Here’s the good news: you can design new jewelry with a family gemstone, and it’s one of the most meaningful (and affordable) services we offer at Scott’s Custom Jewelers. In fact, it’s what we do best!
When you inherit a gemstone or an older piece of jewelry, you inherit a story. But often, that piece of jewelry doesn’t quite fit your life or your style. Maybe it’s too big, too small, too vintage, too worn, or not you.
Restyling heirloom jewelry allows you to keep the memories, update the style, and create something you’ll actually wear every day.
Explore your options anytime here:
👉 https://scottscustomjewelers.com/restyling
Why Restyle Old Jewelry? (Some Background)
Heirloom gemstones and inherited jewelry often sits in drawers for years—not because they’re unloved, but because they’re just not wearable any longer. They may have broken prongs, or are missing a gem. But restyling old jewelry allows you to make something old, new again!
Restyling brings together the best of both worlds. You get to keep your family’s history, incorporate your style and even save some money.
So how can you can transform vintage pieces into fresh, new jewelry:
- Turn Grandma’s diamond into a modern pendant
- Take parts of a vintage ring and incorporate them into a new engagement ring
- Transform gemstones from an antique brooch into stackable bands
- Repurpose old jewelry into new heirlooms for the next generation
It’s sentimental, sustainable, and surprisingly budget-friendly.
How to Design Jewelry With a Family Gemstone
Designing custom jewelry with heirloom stones is smoother than most people expect—especially with Scott’s modern tools and personal guidance.
Step 1: Bring in the Gemstone
Loose gemstone? Old engagement ring? Broken diamond necklace? A tiny envelope you’re afraid to open? Bring it all!
We’ll evaluate the stones to ensure they’re strong, authentic, and safe to reset. Then we’ll get to work.
Step 2: Share Your Vision
Not a designer? No problem.
Just give us some ideas. Do you love modern solitaires? Vintage-inspired halos? Slim gold bands? We’ll help you translate that vision into something beautiful and wearable with the gemstones.
We’ll discuss:
- Metal color
- Setting style
- Band width
- Diamond or gemstone accents
- Everyday wear vs special occasion
Step 3: Create the Design
This is where your heirloom stone becomes your style. Using computer aided design (CAD), over 99 years of jewelry experience and modern technology like 3D printers, we’ll help you create a new design with your old jewelry.
We’ll send realistic CAD photos in different views for you to evaluate. We can even offer different color gold options. Here’s where you’ll get to make any changes and fine-tune the image.
This step alone sets custom stores apart. We design with you, not for you.
Step 4: Try on the 3D Printed Model
Before we craft your real piece in gold or platinum, we’ll create a precise resin model and even set the gemstones in place, for you to try on.
This is an important step. Here you’ll be able to adjust anything that doesn’t feel perfect.
Customers LOVE this part – it takes away all the scary guesswork!
Step 5: Casting Your New Jewelry
Our on-site, high tech jewelry department, with expert jewelers and goldsmiths will then set your family gemstone with precision and care.
Here we’ll cast the metal, set the gems, polish every detail, and bring your new design to life! It’s our favorite part.
The result?
A meaningful, modern heirloom you’ll treasure for decades.
Is Restyling Expensive? Not at Scott’s.
Here’s the secret big jewelry chains don’t advertise:
Custom restyling is often more affordable than buying a new piece.
Why?
- You’re repurposing gemstones you already own
- You can recycle your old gold towards the price of the new piece
- You’re not paying for big-brand marketing
- You can add super affordable lab grown diamonds to your piece at a substantial savings
We like to say “Custom doesn’t mean expensive. It means you get exactly what you want!”
Why Choose Scott’s Over a Mall Store or Online Jeweler?
Restyling heirloom jewelry is an art. It requires jewelry knowledge, technical ability, and vision.
Here’s why choosing a true custom jewelry store in Dublin like Scott’s Custom Jewelers over a mall or online store matters:
1. We Handle Your Family Gemstones With Care
Many mall jewelers or online retailers often won’t set heirloom stones because it’s risky and requires expertise. But at Scott’s we’ve made restyling jewelry our main focus and have safely reset thousands of family diamonds and gemstones.
Your gem isn’t “just another job”, it’s someone’s history and we honor it.
2. You Work Directly With Experienced Designers
At Scott’s, you work with actual jewelry experts who’ve seen it all and can design and craft your piece with care. We all work together as a team, problem solve and really listen to the customer’s wants and vision. And, since all the work is down in-house, there’s no middlemen. The person working with the customer is involved in every step of the process.
Just real jewelers who know how to work with older cuts, fragile stones, and sentimental pieces.
3. We Use Advanced CAD Technology
Here’s a secret. Most mall and chain stores send their jewelry design projects to third parties. And online stores make you choose from pre-set templates. It’s like playing the child’s game, telephone. The initial message is usually NOT what you hear at the end!
We design YOUR piece in-house, in real time, with:
- Custom CAD technology
- 3D printed resin models you can actually try on
- State-of-the-art jewelry tools
- 99 years of experience in custom jewelry design
4. Higher Quality Craftsmanship
We see it all of the time. Customers come in with broken jewelry because other store’s use lightweight settings, mass-produced parts, and outsourced labor.
Scott’s custom makes every setting to fit your gemstone securely and beautifully—because heirloom stones deserve better than mass production.
5. Personal Service You Can’t Get Online
No more guessing from photos or hoping the return policy is kind. At Scott’s, you’re working with real jewelers who treat your gemstone like family.
We guide you, listen to you, and make the process fun and stress-free.
6. Transparent Pricing—No Surprises
Online stores upsell.
Mall stores overcharge.
We give clear, honest pricing so you stay in control of your budget.
FAQ: Design Jewelry With a Family Gemstone
Can all gemstones be reset?
Most can. We’ll inspect your stone for chips or structural issues before resetting.
What if I want to add diamonds or gemstones?
Absolutely—you can enhance your family stone with new diamonds or gems no problem!
Can you reuse old gold?
Old gold can be traded in towards the price of the new piece. In fact, at Scott’s, we encourage our customers to clean out their jewelry box and recycle their old gold!
How long does the process take?
Usually 3–6 weeks, depending on complexity.
Do I have to know what I want?
Nope! Many customers start with zero ideas. We help every step of the way.
Ready to Restyle Something Meaningful?
Your family gemstone deserves to shine—not sit in a drawer.
Let’s bring it back to life together.
Schedule your custom jewelry appointment (in person or via ZOOM here:
Or stop into Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Dublin, Ohio for personal, friendly guidance and a design you’ll love forever.