And at Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Columbus, Ohio? You can also try it on!

We know that designing a custom engagement ring from scratch can feel a little nerve-wracking. I mean, it’s one of the most sentimental pieces of jewelry you’ll ever buy, and the idea of not seeing it until it’s finished is enough to make anyone break out in a sweat. And that’s exactly why we built our whole custom design process around making sure you’re never left guessing.

What’s our secret? A 3D printed model of your ring. And it’s one of the coolest parts of what we do.

What Is a 3D Printed Engagement Ring Model?

Here’s how it works at Scott’s.

After our initial consultation, our CAD (computer-aided design) team will work up your ring design based on your ideas, photos, and inspiration and will send you hi-resolution photos of the piece using specialized jewelry design software.

Then, we take that digital design and print it. Literally. Our 3D printer creates a physical replica of your ring in a resin material that’s identical to the finished piece. We can even set the gemstones into place.

You get to hold it. Try it on. Look at it in the mirror. Show it to your best friend.

And if something’s not quite right – maybe the band feels a little too wide, or the setting sits a little higher than you’d like – we make those adjustments right then and there. At no extra charge.

Only when you’re completely in love with the model do we cast your ring in gold or platinum and set the real stones.

Why This Matters More Than You Might Think

“I’ve been looking online for weeks and I still can’t picture what I actually want.”

We hear this every.single.week. Shopping for a custom engagement ring is exciting, but it can also be overwhelming. Pinterest boards are full of gorgeous rings. Instagram reels show them from the most flattering angles. AI creates jewelry that isn’t physically possible (more on that in another post!) But none of that tells you how a ring will actually look on your hand, with your stone.

But a 3D printed model does.

And for couples who want to design their ring together, which is becoming more and more common, this step is everything. You’re not trusting a sketch. You’re holding the real thing. (Well, almost the real thing.)

The Full Custom Ring Process at Scott’s: Step by Step

If you’re new to the idea of designing a custom engagement ring, here’s a simple look at how our process works from start to finish:

Step 1: The design consultation

We start with a conversation. In person at our Dublin, Ohio studio, or virtually if that’s easier. You bring your inspiration – photos, pins, sketches, a grandmother’s ring – and we start mapping out what you love. No pressure. No sales scripts. Just a real conversation about what you want.

Step 2: The CAD design

Our in-house CAD designers build a precise digital model of your ring. You’ll receive rendered images so you can see the design from every angle before anything physical is made. We’ll go back and forth with you on the details until it’s exactly right.

Step 3: The 3D printed model

This is the step most people don’t expect (and the one they love the most.) We print a physical model of your ring so you can try it on. This is where it becomes real. You’ll see the proportions, and can make any final tweaks before we cast in in our on-site.

Step 4: Casting and finishing

Once you’ve approved the model, our jewelers will cast your ring right here in our Columbus-area studio. We set your diamonds or gemstones – whether that’s a stunning lab-grown diamond, a family heirloom stone, or a mined diamond of your choice – and finish every detail by hand.

Step 5: You pick it up and fall in love

Seriously. This part is our favorite. There’s nothing like watching someone see their finished ring for the first time!

How Long Does This Take?

Great question! The custom process typically takes 4–6 weeks from first consultation to finished ring, depending on the complexity of the design. Because we design, print, cast, and set everything in-house, with three CAD operators and four jewelers on staff, we can generally move much faster than chain stores that outsource their work.

Can I Use My Own Stones in a Custom Ring?

Yes! In fact, that’s one of the things we do best. We love repurposing family diamonds and gemstones into brand new custom pieces. Your grandmother’s diamond. Your mom’s sapphire. A stone from a ring you no longer wear. Our CAD technology lets us design the new piece to fit your exact stone perfectly, and the 3D model means you’ll see exactly how it’ll look before anything is touched.

And yes — you can even trade in old gold toward the cost of your new ring. It’s one of the ways we help couples get more ring for their budget.

What About Lab Grown Diamonds?

If you haven’t heard about lab grown diamonds yet, here’s the short version: they’re chemically, optically, and physically identical to mined diamonds plus they cost 80–90% less.

That price difference means many of our clients are able to go significantly bigger on the center stone than they originally planned. A 2-carat lab diamond that might have been out of reach with a mined stone is suddenly very possible. And with our 3D model process, you can see exactly how that stone size will look on your hand before you commit.

Curious about whether a lab diamond is right for you? We wrote about that here → Is a lab grown diamond a real diamond?

Why Columbus Couples Choose Scott’s for Custom Rings

Scott’s Custom Jewelers has been a Columbus-area institution for almost 100 years and we’re now in its fourth generation as a family business. Scott, his wife, Beth and their sons Jacob and Nicholas have combined old-school craftsmanship with some seriously impressive technology to create a process that most national chain stores simply can’t match.

Here’s what makes us different:

• Everything is done in-house. Design, 3D printing, casting, and setting – all in our Dublin, Ohio studio.
• No pressure, ever. Our team works together with your vision, not a sales quota.
• You see it before we make it. The 3D model step isn’t optional. It’s standard in our process.
• You can bring your own materials. Old gold, family stones, broken jewelry you no longer wear. It all can become something beautiful.
• We’re proud to support our community. When you purchase a lab grown diamond from us, Scott’s makes a donation to the Dublin Food Pantry of $100 per carat of diamond.
• We’re also sustainable in other ways. We only use purified, recycled gold in our castings. And we’re also earned accredited retailer status with SCS-007 Jewelry Sustainability Standard for our practices.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can You See Your Engagement Ring Before It’s Made?

Yes! Our 3D printed model is an exact physical replica of your design. You can put it on your finger, look at it in real life, and make changes all before we cast in metal.

Does seeing a 3D model cost extra?

Nope. It’s part of our standard custom design process. We believe you should never have to trust a sketch when you’re making a purchase this important.

How do I get started?

Easy. Book a free design consultation in person at our Dublin, Ohio studio or virtually from your couch. We’ll talk through your ideas, look at inspiration, and give you a realistic estimate. No obligation, no pressure.

What if I don’t know exactly what I want yet?

That’s honestly where we shine. Bring us a vague idea, a Pinterest board, or just a feeling. We’re great at helping people find their style, and the design process is collaborative the whole way through.

How long does it take to make a custom engagement ring in Columbus?

Most of our custom rings are completed in 4–6 weeks. Because everything is done in-house, we can often move faster than that depending on the design complexity.

Ready to See Your Ring Before It’s Made?

Come visit us at Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Dublin, Ohio — right in the Columbus area. Or if you’d rather start from home, we offer virtual consultations too.

Book your free design consultation here: Schedule your appointment

Bring your ideas. Your inspiration photos. Your grandmother’s ring. Your questions. We’ll take it from there. And we promise, you’ll leave knowing exactly what your ring will look like before we ever touch a piece of gold.

We’ve been answering this question for a long time. 99 years actually! Scott’s Custom Jewelers has been a family-owned shop since 1927 and now is in its fourth generation, so we’ve had this conversation with just about every kind of customer there is. Here’s how we explain it to our customers.

What Does the “K” Even Mean?

