So let’s talk honestly about the question we hear all the time in our custom jewelry showroom:

“What are the disadvantages of lab grown diamonds?”

Lab grown diamonds have become incredibly popular in Columbus (actually, they’re popular in the entire country!) and we totally get why. I mean, they’re beautiful, affordable, and check off all the sustainability boxes. No wonder they’ve become the hottest selling gemstone for a custom engagement ring!

Here at Scott’s Custom Jewelers in Columbus, Ohio, we work with both lab grown and natural diamonds every single day. We also specialize in reusing diamonds and gemstones that you already own in your designs (another nod to sustainability). We don’t believe in pushing one gem over the other, and work with you to help you make the right decision for you.

First Off: What Is a Lab Grown Diamond?

A lab grown diamond is a real diamond. Same sparkle. Same hardness. Same chemical structure. The only difference is where it’s grown. We have been following lab grown diamonds for over 10 years now, and when the Federal Trade Commission said they were exactly the same chemically, physically and optically, we started offering them to our customers.

Here’s what they are:

• Natural diamonds grow in the earth over billions of years
• Lab diamonds are grown in a lab in a few weeks using advanced technology

Also, lab diamonds are not fake and not cubic zirconia. In fact, if a jeweler says they can tell a lab diamonds from a mined diamond without special equipment, they’re lying.

(We explain this more here → https://scottscustomjewelers.com/lab-grown-diamonds-lp/)

The Disadvantages of Lab Grown Diamonds

We’re all about transparency! There are a few things you should absolutely know before choosing a lab diamond for an engagement ring or custom jewelry piece.

1. Lab Grown Diamonds Do Not Hold High Dollar Value Like Natural Diamonds

This is the biggest difference, but it comes with an explanation.

Lab diamonds:

• Are not rare
• Can be produced in unlimited quantities
• Continue to drop in price as technology improves

Because of this, lab grown diamonds do not retain or increase in value like natural diamonds sometimes can. Now for the explanation: Natural diamonds are also not “rare” but rather the amount available to the public is controlled by the mining companies, kind of like fossil fuels.

And even more importantly, natural diamonds may have higher worth, but unless you’re a diamond wholesaler, you won’t get the full value of either a lab or mined diamonds if you need to sell it. At best, you’ll get 20% of it’s worth if you have to sell your diamond to a pawn shop.

Simple math time. Say you spend $10,000 on a natural diamond and you need to sell it. You’ll most likely get $2,000 for it, but will have lost $8,000. Ouch.

Same situation, but with a lab grown diamond. You spend $1,000 on it (because they’re about 90% less expensive than mined stones) and need to sell it. You’ll get about $200 for it at a pawn shop, but will only have lost $800! That’s a much better scenario!

Why many Columbus buyers are still okay with this:

Most people aren’t buying an engagement ring as an investment. They’re buying it to celebrate a relationship, and they plan on wearing it everyday. Lab diamonds check off those boxes!

And lab diamonds let you get a bigger, more impressive diamond because they are 80-90% less than diamonds mined from the earth. Plus, they are sustainable and conflict free.

2. Lab Diamond Prices Keep Dropping

Yes, just like electronics and appliances, this is true. Lab diamond prices have come down a lot over the past few years, due to more companies getting into the market, but those prices now seem to have stabilized.

The upside for you:

With a much lower cost than natural diamonds, you can invest more of your budget into the design and craftsmanship of the ring, giving it even more meaning!

We see this every day in our Columbus custom design studio.

3. Lab Grown Diamonds Are Not Rare

Some people love the idea of a diamond formed naturally over billions of years. That story matters to them, and that’s completely valid. But then again, natural diamonds aren’t as rare as they’ve been marketed to be. It’s supply and demand!

The romance of a mined diamond is pretty cool. And, as sustainable jewelers, we absolutely LOVE to reuse diamonds and gemstones from family pieces, because of the stories associated with these stones!

And that brings us to a super important point:

What actually makes your engagement ring unique:

It’s all about the story. At Scott’s Custom Jewelers, your ring is unique because YOU call the shots! We’ll work with you to create a piece that fits your style, your hand, your story!

The design and the meaning associated with the piece, is what makes it special.

