beautiful, together!
– We’ll Help You Design Your Dream –
Scott Cevasco is a third generation, family jeweler.
6365 Perimeter Drive Dublin, OH 43016
Evening Appointments Available!