The “K” stands for karat, and it measures how much pure gold is actually in the piece. And to add a little more confusion into the jewelry mix, “C” means carat and pertains to the weight of the gemstone. Crazy, huh!

Pure gold is 24K, meaning 24 out of 24 parts are gold. But here’s the thing: pure gold is soft. Like, really soft. Think butter! It bends, scratches, and dents easily, which makes it pretty impractical for jewelry you wear every day. So jewelers mix it with other metals like copper, silver, zinc, or palladium to make it stronger, and to change it’s color from yellow to white, rose or even green. That’s where 10K, 14K, and 18K come in.

Here’s what that actually looks like:

• 10K gold = 41.7% pure gold
• 14K gold = 58.3% pure gold
• 18K gold = 75% pure gold

The rest is alloy metals. The more alloy, the more affordable the piece because it contains less gold. The more gold, the richer the color and the gentler it is on sensitive skin, but also the softer and pricier it gets.

These aren’t random ratios either. Gold karat mixtures are actually regulated by the Federal Trade Commission, and have to not only meet these standards, but be properly stamped as 10k, 14k or 18k.

10K Gold: The Workhorse

10K gold is the most budget-friendly. It’s the standard you’ll see at a lot of big box retailers and online stores because it keeps costs down without looking cheap, at least not at first glance.

**The good:**It’s also a great option if you want a bigger or heavier piece without spending a fortune.

**The not-so-good:** Because it has more alloy metals mixed in, 10K gold is more likely to cause skin reactions, especially if you have a nickel sensitivity. 10K can also be brittle. Depending on the alloys mixed in with the gold, 10K jewelry can crack or break more easily. It also tends to look slightly less warm and rich in color compared to 14K or 18K. Over time, it can tarnish a bit faster too.

**Best for:** People on a budget.

14K Gold: The Sweet Spot

This is the most popular karat in the US, and honestly, for good reason. 14K gold hits a balance that most people actually want: it’s durable enough for daily wear, it looks great, and it won’t break the bank the way 18K does.

**The good:** At 58.3% gold, 14K is strong enough to hold up for years of everyday wear without needing constant maintenance. It’s also less likely to cause skin irritation than 10K, though it still contains alloy metals.

**The not-so-good:** It still contains alloy metals, so if you have a serious nickel allergy, you’ll want to ask what the specific alloy mix is before buying.

**Best for:** Engagement rings, wedding bands, everyday rings, earrings, necklaces you wear daily. Basically, this is the go-to for most people.

18K Gold: The Luxurious One

18K gold has 75% pure gold in it, which gives it that deeper, richer yellow color you see in high-end jewelry, but again, 18K gold can also be white or rose color, not just yellow. It’s the standard in a lot of European countries and in fine jewelry design.

**The good:** The yellow color is stunning. It also has fewer alloy metals, which makes it a better choice for people with sensitive skin or metal allergies. If you’ve had reactions to other gold jewelry, 18K is worth trying. It’s also hypoallergenic in white gold and rose gold versions more often than lower karats.

**The not-so-good:** It scratches more easily than 10K or 14K because it’s softer. If you wear rings while doing dishes, cooking, or working out, you’ll notice wear faster. It’s also noticeably more expensive.

**Best for:** Special occasion pieces, earrings, necklaces that don’t take as much physical abuse as rings, and anyone with metal sensitivities. Also a great pick if a rich yellow color matters to you.

Fun fact: At Scott’s since we cast everything on site, if you love the rich yellow color of 18K gold, we offer a 14K “extra yellow” gold – the same durability of 14K gold, but with special alloys that look like 18K yellow gold. And priced like 14K too!

What About White Gold and Rose Gold?

The karat system works the same way across all gold colors. 14K white gold is still 58.3% gold, it’s just alloyed with white metals like palladium or silver and usually coated with rhodium for that bright white finish. 18K rose gold is 75% gold, alloyed with copper for that pink hue.

So when you’re comparing white or rose gold options, the karat choice still matters for the same reasons: durability, price, and skin sensitivity.

One More Thing: Gold Prices Are High Right Now. Here’s How to Use That to Your Advantage.

Gold prices have climbed significantly in recent months, and that does affect what you’ll pay for new jewelry. But here’s something a lot of people don’t think about: if you have old gold jewelry sitting in a drawer that you never wear, it has real value right now and you can put it toward something new.

At Scott’s, we accept old gold and recycle it. We sent it to a refiner who sends us purified gold that we use in casting it right here in our shop, on-site, into brand new pieces. That means the necklace your grandmother left you that isn’t your style, or the men’s ring from 20 years ago that doesn’t fit anymore, can become a completely new piece of jewelry that you’ll actually wear.

It’s a practical way to offset the cost of new gold without just eating the current market price. And honestly, there’s something kind of meaningful about it too. Old gold doesn’t disappear, it just becomes something new.

This also makes our process more sustainable than buying newly mined gold. We’ve been doing this since we started casting our own custom jewelry, and with where gold prices and environmental awareness both are right now, it’s worth knowing that’s an option.

If you’re curious what your old pieces might be worth toward something new, just bring them in. We’ll take a look.

Q: Is 14K or 18K gold better for an engagement ring?

A: It depends on the person’s lifestyle. 14K is better if they’re active, work with their hands, or are generally rough on jewelry. 18K is better if color richness and skin sensitivity are priorities, or if the ring won’t take a lot of physical abuse.

Q: Will 10K gold turn my finger green?

A: It can, especially if you have a sweat-prone skin type or a copper sensitivity. The higher the alloy content (like in 10K), the more likely a reaction. 18K is least likely to cause discoloration.

Q: Is 14K gold good quality?

A: Yes, absolutely. 14K is actually the most widely used karat in American fine jewelry. It’s not a “lesser” version of gold, it’s a practical, durable, beautiful choice that lasts for decades.

Q: Can I wear 14K gold in the shower?

A: Technically it won’t dissolve or immediately fall apart, but water, soap, and shampoo do dull gold over time and can weaken prong settings. Taking it off is the better habit.

Q: Why is 18K more expensive if it scratches easier?

A: Because the gold itself is worth more. You’re paying for a higher percentage of a precious metal. The trade-off is softness, but many people prefer 18K for pieces like earrings or pendants that don’t get as much friction.

Q: What karat gold is best if I have a nickel allergy?

A: 18K is your safest bet because there’s less room for alloy metals in the mix. But always ask the jeweler what specific alloys they use, because not all 18K gold is made the same way.

Q: Does higher karat gold last longer?

A: Higher karat gold is purer but softer, so it actually scratches and dents more easily. Lower karat gold (like 10K or 14K) lasts longer in terms of physical wear resistance because of the stronger alloy metals mixed in.

Q: Can I trade in old gold jewelry to put toward new pieces?

A: Yes, and with gold prices where they are right now, it’s actually a smart move. At Scott’s Custom Jewelers, you can trade in old gold towards the price of your new jewelry. It offsets the cost of your new piece and keeps old metal out of a drawer (or a landfill).

Q: Is recycled gold the same quality as newly mined gold?