See some of our custom jewelry projects

Pros and Cons of Lab Grown Diamonds (Quick List)

Pros

• Cost 80-90% less than natural diamonds
• Bigger or higher quality diamond for your budget
• Real diamond (same sparkle, same durability same material)
• Excellent for everyday wear as a custom engagement rings
• Great option for an anniversary upgrades and statement rings
• No mining required, no social conflicts
• Consistent quality and availability

Cons

• Do not hold or increase in value
• Prices continue to drop over time
• Limited resale or trade-in value
• Not rare or finite

Why So Many Columbus Couples Choose Lab Diamonds

That’s the big question. We actually sell more lab diamonds at our Columbus store than any store in Ohio! Customers have chosen lab diamonds because they check so many boxes:

• More affordable, so they can have a bigger center stone
• High quality lab diamonds offer better quality, clarity and color for the price
• Able to afford a more detailed custom setting for their engagement ring
• Or all the above!

We regularly hear in our Columbus showroom, “I never thought I could afford something like this.” That’s one of our favorite things about lab diamonds.

Our Honest Opinion at Scott’s Custom Jewelers

We love them all!

• Lab diamonds
• Natural diamonds
• Family diamonds
• Vintage diamonds
• And everything in between

They’re just different tools for different goals.

Our job is to educate you, show you the real differences, and help you choose what fits your priorities and budget.

Frequently Asked Questions About Lab Grown Diamonds

Are lab grown diamonds real diamonds?

Yes. Lab grown diamonds are chemically, optically and physically identical to natural diamonds.

Do lab grown diamonds look different than natural diamonds?

No. Even gemologists need special equipment to tell them apart.

Are lab diamonds cheaper than natural diamonds?

Yes. Lab diamonds typically cost 80–90% less than natural diamonds of the same size and quality.

Do lab grown diamonds lose value?

They don’t “lose” value — but they don’t hold value or appreciate like natural diamonds might.

Are lab diamonds good for engagement rings?

Absolutely. They are durable, beautiful, and perfect for everyday wear.

Should I buy a lab or natural diamond?

That depends on:

• Your budget
• Your priorities
• Whether size, value retention, or tradition matters more to you

We help Columbus clients compare both every day in our showroom.

Thinking About a Custom Engagement Ring?

Whether you’re considering lab grown diamonds, natural diamonds, or a combination of both, we’d love to help you design something that fits your style, your budget, and your story.

Make your FREE custom jewelry appointment (both in person and virtually) here

Or stop into Scott’s Custom Jewelers and let’s design something amazing together.

A Guide from Scott’s Custom Jewelers

When you’re ready to pop the question, one of the most common (and stressful!) decisions you’ll make is: “How much should I spend on an engagement ring?” The truth is, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer — but there are several variables to consider.

At Scott’s Custom Jewelers, we know that every love story—and every budget—is unique. The right amount to spend on an engagement ring isn’t a set number; it’s what feels right for you, your partner, and your future together.

The Truth About the “3-Month Salary Rule”

You’ve probably heard the old rule that says you should spend two or three months’ salary on a ring. Yikes! That idea came from a 20th-century marketing campaign — not from real-life couples.

Today’s couples are smarter about their money. They want a beautiful, meaningful engagement ring without the financial stress. So, whether that means spending $1,500 or $15,000, what matters most is creating something personal that will last a lifetime.

What Affects the Price of an Engagement Ring?

When setting your budget, here are the main factors that impact cost:

• Diamond or Gemstone Choice – Lab-grown diamonds, natural diamonds, inherited diamonds, — even sapphires, and rubies — all vary in cost. Lab-grown diamonds are especially popular right now — they’re exactly the same as mined diamonds chemically, optically and physically, but cost up to 80% less than mined diamonds.
• Setting Style – Solitaire, hidden-halo, name brand, or custom settings can affect both style and cost.
• Metal Type – Platinum, white, yellow, or rose gold. Depending on how much metal is in the design will affect the total cost of an engagement ring.
• Customization – A custom-designed ring isn’t necessarily more expensive than an “off-the-shelf” ring. A custom ring lets you control your budget and design every detail to match your taste.

What’s the Average Cost of an Engagement Ring?

In 2025, the average engagement ring in the U.S. costs around $6,000, but most couples spend between $2,000–$8,000.
At Scott’s Custom Jewelers, many of our custom lab diamond engagement rings fall in the $3,000–$5,000 range — proving you can have a stunning, high-quality ring without overspending.