A: Yes. Once gold is purified, it’s just gold. There’s no quality difference between recycled and newly mined gold at the same karat. The karat stamp tells you the gold content regardless of where the metal originated.

Q: How can I tell what karat my jewelry is?

A: Look for a stamp on the inside of rings or on the clasp of chains. Common stamps include 417 (10K), 585 (14K), and 750 (18K). These are the European hallmark equivalents. Not sure? Bring it in and we’ll tell you.

So Which One Should You Buy?

Here’s the honest answer: for most people buying everyday jewelry, 14K is the right call. It lasts, it looks great, it won’t eat your budget alive, and it works for the majority of skin types. If budget is a real concern and you want something durable, 10K does the job. If you have sensitive skin, love rich color, or you’re buying something that won’t take much physical wear, 18K is worth the splurge.

There’s no objectively “best” karat. It just depends on your life.

And if gold prices are making you hesitate, remember that old jewelry sitting in a box has real value right now. Scott’s Custom Jewelers has been casting jewelry from recycled, purified gold for generations. It’s one of the better-kept secrets in jewelry buying, and it’s worth a conversation before you write off a new piece as out of reach.

Have a question about gold jewelry we didn’t cover? Drop it in the comments below, stop by the shop or schedule a meeting (in person or Zoom) at the link below.

These pieces are there not because they don’t matter anymore, but because maybe the style doesn’t fit who you lifestyle now, or because wearing them would feel strange, or because the setting is damaged and you’re not sure what to do. But they do hold memories, and Scott’s mom (a 2nd generation jeweler) always said, jewelry not worn is being wasted!

What most people don’t know is that those pieces can become something entirely new again. Something you’d actually wear every single day. Something that carries the original meaning forward into a design that feels like yours. We’re Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Dublin, Ohio, and jewelry redesign and restyling is one of the things we do best. Here’s everything you need to know about how the process works, what it costs, and why we think it’s one of the most meaningful things you can do.

What to Do With Inherited Jewelry You Don’t Like the Look Of

Let’s start with the most common scenario: you’ve inherited a ring or piece of jewelry that has real sentimental value but a style you wouldn’t choose for yourself. Maybe it’s a yellow gold setting with a big ornate design that feels dated. Maybe the stone is beautiful but the ring is too fragile for daily wear. Maybe it belonged to a relative you loved, and the thought of selling it or letting it sit in a box feels wrong.

The answer in almost every case is jewelry redesign. The gemstones, especially diamonds, are almost always in excellent condition and can be reused in a completely new design. The gold can be traded in and repurposed toward your new piece. What was once a 1970s yellow gold cocktail ring can be reimagined into a modern diamond wedding band, or a delicate halo pendant or a fun stacking ring you layer with others.

The original piece doesn’t disappear. The memory doesn’t get erased. It transforms. Redesign Inherited Jewelry You Don’t Wear.

Can I Use My Grandmother’s Diamond in a New Ring?

Absolutely! This is actually one of the main reasons we started our store, Scott’s Custom Jewelers. Reusing and repurposing diamonds and gemstones from inherited or unwanted jewelry is something we built our process around as a nearly 100 year old family business.

“We can make the new piece of custom jewelry to fit your own gemstones perfectly. Plus, you can see a 3D model of the piece BEFORE we cast it into gold or platinum, and make sure you love it.” — Scott’s Custom Jewelers

This is one of the most sustainable approaches to fine jewelry. You’re not discarding a stone that took nature (or someone you loved) a long time to produce. You’re giving it a new life in a form you’ll actually cherish.

The Part Nobody Tells You About: You Can See It Before We Make It

Here’s what sets Scott’s redesign process apart from most custom jewelry stores in the Columbus area, and honestly, from most jewelers anywhere: you get to see and actually try on a physical model of your new design before it’s actually cast into metal and stones are set.

Here’s how it works:

Step 1: The consultation

We start with a conversation. You bring in the jewelry you want to redesign, along with any inspiration images, Pinterest boards, or even just a general sense of what you like. Our design team will walk you through possibilities, talk through what stones and metals can be reused, and give you a price estimate.

We offer these consultations in person at our Dublin, Ohio store, or virtually — whichever works best for you. Oh, and there’s no charge for the initial consultation!

Step 2: CAD design

Once we understand your vision, our designers use CAD (computer-aided design) to create detailed pictures of your new piece. You’ll see images from multiple angles — not a sketch, but a photo-realistic digital rendering. Then, we can make adjustments and refine the design until it’s exactly right. Changes at this stage cost nothing extra.

Step 3: The 3D printed try-on model

This is the step most people don’t expect. Before we cast a single gram of gold or platinum, we 3D print an exact physical replica of your new piece. You can hold it, try it on, see how it fits and decide whether you want any final adjustments.

We love this part because it eliminates the anxiety most people feel about custom jewelry. You’re not committing to something you’ve only seen on a screen. You’re committing to something you’ve physically tried on.

Step 4: Casting and hand-finishing

After you’ve approved the 3D model, we cast your piece right here in our Dublin, Ohio shop. Every piece is finished by hand, which means the final product has the kind of attention to detail you don’t get from chain stores or online-only jewelers. Timeline is typically four to six weeks depending on complexity (often faster) because everything happens in-house, not sent out to be completed.

How Do I Recycle Old Gold Jewelry Toward a New Design?

Your old gold still has value, and at Scott’s, we apply that value directly toward the cost of your new piece. Bring in all your broken chains, old rings, outdated pieces you’ll never wear again, or even gold from the piece you’re redesigning. We send it to a refiner and will give you credit towards your new piece. It’s very sustainable!

In fact, we’ve only used recycled gold in all of our casting process – we’ve never purchased newly mined gold to melt! So when you bring us your old jewelry, it genuinely reduces both your cost and the environmental footprint of your new piece. The same applies to gemstones. Diamonds, sapphires, rubies, emeralds – if your existing stones are in good shape, they go directly into your new design. You’re not paying for new gems you don’t need. Talk about eco-friendly!

What Kinds of Jewelry Can Be Redesigned?

That’s the beauty of custom jewelry – we can make just about anything! The most common redesign requests we handle at Scott’s are:

• Inherited engagement rings or wedding bands can be reset into a new style, converted into a pendant or earrings, or combined with other family stones
• Old yellow gold jewelry credited towards platinum, white or rose gold
• Brooches and pins may have stones that can translate beautifully into rings or pendants
• Post-divorce ring redesigns – repurposing a stone and gold from a ring that carries complicated meaning into something that marks a new chapter, like a mother’s ring or pendant
• Anniversary upgrades – taking a first engagement ring and redesigning it for a milestone anniversary with added diamonds or replacing it with a bigger, lab grown diamond and using the original stone in a special pendant, worn close to the heart
• Multi-piece family heirlooms combined into one new piece with stones or metal from several relatives woven into a single meaningful design

How Much Does It Cost to Redesign Inherited Jewelry You Don’t Wear?

This is the question we get most often, and the honest answer is: it varies, but it’s usually much expensive than people expect, especially when you factor in recycled metal and existing stones. At Scott’s, we can give a good estimate of the final cost, before we begin, so there are no surprises. Plus there’s no high designer brand price. And best of all, you’ll create a high quality, gorgeous piece of jewelry, filled with memories! What’s better than that!