How to Set a Ring Budget You’ll Feel Good About

1. Decide what’s comfortable for you. Focus on what fits your lifestyle and finances.
2. Talk with your partner. Some couples plan the purchase together, others prefer a surprise — just make sure you’re on the same page.
3. Compare options. Lab-grown and mined diamonds both offer beauty — see them side-by-side in person.
4. Work with a trusted jeweler. The right jeweler will explain your options clearly and help you maximize your budget.

Engagement Ring Budget Q&A

Q: Is it okay to spend less than the average on a ring?
A: Absolutely! Your ring should match your budget and your priorities. Many couples today are choosing meaningful designs that emphasize craftsmanship and sentiment over size or price tag.

Q: Are lab-grown diamonds worth it?
A: Yes — lab diamonds are chemically identical to mined diamonds, eco-friendly, and more affordable. You can often get a larger or higher-quality stone for the same price. And no one — not even a jeweler — can tell them apart without special equipment!

Q: Can I design a custom engagement ring on a budget?
A: Definitely. At Scott’s Custom Jewelers, custom doesn’t mean expensive. It means personal. We can work within nearly any budget to design something that’s uniquely yours — even using inherited gems or family stones.

Q: How do I know if I’m getting a fair price?
A: Look for transparency. We show you diamond options side-by-side and explain what affects the cost so you can make an informed, confident decision.

Final Thoughts

There’s no universal rule for how much you should spend on an engagement ring — only what feels right for you.

At Scott’s Custom Jewelers, we help you design a ring that fits your love story and your budget. From classic solitaires to one-of-a-kind custom designs, we’ll guide you every step of the way.

Ready to start your design?
Schedule your custom appointment today and discover how easy (and fun!) it is to create the perfect engagement ring — right here at Scott’s Custom Jewelers.

The History of Old Mine Cut Diamonds

The Old Mine Cut diamond dates back to the 18th and 19th centuries, when diamonds were cut by hand rather than machines. Originating in Brazil and later South Africa (hence “mine” because they were mined from the earth), these stones were uniquely shaped to maximize sparkle under candlelight. How romantic!

Unlike today’s precision cuts, each Old Mine Cut was slightly different — no two were ever identical. This just adds to their charm and explains why an antique Old Mine Cut diamond ring feels so special and personal.

If you love heirloom pieces, you might also enjoy seeing how we redesign heirloom jewelry into modern styles.

How to Recognize an Old Mine Cut Diamond

Old Mine Cut diamonds are often described as the great-great-grandparent of today’s cushion cut. They typically feature:

• A squarish or cushion-like outline
• A high crown and deep pavilion
• A small table (the flat top facet)
• A large, open culet (the facet at the bottom)

This cut creates a warm, romantic glow rather than the sharp brilliance of modern cuts — perfect for anyone who values character and history in their jewelry.

Why Choose an Old Mine Cut Diamond Engagement Ring?

Choosing an Old Mine Cut diamond engagement ring means celebrating craftsmanship from another era. These stones often come from repurposed or antique jewelry, making them both eco-conscious and rich in history. Couples who choose them often love the one-of-a-kind look and the idea of wearing a piece of the past.

Thinking about an Old Mine Cut diamond for your engagement ring? Contact us at Scott’s Custom Jewelers to start designing yours today.

Not sure if antique is your style? You can also learn why lab-grown diamonds are trending for engagement rings.

Elongated Old Mine Cut Diamonds

While most Old Mine Cuts are square or cushion-shaped, some rare examples come in elongated proportions. These elongated Old Mine Cut diamonds have a stretched, oval-like appearance, blending antique charm with a flattering finger shape. They’re highly sought-after (thanks to a very popular singer who just got engaged!) for those who want an antique look with a unique silhouette.

If elongated shapes catch your eye, discover the beauty of oval, radiant, and pear diamonds.

Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond Rings Today

Whether passed down through family or discovered in antique collections, an antique Old Mine Cut diamond ring is a treasure. Many jewelers also restyle these stones into modern settings, giving you the best of both worlds — timeless sparkle with a setting designed for your lifestyle.

For more ideas, check out our guide to diamond alternatives for engagement rings.

Final Thoughts

An Old Mine Cut diamond is more than just a gemstone — it’s a window into history. From the romantic glow to the hand-cut craftsmanship, these diamonds carry a story you simply can’t find in modern cuts.