Custom jewelry doesn’t mean expensive — it means you get exactly what you want, without paying for features you don’t need. When you bring your own diamonds and gold, the savings can be substantial.

Why Dublin, Ohio Couples Come to Scott’s for Jewelry Redesign

Well for one, we’re not a chain store. We don’t send your jewelry out of state for weeks. We have an actual workshop in our Dublin, Ohio location — with laser welders, 3D printers, goldsmiths, and CAD designers all working under the same roof. That means faster turnaround, direct communication, and work done by people who care about the outcome.

Scott has been doing this for over 25 years using CAD technology. His sons Jacob and Nicholas are now part of the team, representing the fourth generation of family jewelers. When you bring us something precious, you’re handing it to people who genuinely understand what it means. We’ve helped families all over the Columbus area — and across the country through our virtual consultation service — transform jewelry that was sitting in a box into pieces they reach for every single day. The before-and-after transformations we’ve done are some of our best work, and we’re proud of every one of them.

Ready to find out what your inherited jewelry could become? Bring it in to our Dublin, Ohio store or schedule a free virtual consultation. We’d love to show you what’s possible. Schedule an appointment online or call 614-336-4111.

And not just okay, it’s actually one of the most meaningful things many of our clients do.

Here at Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Columbus, Ohio, we’ve helped generations of couples redesign, refresh, and restyle their rings. I mean, we’ve been in the “love business” now for close to 100 years! And almost every time someone asks this question, it comes with a little guilt.

“I still love my ring… I just want to update it.”
“It feels sentimental… but it doesn’t really fit my style anymore.”
“Is it wrong to change it?”

The answer is simple: your ring is a symbol of your life together — and your life grows and changes. Your ring can too. We always say, styles change, gold wears away and fingers change. What was perfect years ago now can use a little update!

Why People Upgrade Their Wedding Rings?

There’s no single “right” reason. Some of the most common ones we hear in our Columbus showroom:

• An anniversary or milestone (10, 20, 25 years together)
• A change in style
• A ring that no longer fits (it happens to all of us!)
• Wanting to incorporate family diamonds or gemstones into the ring
• Or simply… “I’m ready for a refresh”

Your marriage didn’t stop growing on your wedding day. Neither did you.

Does Upgrading Your Ring Mean You Didn’t Love the Original?

Oh my gosh, not at all! In fact, we see upgrades as the opposite.

Your original ring represents where your story started.
Your updated ring represents how far you’ve come.

Many of our clients keep their original stones and build around them, preserving the sentiment while improving the look, comfort, or style.

Easy (and Affordable) Ways to Upgrade Your Wedding Ring

So now that that’s settled, what’s the next steps? Upgrading doesn’t have to mean starting over — and it definitely doesn’t have to mean breaking the bank.

Here are some of our favorite ways to refresh a ring.

Add a Diamond Halo

One of our favorites! A halo can make your center diamond look bigger or even change the shape of the original stone. Halos also add tons of sparkle and can completely transforms the look without replacing your main stone.

Depending upon the structure of the original wedding ring, adding a halo is one of the most cost-effective visual upgrades we do.

Add Stacking Rings or Anniversary Bands

We love a good stack! Adding stacking rings is a trendy, sentimental way to tell your life’s story. Plus, you can add one at a time over the years, making it an affordable option.

Stacking bands are perfect for commemorating significant milestones in your life. Anniversaries, birthdays, big milestones, even a ring to represent a child – your wedding stack can make your original ring feel brand new again.

Upgrade the Center Stone (Hello, Lab Diamonds!)

With today’s affordable lab grown diamonds, upgrading your center stone is more accessible than ever.

Adding a new lab diamond center stone let’s you go bigger or change the shape of your wedding ring at a bargain because they are 80-90% less than natural diamonds!

Lab grown diamonds are real diamonds, and they’ve opened the door for so many clients to finally get the ring they’ve always dreamed of. So many of our customers have upgraded their rings with bigger, higher quality lab diamonds, then set their original stone into a pendant, that they can wear close to their hearts.

(We explain lab diamonds more here → Is a lab grown diamond a real diamond?

Use Family Diamonds or Gemstones

One of our favorite things to do at Scott’s is blend generations together. Adding a family stone to your wedding ring – maybe in a trendy Toi et Moi or Three-Stone design – is so meaningful!

Suddenly, your ring isn’t just jewelry — it’s a family story you can wear every day.

Why Winter Is the Perfect Time to Upgrade or Restyle Your Ring

After the holidays, we see an upturn in wedding ring restyling at our store. Winter is rough in Columbus, Ohio, but it’s our favorite season for ring redesigns — and here’s why:

• You’re indoors more, scrolling reels and Pinterest
• You’re thinking about fresh starts and spring cleaning
• Jewelry tends to come out of the drawer this time of year
• And there’s less rush than during engagement season

We like to call it “Spring cleaning your jewelry box… before spring even gets here.”

It’s the perfect time to bring in your old pieces, remove the stones and recycle that gold (another cost saving move) and turn forgotten jewelry into something you’ll love again.

Is It Expensive to Redesign a Wedding Ring?

It doesn’t have to be. Redesigning your wedding ring lets you reuse your gold and stones, so you preserve the memories. And, with sustainable, affordable lab diamond options, we can design around your budget.

Most people are surprised by how affordable restyling can be compared to buying something brand new.

Our Philosophy at Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Columbus, Ohio

My mom, who worked in the family business with my dad, used to say, it was sinful for jewelry to sit in a drawer. Wear it! And we couldn’t agree more.

We believe jewelry should be worn, adored, and fit the life you’re living now.

And after four generations in the jewelry business, we can tell you — some of the most emotional, meaningful pieces we create are upgraded and redesigned rings.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it okay to change my wedding ring?

Absolutely. Many couples upgrade or redesign their rings to celebrate milestones or match their current style.

Should I keep my original diamond?

If you love it — yes! We often design around original stones to preserve the sentiment.

Can I upgrade my ring on a budget?

Yes. Using lab diamonds, halos, stacking bands, or your existing materials keeps costs very reasonable.

Can you use my old or family jewelry?

We specialize in that. It’s one of our favorite parts of custom design.

Thinking About Upgrading Your Wedding Ring in Columbus?

Whether you want a simple refresh, a bigger center stone, a more modern look, or a meaningful family redesign., we can help.

Make your appointment (in person or virtual) here:

Or stop into Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Columbus, Ohio and let’s take a look at what you have, and what it could become.

When you inherit a gemstone or an older piece of jewelry, you inherit a story. But often, that piece of jewelry doesn’t quite fit your life or your style. Maybe it’s too big, too small, too vintage, too worn, or not you.

Restyling heirloom jewelry allows you to keep the memories, update the style, and create something you’ll actually wear every day.