Whether you’re dreaming of an old mine cut diamond engagement ring, seeking an antique Old Mine Cut diamond ring, or curious about rare elongated Old Mine Cut diamonds, one thing is certain: these gems are as unforgettable as the love stories they represent.

Want to explore Old Mine Cut diamonds for yourself? Contact us at Scott’s Custom Jewelers — we’d love to help you create a one-of-a-kind ring that blends antique beauty with your modern love story.

So, What Is a Lab-Grown Diamond?

A lab-grown diamond is simply a diamond that’s created in a laboratory rather than mined from the earth. It’s formed using advanced technology that replicates the natural diamond-growing process, meaning extreme heat, high pressure, and lots of time.

The result? A stone that is chemically, physically, and optically identical to a diamond mined from the ground. Even the Federal Trade Commission says they are the same.

We like to say that diamonds are like tomatoes. Some are grown in a field, others in a greenhouse. The only difference is where they are grown, not what they are. It’s pretty simple.

In fact, if you put a mined diamond and a lab-grown diamond side by side, even a trained gemologist can’t tell the difference without specialized equipment. Same sparkle, same hardness, same durability, same wow factor. But not the exact cost!

Are Lab Diamonds Less Expensive Than Mined Diamonds?

Absolutely! Lab-grown diamonds are generally less expensive than mined diamonds—often by 50% to 80% or more for a comparable stone.

Here’s why:

• Lower production costs: Creating diamonds in a lab doesn’t require massive mining operations, which makes it more efficient and less costly.
  
• Shorter supply chain: Lab diamonds typically go from lab to jeweler with fewer middle steps than mined diamonds.
  
• Not as rare: Mined diamonds take billions of years to form; lab diamonds can be grown in weeks. Since they’re more accessible to produce, prices are more competitive.
  
• Market perception: Some buyers still prefer the “romance” of mined stones, which affects demand and pricing, though this is changing fast!

The bottom line:

You can get a larger, higher-quality lab-grown diamond for the same budget you’d spend on a smaller mined one, without compromising beauty or durability.

Then What’s the Difference?

The main difference between a lab-grown diamond and a mined diamond is the origin of the diamond.

A mined diamond comes from deep underground and has been formed over billions of years. A lab-grown diamond is created in a controlled lab environment in weeks. But both are made of carbon atoms arranged in the same crystal structure.

The same independent labs (like GIA or IGI) grade both types of diamonds using the same 4Cs: Cut, Color, Clarity, and Carat weight. That means you’ll get the same official certification and guaranteed quality if your diamond was grown on Earth or in a lab.

Why Choose Lab Grown?

We made the decision to sell lab diamonds about 7 years ago, when they came into the market for engagement rings. The reality is that lab diamonds have been made for years for industrial uses (drills, technology). They just weren’t made for jewelry. And with all of the social issues surrounding mined gemstones, we decided to offer a sustainable, conflict-free option in our custom jewelry store.

Many of our customers love lab-grown diamonds for the following reasons:

• More Diamond for Your Budget: Lab-grown diamonds typically cost 50–80% less than mined ones, meaning you can often go bigger, or get better quality, or both.
  
• Sustainability: They’re a more eco-conscious option, using fewer natural resources and causing less environmental disruption. The labs we source our diamonds from use solar and wind to power their plants too, reducing their carbon footprint even more!
  
• Ethics: Since they’re grown in labs, there are no concerns about conflict diamonds or questionable mining practices.

The Bottom Line: Lab-Grown Diamonds Are Real Diamonds

Lab-grown diamonds aren’t “fake,” “synthetic,” or “imitations.” Those terms belong to cubic zirconia or Moissanite—stones that look like diamonds but are made of entirely different materials.

Lab-grown diamonds are diamonds. And whether you’re shopping for an engagement ring, a custom necklace, or a sparkling pair of earrings, they’re a beautiful, modern choice that we’re proud to offer.

Is a Lab-Grown Diamond a Real Diamond? Frequently Asked Questions

Are lab-grown diamonds considered fake?

No, lab-grown diamonds are not fake. They are real diamonds with the same chemical, physical, and optical properties as mined diamonds. Only their origin differs.

What are the disadvantages of lab-grown diamonds?