Explore your options anytime here:
https://scottscustomjewelers.com/restyling

Why Restyle Old Jewelry? (Some Background)

Heirloom gemstones and inherited jewelry often sits in drawers for years—not because they’re unloved, but because they’re just not wearable any longer. They may have broken prongs, or are missing a gem. But restyling old jewelry allows you to make something old, new again!

Restyling brings together the best of both worlds. You get to keep your family’s history, incorporate your style and even save some money.

So how can you can transform vintage pieces into fresh, new jewelry:

• Turn Grandma’s diamond into a modern pendant
• Take parts of a vintage ring and incorporate them into a new engagement ring
• Transform gemstones from an antique brooch into stackable bands
• Repurpose old jewelry into new heirlooms for the next generation

It’s sentimental, sustainable, and surprisingly budget-friendly.

How to Design Jewelry With a Family Gemstone

Designing custom jewelry with heirloom stones is smoother than most people expect—especially with Scott’s modern tools and personal guidance.

Step 1: Bring in the Gemstone

Loose gemstone? Old engagement ring? Broken diamond necklace? A tiny envelope you’re afraid to open? Bring it all!
We’ll evaluate the stones to ensure they’re strong, authentic, and safe to reset. Then we’ll get to work.

Step 2: Share Your Vision

Not a designer? No problem.
Just give us some ideas. Do you love modern solitaires? Vintage-inspired halos? Slim gold bands? We’ll help you translate that vision into something beautiful and wearable with the gemstones.

We’ll discuss:

• Metal color
• Setting style
• Band width
• Diamond or gemstone accents
• Everyday wear vs special occasion

Step 3: Create the Design

This is where your heirloom stone becomes your style. Using computer aided design (CAD), over 99 years of jewelry experience and modern technology like 3D printers, we’ll help you create a new design with your old jewelry.

We’ll send realistic CAD photos in different views for you to evaluate. We can even offer different color gold options. Here’s where you’ll get to make any changes and fine-tune the image.

This step alone sets custom stores apart. We design with you, not for you.

Step 4: Try on the 3D Printed Model

Before we craft your real piece in gold or platinum, we’ll create a precise resin model and even set the gemstones in place, for you to try on.

This is an important step. Here you’ll be able to adjust anything that doesn’t feel perfect.

Customers LOVE this part – it takes away all the scary guesswork!

Step 5: Casting Your New Jewelry

Our on-site, high tech jewelry department, with expert jewelers and goldsmiths will then set your family gemstone with precision and care.

Here we’ll cast the metal, set the gems, polish every detail, and bring your new design to life! It’s our favorite part.

The result?
A meaningful, modern heirloom you’ll treasure for decades.

Is Restyling Expensive? Not at Scott’s.

Here’s the secret big jewelry chains don’t advertise:
Custom restyling is often more affordable than buying a new piece.

Why?

• You’re repurposing gemstones you already own
• You can recycle your old gold towards the price of the new piece
• You’re not paying for big-brand marketing
• You can add super affordable lab grown diamonds to your piece at a substantial savings

We like to say “Custom doesn’t mean expensive. It means you get exactly what you want!”

Why Choose Scott’s Over a Mall Store or Online Jeweler?

Restyling heirloom jewelry is an art. It requires jewelry knowledge, technical ability, and vision.
Here’s why choosing a true custom jewelry store in Dublin like Scott’s Custom Jewelers over a mall or online store matters:

1. We Handle Your Family Gemstones With Care

Many mall jewelers or online retailers often won’t set heirloom stones because it’s risky and requires expertise. But at Scott’s we’ve made restyling jewelry our main focus and have safely reset thousands of family diamonds and gemstones.

Your gem isn’t “just another job”, it’s someone’s history and we honor it.

2. You Work Directly With Experienced Designers

At Scott’s, you work with actual jewelry experts who’ve seen it all and can design and craft your piece with care. We all work together as a team, problem solve and really listen to the customer’s wants and vision. And, since all the work is down in-house, there’s no middlemen. The person working with the customer is involved in every step of the process.

Just real jewelers who know how to work with older cuts, fragile stones, and sentimental pieces.

3. We Use Advanced CAD Technology

Here’s a secret. Most mall and chain stores send their jewelry design projects to third parties. And online stores make you choose from pre-set templates. It’s like playing the child’s game, telephone. The initial message is usually NOT what you hear at the end!

We design YOUR piece in-house, in real time, with:

• Custom CAD technology
• 3D printed resin models you can actually try on
• State-of-the-art jewelry tools
• 99 years of experience in custom jewelry design

4. Higher Quality Craftsmanship

We see it all of the time. Customers come in with broken jewelry because other store’s use lightweight settings, mass-produced parts, and outsourced labor.

Scott’s custom makes every setting to fit your gemstone securely and beautifully—because heirloom stones deserve better than mass production.

5. Personal Service You Can’t Get Online

No more guessing from photos or hoping the return policy is kind. At Scott’s, you’re working with real jewelers who treat your gemstone like family.

We guide you, listen to you, and make the process fun and stress-free.

6. Transparent Pricing—No Surprises

Online stores upsell.
Mall stores overcharge.

We give clear, honest pricing so you stay in control of your budget.

FAQ: Design Jewelry With a Family Gemstone

Can all gemstones be reset?

Most can. We’ll inspect your stone for chips or structural issues before resetting.

What if I want to add diamonds or gemstones?

Absolutely—you can enhance your family stone with new diamonds or gems no problem!

Can you reuse old gold?

Old gold can be traded in towards the price of the new piece. In fact, at Scott’s, we encourage our customers to clean out their jewelry box and recycle their old gold!

How long does the process take?

Usually 3–6 weeks, depending on complexity.

Do I have to know what I want?

Nope! Many customers start with zero ideas. We help every step of the way.

Ready to Restyle Something Meaningful?

Your family gemstone deserves to shine—not sit in a drawer.

Let’s bring it back to life together.
Schedule your custom jewelry appointment (in person or via ZOOM here:

Or stop into Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Dublin, Ohio for personal, friendly guidance and a design you’ll love forever.

At Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Dublin, Ohio, we actually specialize in custom jewelry made just for you. As a 4th generation jeweler, we’ve perfected the design process and have created thousands of heirloom-quality pieces over the past 25 years. We use CAD technology and 3D printers (we currently have 3!), to design each piece, then cast them into gold or platinum and set the stones, all on-site in our store.

With custom jewelry, every design starts with your input and ideas, and ends with a sparkle that’s completely your own. Here’s what to expect — and how long it really takes — to bring your custom ring to life.

Step 1: The Design Consultation (1-2 weeks)

Your custom ring journey begins with a design appointment. We’ll sit down with you (in person or virtually via ZOOM) to talk about your ideas, budget, and inspiration. This is where the fun begins! Bring all the photos, sketches, Pinterest boards, and any sentimental piece of jewelry you’d like to reuse — like grandma’s diamonds or an old engagement setting.

This is also a great time to go through that jewelry box and recycle all those mismatched earrings, broken chains and out-of-style pieces you don’t wear anymore. We’ll remove any stones for you, recycle the gold, then credit you that amount off your new jewelry.

From there, we’ll create sketches or CAD renderings so you can see exactly how your design will look from multiple angles, before it’s made. We can also easily give you options of on metal color or added design features.

Average time: 1–2 weeks, depending on revisions and design complexity.

Step 2: Final Design Approval (about 1 week)

Once you’ve reviewed your renderings, we’ll make any small tweaks before production begins. Most clients approve their design within a few days, but we always allow about a week to make sure it’s perfect.

Step 3: Crafting Your Custom Ring (3–6 weeks)

Here’s where our jewelers bring your vision to life. Your ring is cast, set, and polished by hand with care and precision.

• Classic solitaire or simple settings: 2–4 weeks
• Detailed or heirloom remount designs: 4–6 weeks

Each ring is crafted from the finest materials — whether you choose a brilliant lab diamond, family gemstones, or both.

Step 4: The Big Reveal

Your finished ring is carefully inspected, cleaned, and presented beautifully — ready for that unforgettable moment.

Total Timeline: 4–6 Weeks

So how long does it take to design a custom ring? From consultation to completion, most custom rings take around 4–6 weeks. If you’re planning a proposal or a holiday gift, it’s best to start your design at least two months ahead so it’s ready to sparkle when you are.

Custom Ring Design Q&A

Q: Can you make a custom ring faster if I’m on a deadline?
A: Often, yes! Simple designs and lab diamond solitaires can sometimes be completed more quickly. Let us know your timing, and we’ll do everything we can to meet your deadline.

Q: Can I use my own stones or gold in the design?
A: Absolutely. We love repurposing family stones or sentimental metals — it adds even more meaning to your new piece.

Q: Do I need a clear idea before scheduling a consultation?
A: Not at all! Bring your inspiration (even just a Pinterest board), and we’ll guide you through styles, stones, and settings that fit your personality and budget.

Q: How much does a custom ring cost?
A: With lab diamonds, you can get a stunning, custom-designed ring for far less than you might expect. Every design is quoted individually, and we’re happy to work within your comfort range.

Q: Is it too late to start a ring for Christmas or the holidays?
A: If you’re reading this — start now! Our holiday custom schedule fills up quickly, and beginning early ensures your piece will be ready to gift or propose with this season.

Ready to Start Your Custom Ring Design?

There’s nothing more special than jewelry designed just for you. Whether it’s a lab diamond engagement ring, an upgraded wedding set, or a one-of-a-kind heirloom redesign, we’ll make the process simple, personal, and fun.

Start your holiday custom design now — appointments fill fast!

Schedule Your Custom Design Appointment at Scott’s Custom Jewelers
Serving Ohio with beautiful, affordable custom jewelry since from our family since 1927.

At our Dublin custom jewelry store, we love helping people restyle their cherished pieces into something that feels just right for who they are now. Here are some creative and timeless ways to turn your wedding ring into a necklace you’ll treasure forever!

What Is a Pendant?

A pendant is a small ornament or piece of jewelry that hangs from a chain worn around the neck. Pendants come in countless shapes and styles, from simple solitaire gemstones to intricate designs with personal meaning.

They’re often used to showcase a centerpiece—like a diamond from a wedding ring in Dublin—and can be completely customized to reflect your story.

6 Ways to Turn a Wedding Ring Into Pendants

Whether you’re honoring a memory, symbolizing a new chapter, or just ready for a fresh take on a beloved piece, there’s a style that will speak to you.

From keeping the original band intact to completely turning it into something new, here are six beautiful and creative ways to turn a wedding ring into a pendant you’ll be proud to wear.

#1. Classic Solitaire Pendant

If your ring has just a center stone (like a diamond or sapphire), a custom jeweler can carefully remove it and set it in a new, solitaire pendant.

A bezel or prong setting keeps the look clean, elegant, and wearable every day. Add a delicate chain and—voilà—a fresh start with the same sparkle.

#2. Circle of Love Pendant

The next idea is, if you want to keep the full ring intact. We can turn the whole band into a pendant with some easy tweaks. We would attach a bail (a small loop that connects to a chain) so that it can hang on a chain. It’s a beautiful symbol of eternity and love in a new form.

#3. Bar-Style Diamond Necklace

Another idea, if your wedding ring is made up of small diamonds, like in a channel or pavé setting, we can remove them and arrange them in a sleek bar pendant. It’s modern, minimal, and super chic—perfect for layering or wearing solo.

#4. Create A Cluster or Floral Design

Got a ring with different-shaped stones or one that has a vintage feel? Then honor that design by creating a cluster pendant—maybe shaped like a flower, starburst, or heart. It adds personality and keeps the original character of the ring alive in a new way.

#5. Initial or Monogram Pendant

For something truly personal, try resetting the stones from your ring into a pendant shaped like your initials, your child’s, or someone meaningful to you. You can even add a birthstone for an added sentimental touch, and you can keep it close to your heart—literally!

#6. Diamond Station Necklace

Do you have a simple diamond band? Create some drama by making it into a statement necklace. Perfect on its own, but also a great piece to layer with other pendants.

Turn Wedding Ring Into Pendant: Frequently Asked Questions

How much does it cost to have a ring turned into a pendant?

Turning a ring into a pendant typically costs between $100 and $500, depending on the complexity of the design, the materials used, and any custom work needed.

Can a ring be made into a pendant?

Yes, a ring can absolutely be turned into a pendant. You can use the whole band, reset the stones, or repurpose the metal and gems into a completely new necklace design.

Can I turn my wedding ring into something else?

Yes, you can redesign a wedding ring into other types of jewelry such as a pendant, bracelet charm, or even earrings. A custom jeweler can guide you through your options.

Can I wear a wedding ring as a necklace?

Yes, wearing a wedding ring as a necklace is a meaningful alternative. It can be strung directly onto a chain or transformed into a pendant for a polished look.

Turn Your Ring Into Something Truly You with Scott’s Custom Jewelers

We love helping people breathe new life into their most meaningful pieces. Whether you want a subtle, everyday necklace or a bold tribute to your journey, we’re here to create a pendant that tells your story beautifully. Book your free consultation today.

Either way, repurposing fun, vintage jewelry is a fantastic way to breathe new life into old pieces while keeping their history intact. But what can you do with these treasure chests of old jewelry? Here are some creative ideas to bring your vintage designer jewelry back to life.

What’s the Difference Between Vintage and Antique Jewelry?

Before you begin repurposing, you should sort the jewelry and determine it’s worth. So, what’s the difference between vintage and antique?

Vintage describes jewelry that was made between 50 and 100 years ago. So, roughly vintage jewelry today would have been manufactured between 1925 and 1975.

Antique jewelry is generally considered to be at least 100 years old – so any inherited jewelry you receive that was made before 1925 would be antique.

As for jewelry’s value—the gemstones and metal all have a calculated worth based on the market prices for gold, silver, platinum, diamonds, and other gems today. Other factors determine antique value.

Sotheby’s, one of the world’s premier auction houses for art and luxury goods, takes many factors into account when evaluating antique bracelets, necklaces, earrings, brooches, rings, or other jewelry. General condition, the designer (such as Cartier, Van Cleef & Arpels, David Webb, or Harry Winston), provenance, and comparable auction prices all play a role in determining jewelry value.