Disadvantages include lower resale value, limited rarity, and market perception. Lab diamonds may not appreciate over time and are less favored by traditional collectors.

Is it better to buy a real diamond or a lab-grown diamond?

It depends on your priorities. Lab diamonds offer better value, ethics, and sustainability. Mined diamonds may appeal more for tradition, rarity, or investment.

Can a jeweler identify a lab-grown diamond from a mined diamond?

Not with the naked eye. Even trained gemologists need specialized equipment to distinguish lab grown from mined diamonds, as they are identical in appearance.

Find Your Perfect Lab-Grown Diamond with Scott’s Custom Jewelers

Ready to dazzle with a diamond that’s ethical, affordable, and just as brilliant? Let Scott’s Custom Jewelers create a custom lab-grown piece just for you!

And now, radiant-style engagement rings are seeing a major resurgence among couples seeking something unique and bespoke, and undeniably glamorous.

Whether you’re shopping for your perfect ring or just dreaming for the future (hint—start a Pinterest board, stat!), here’s a look at 5 popular radiant cut diamond engagement rings that are rising in popularity.

What is a Radiant Cut Diamond?

The radiant cut was first introduced in the late 1970s by master diamond cutter Henry Grossbard. It was designed to combine the best of both worlds: the fiery sparkle of a round brilliant cut with the elegant, elongated shape of an emerald cut.

Radiant cut diamonds are incredibly versatile, characterized by trimmed corners, straight sides, and a brilliant facet pattern. They can be either square or rectangular, and are known for their intense sparkle and strong presence on the hand.

Why Radiant Cut Rings Are Trending

Trends follow the stars—and thanks to the gorgeous engagement rings worn by celebrities like Jennifer Aniston, Jennifer Lawrence, and Lea Michaels, the radiant cut is becoming very popular. And rightly so! Radiant cut diamonds offer maximum sparkle, thanks to their 70+ facets or cuts.

Plus, radiant cut stones feel contemporary, but have enough classic elegance to stand the test of time. And the finger-flattering, elongated shape tends to make fingers appear longer and slimmer (always a win in our books!)

And let’s talk about the durability of a radiant cut diamond. The trimmed corners help prevent chipping, making it ideal for daily wear.

Lab-Grown Radiant Cut Diamonds

With the popularity of lab-grown diamonds, an ethically, sustainable, and inexpensive option now in diamond engagement rings, the radiant cut lab-grown diamond has become even more popular.

And for good reason! Radiant cut lab grown diamonds in large carat sizes (3 carats and bigger) are now affordable, especially in high-quality, well-cut stones.

5 Popular Radiant Style Engagement Ring Settings

From classic to contemporary, radiant cut diamond rings have tons of setting options.

1. Solitaire Radiant Cut Ring

Simplicity meets sophistication. A solitaire radiant cut engagement ring lets the diamond take center stage. With a sleek band, designed in either yellow gold, white gold, or platinum, it’s a minimalist’s dream with a modern edge.

2. Radiant Cut with a Halo

A radiant cut diamond, surrounded by a halo of smaller diamonds, will always boost the bling factor. This engagement ring setting adds size, sparkle, and an air of vintage glamour. It’s ideal for those who love a dramatic, eye-catching look and want to make a statement!

3. Three-Stone Radiant Cut Engagement Ring

Also called a past, present, and future ring, three-stone radiant cut engagement rings are flanked by two smaller side stones, of either the same cut or a complementary shaped cut stone. The three-stone ring offers a regal, balanced look that’s both romantic and elegant, and is popular with romantics who love symbolism and symmetry.

4. Hidden Halo Radiant Cut Setting

A subtle twist on the traditional diamond halo setting, the hidden halo lies just beneath the center stone, adding sparkle without overpowering the diamond. The brilliant wisp of diamonds under the main radiant cut stone is perfect for brides who want something classic, but with a twist.

5. Radiant Cut with Pavé Band

For those who love luxury, a pavé-set band, encrusted with tiny diamonds, enhances the radiant cut’s sparkle without overwhelming it. This engagement ring style is a favorite among those who love detail and shine but prefer a sleek, refined design.

Metal Choices That Enhance Radiant Cuts

Want to add even more personality to your radiant cut diamond engagement ring? Then, consider the metal color.

Looking for warmth and a vintage vibe? Yellow gold (especially 18k) is a great choice. This trending color enhances the radiant cut’s sparkle.