5 Ways to Repurpose Your Vintage Designer Jewelry

Once you’ve determined that grandma’s diamond-encrusted cocktail ring isn’t designer jewelry from Tiffany & Co, you have all kinds of ways to repurpose it and make it into your own exquisite piece.

1. Turn pins into pendants.

With more people choosing remote work, blazers and suits just aren’t a thing like they were in the 80s when pins were popular. So turn those vintage brooches into necklaces or pendants!

Sometimes, all it takes is to remove the pin backing and then attach it to a chain or cord for a one-of-a-kind pendant. And a bold, funky pendant will add some fun flare to your sweatshirt at your next Teams meeting!

What if the pin has some valuable gemstones in it? Then, take a trip to a custom jewelry store and let them help you design a pendant that shows off the diamond, ruby, sapphire, or emerald gemstone in a more modern and wearable style.

2. Rework old rings into a new design.

Over time, gold and silver metals will wear away, and vintage jewelry just can’t be worn safely any longer. But those diamonds and gemstones in them can still be enjoyed! A qualified jeweler will be able to recycle the metal and reuse the gems in a new design to complement your pre-owned designer jewelry.

Consider combining multiple vintage rings—especially ones with family stories attached to them—and make a new pendant, ring, or even earrings out of them.

Even better, design matching necklaces with diamonds from mom’s wedding ring for each sister or granddaughter. Having a new piece of jewelry filled with family lore is a great way to connect the generations.

3. Make a charm bracelet.

Repurpose vintage pendants, broken bracelet pieces, or lost earrings into a new custom charm bracelet. Simply add a small ring to the item and have it attached to a link-style bracelet.

Not only will it be a wonderful conversation starter, but a charm bracelet filled with jewelry collected from travel adventures and life’s milestones is another chapter in a family’s jewelry history. Charm bracelets are exquisite pieces that elevate any outfit!

4. Repurpose vintage cufflinks into rings or earrings.

Only have one cufflink from your Great Uncle Joe? Turn it into a gorgeous signet ring. A jeweler can attach it to a ring base, and that beauty has another life to live!

Vintage cufflinks often have beautiful details and, most times can be easily transformed into a pair of fun earrings. Simply remove the cufflink back and attach them to earring wires, available at most hobby centers.

5. Upcycle old jewelry into home decor.

With a little glue and some imagination, old jewelry can often be used to decorate picture frames or mirrors. Adding costume jewelry accents like ornate pins, flower pendants, or colorful ringtops to ready-made picture frames is a great way to upcycle and add a personal flair to your home decor.

Another fun idea is to get a small shadow box from a hobby center and trace a simple tree or holiday outline on the pad with chalk. Then, use small pins to attach the jewelry pieces to the design.

You can even create a Christmas tree by draping chains like garland, filling in the tree with lone earrings, bold costume jewelry necklaces, and crazy brooches. Add a star pendant to the top, and you’ve got a unique piece of home decor!

Vintage Designer Jewelry: Frequently Asked Questions

How to repurpose old jewelry into new jewelry?

To repurpose old jewelry, take it to a custom jeweler who can redesign it into a new piece. Options include resetting gemstones into new settings, melting old gold to create a fresh design, or incorporating elements into a custom bracelet, ring, or necklace

What is repurposed designer jewelry?

Repurposed designer jewelry refers to high-end jewelry pieces that have been redesigned or modified while retaining elements of the original design. This can include resetting stones, altering settings, or combining vintage designer pieces into a new, unique creation.

What to do with deceased parents’ jewelry?

You can keep, repurpose, donate, or sell inherited jewelry. Many choose to redesign sentimental pieces into new wearable jewelry, such as turning a ring into a pendant or combining stones into a custom design. Selling or donating are also options if the pieces don’t fit your style.

Can you resell designer jewelry?

Yes, you can resell designer jewelry, especially brands like Cartier, Tiffany & Co., or Van Cleef & Arpels, which retain high value. Sell through jewelry consignment shops, auction houses, or online luxury resale platforms to get the best price.

Give Your Vintage Designer Jewelry a Fresh New Look with Scott’s Custom Jewelers

Have a vintage designer piece that no longer fits your style? Don’t let it sit unworn—repurpose it into a stunning new design that you’ll love wearing every day! Let’s reimagine your vintage jewelry—start your custom redesign!

Why not recycle it?

Recycling jewelry is an ethical and sustainable way to repurpose your old jewelry. This guide will walk you through all the options available to you to get the most use out of your old jewelry.

Why Recycling Jewelry Is Important

Not only is recycling old jewelry good for the environment – but it’s good for your budget too! Re-purposing broken, out-of-style pieces into new, custom jewelry helps the planet, saves you money and, best of all, retains the memories!

When you recycle your gold, platinum, or sterling silver jewelry, the jeweler will remove the gemstones, and then you can trade in the metal for the purchase of a new design. That way, everything gets reused.

Fun fact: jewelers recycle everything – even the floors of the workshop get recycled because there’s gold dust in them!

Taking your old jewelry to a custom jeweler is a great way to recycle those pieces into something that fits your style. I mean—trends change all of the time. What once was super hot (we’re looking at you, cocktail ring) is just not a thing now.

3 Ingenious Ways to Repurpose Your Old Jewelry

Okay, you’re really liking the idea of repurposing your old jewelry, but you aren’t sure where to start. Here are three unique ways to turn your diamonds into stunning new works of art.

#1: Turn a ring into a necklace.

Do you have an old engagement ring that you aren’t wearing anymore? Or maybe you’ve inherited your mother’s wedding set and want to incorporate it into a new necklace.

Something as simple as resetting a diamond from a ring into a simple pendant design will give old jewelry new life! Or add the small diamonds from a wedding ring to a chain that can be layered with all of your pieces.

#2: Make a custom bracelet from old jewelry.

Maybe you’ve run out of fingers to display those old rings, but you still want to be able to glance down and see that special stone. Why not make a new custom bracelet from your pieces?

Take your original diamond (because who wants to give up those great memories, even if you’ve upgraded to a new, larger diamond) and make a beautiful bangle-style bracelet that you can wear every day.

And don’t forget about those big, chunky, colored gemstones that your Great Aunt Gertie bequeathed to you. Clustered together, they can be made into a gorgeous statement bracelet! There are really so many options when it comes to restyling jewelry.

#3. Add small diamond earrings to your wedding band

Maybe you found a pair of small diamond earrings in that old jewelry stash. They can make great accent stones to your engagement ring, turning it into a meaningful three-stone, or past-present-future ring.

And that lone diamond hoop earring that’s just gathering dust? It can easily be reset into a new stacking band.

What To Do With Costume Jewelry

After sorting through that old jewelry, you may find some pieces that are not precious metal but are, instead, costume jewelry. They can be upcycled, too!

One easy way to showcase those vintage brooches, colored cluster style flower pendants, or large clip-on earrings, popular decades ago, is to visit a craft store and get a shadow box!

Simply outline a pattern in chalk on the fabric of the shadow box. Examples could be a wreath, a Christmas tree, or even a butterfly. Then, using small straight pins or glue, use those old gold-filled chains and costume pieces to fill in the design.

Not only will you have a one-of-a-kind piece of art, but you’ll smile every time you pass by.

Another option for costume jewelry is to donate it to your local theater program or high school, where it will be appreciated over and over again.

How to Redesign Old Jewelry

Redesigning old jewelry into fresh new designs is easier than you think! Follow these simple steps to breathe new life into sentimental pieces.

Step 1: Find a Trusted Custom Jeweler

Start by researching experienced custom jewelers who specialize in redesigning jewelry in Dublin. Look for customer reviews, portfolio examples, and ethical sourcing practices to ensure quality craftsmanship.

Step 2: Schedule a Consultation

Book an appointment with your chosen jeweler and bring in your old jewelry. Whether it’s an inherited piece, outdated design, or broken jewelry, they’ll assess what can be reused or repurposed.

Step 3: Discuss Your Vision

Share your ideas! Do you want to create a custom bracelet, necklace, ring, or earrings? Your jeweler will help refine your vision, suggest design options, and ensure the piece fits your style.

Step 4: Choose Materials and Design Details

Decide on key design elements, such as metal type, gemstone settings, engravings, or additional stones. Your jeweler may create a sketch or CAD (computer-aided design) rendering for approval before production.

Step 5: Watch the Magic Happen

Once the design is finalized, the jeweler will begin transforming your old jewelry into a stunning new piece. This process typically takes a few weeks, depending on complexity.

Step 6: Pick Up Your New Custom Jewelry

After final adjustments and polishing, your redesigned jewelry is ready! Enjoy your new, personalized piece that carries sentimental value while reflecting your style.

What To Do With Old Jewelry: Frequently Asked Questions

How to get rid of unwanted jewelry?

You can sell, donate, repurpose, or recycle unwanted jewelry. Selling to a jeweler, pawn shop, or online marketplace can get you cash while donating to charities or thrift stores helps others. If the piece has sentimental value, consider redesigning it into something new.

How to dispose of old jewelry?

To dispose of old jewelry responsibly, consider selling, donating, or recycling it. Gold, silver, and gemstones can be melted down and reused. Avoid throwing jewelry in the trash—take broken or unwanted pieces to a jewelry store or metal recycler for proper disposal.

How can I get the most money out of old jewelry?

To maximize value, get a professional appraisal and compare offers from jewelers, pawn shops, and online buyers. Selling directly to individuals through auction sites or marketplaces often yields higher returns. If your jewelry has historical or brand value, consider an auction house.

How do I dispose of old jewelry near me?

Look for local jewelry stores, pawn shops, gold buyers, or donation centers that accept old jewelry. Many jewelers offer trade-in or recycling programs. Searching online for “jewelry disposal near me” can help you find nearby options.

Work with the Best Custom Jewelers in Columbus

Just like a tailor, a custom jeweler will start with measurements. They will remove the diamonds and gemstones from old jewelry, weigh the old gold, silver, or platinum, and send it to a refiner to be reused again in new jewelry. It’s recycling at its finest!

Looking to learn more about recycling your jewelry into new designs? Call 614 336-4111 to schedule your custom jewelry appointment today, or book an appointment here.

Resetting a ring is the perfect way to bring those pieces out of the jewelry box and into something one-of-a-kind. We have seen a ton of restyles in 24 years, but here are 10 reset fine stone and diamond engagement ring before & afters that you just HAVE to see!

1. A One-of-a-Kind Pendant

The original diamond from mom’s engagement ring became part of a gorgeous, two-stone pendant. Adding a pop of color with tanzanite lets the heirloom diamond shine, especially in the sleek white gold setting. Now the stone and all it’s memories can live close to the heart!

2. A Restyled Rose Gold Wedding Band

J. brought in two rings that were wearing thin and needed a refresh, along with some other, small, additional diamonds. We came up with this wider wedding band featuring a delicate, open vine style center nestled between 14k white gold bands.

Using her larger center stone and side accents, we created something unique and strong enough for everyday wear. She loved it!

3. The Perfect Good Luck Charm

This princess cut diamond ring from a previous wedding ring had it’s lucky day as the center of this cool, custom horse shoe style ring! Setting fancy cut stones on their side like this princess cut diamond can give your ring a super modern feel, with only a simple change.

4. A Pear Shaped Diamond that Makes a Statement

This pear shaped diamond took on a whole new life in this wedding ring upgrade! The wide band used accent diamonds from old, unworn jewelry in a split design that helps balance out the top.

Reusing an old piece of jewelry is a great way to repurpose earrings, random accent stones from a band, or stones from a pendant, creating a new jewelry story.

5. This Unique Take on a Three Stone Ring

This three stone ring started as a few separate pieces from our customer’s family. The center stone from her mother, the top and bottom from both of her grandmothers.

S wanted to combine these diamonds into one piece, without leaning into the traditional three stone engagement ring style. By using a vertical layout, this ring goes from bridal and classic to a modern statement piece!

6. A Piece Combining Family History

This ring came to life from multiple family pieces! We blended the diamonds from two old wedding rings and a few diamond earrings to create this one-of-kind, custom, right hand ring. Another great example of a seamless design made from a collection of heirloom pieces.

7. This Criss Cross Statement Ring

This cool, criss cross design is a true showstopper! The cascade design of this old ring was straight out of the 80’s, but the diamonds were still in great shape.

We pulled this ring back into the future with a more modern setting, and added a small round diamond that belonged to her grandmother. It turned out spectacular! As a bonus, the squared design of this ring keeps it from turning on her finger, too.

8. Tennis Bracelet Made Into A Pave Band

This broken, outdated tennis bracelet gave us so many diamonds to work with that our options were truly endless. We made the switch from yellow to white gold and created a beautiful pave diamond wedding band from all those heirloom stones.

Plus, we recycled the old gold towards the price of the new piece. It was a win/win for everyone!

9. From an Unworn Ring to a Favorite Necklace

Rings not your style? They weren’t our customer’s style, either. She loved the three stone look of her wedding set, but felt like she never wore them (she works with her hands, and didn’t want them to get damaged).

So, we converted them to an amazing custom necklace that mimicked her rings with center stones and diamond accent stones, but that she could wear more comfortably. (Hint, this is a great way to wear your original bridal set after a well-deserved upgrade!)

10. Combining Old Jewelry to Create Something Special

This necklace and stick pin wasn’t worn anymore, so we combined into something more in line with our customer’s style. Keeping the piece two-tone makes it super wearable too. Also: two tone jewelry is really trending this fall!

Don’t feel boxed in with jewelry design. Heirloom pieces can be anything with enough imagination.

Ready to Reset Your Original Engagement Ring Into Something You Love?

The moral of the story is that old jewelry doesn’t have to sit in a jewelry box anymore. With a little imagination, a reputable jeweler, and Scott’s cool custom design technology, old jewelry can be reset into new engagement rings, filled with history and personality!

We hope you were inspired with these 10 reset engagement ring before and afters that you just HAVE to see!

Want to see what you can do? Set up your custom appointment (in person or via ZOOM)!