For those who prefer sleek and modern, white gold or platinum is the all-time favorite. This color of metal amplifies the brilliance of a radiant cut and puts the focus on the stone.

And for those who yearn for a romantic or feminine touch, setting a long, radiant cut diamond into 14k rose gold is a beautiful way to get that old-world feel.

Why Choose a Radiant Cut Engagement Ring?

Radiant cut engagement rings are the perfect mix of sparkle, structure, and style. Whether you love a minimal solitaire or a glittering halo, the radiant cut offers versatility and brilliance that’s hard to beat.

When choosing an engagement ring, remember—style is personal, but sparkle is forever. If you’re looking for a stone that dazzles from every angle and feels just a bit different from the crowd, the radiant cut might just be your perfect match.

Radiant Cut Diamond Engagement Rings: Frequently Asked Questions

Is a radiant cut diamond more expensive?

Radiant cut diamonds are typically less expensive than round cuts but can cost more than other fancy shapes like emerald or cushion cuts. Their price depends on carat, clarity, color, and cut quality.

How much is a 1.5-carat radiant diamond worth?

A 1.5-carat radiant-cut diamond typically ranges from $1,500 to $15,000, depending on factors like color, clarity, and whether it’s lab-grown or natural.

What diamond cut is the prettiest?

The prettiest diamond cut is subjective, but round brilliant cuts are often considered the most classic and sparkly. Other popular choices include oval, emerald, and radiant for their unique shape and light performance.

Shop Custom Radiant Cut Diamond Engagement Rings with Scott’s Custom Jewelers

Looking for your dream ring? Let us help you explore radiant-style engagement rings tailored to your taste and budget. Book your in-person or ZOOM appointment here for a custom consultation!

Known as a symbol of luxury, love, and commitment, diamonds—and diamond jewelry—have so much meaning tied up in them. From grandma’s beautiful, depression-era chip of an engagement ring to the bold beauty of a celebrity’s stunning red carpet necklace, the scintillating sparkle lures you in.

In recent years, a new contender has emerged in the glittering, diamond gemstone world—lab-grown diamonds. These diamonds, created in high-tech laboratories instead of mined from deep within the earth, offer a compelling alternative to their natural counterparts.

So, how do lab-grown diamonds stack up against natural diamonds? Are they really the same thing? And which one should you choose?

In this ultimate guide, we’ll break down everything you need to know about lab-grown vs. natural diamonds—from their formation and environmental impact, to their price and resale value.

What Are Lab-Grown Diamonds?

Lab-grown diamonds, also known as synthetic or man-made diamonds, are created using advanced technological processes that replicate the natural conditions under which diamonds form in the Earth’s mantle.

Unlike diamond simulants (which are not made from diamond materials), lab-grown or synthetic diamonds are comprised of the same material, and have the same properties as naturally formed diamonds, which are pure carbon crystallized in an isotropic 3D form, and have identical chemical and physical components.

Lab diamonds have actually been around for decades, but were used mainly in industrial capacities like drilling. They are made by two primary methods:

• High Pressure High Temperature (HPHT)
• Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD)

Both methods result in real diamonds—chemically, physically, and optically identical to natural diamonds. In fact, the Federal Trade Commission has said that lab-created diamonds have the same chemical, physical, and visual properties as natural diamonds.

Lab diamonds, like their mined counterparts, are unique and have the same inclusions and color variances. The only difference is that they’re manufactured above ground. 

A History of Natural Diamonds

Natural diamonds are formed deep beneath the Earth’s surface, over billions of years, through a process of intense heat and pressure. They are found in kimberlite mines, which are pipes of minerals and alluvial deposits in various regions around the world, including Africa, Russia, Canada, and Australia.

Natural diamonds often contain small inclusions or color variations from other minerals that are in the earth, and are part of its geological history.

Lab Grown vs Natural Diamonds Facts

If you’re considering whether to jump on the lab-grown diamond train and fully commit to leaving natural diamonds in the past, here are a few facts and questions for you to consider.

Is There A Difference In Appearance?

To the naked eye and even under a high-powered microscope, lab-grown diamonds and natural diamonds are virtually indistinguishable from each other. They share the same hardness (10 on the Mohs scale), offer identical brilliance or fire, and have the same chemical composition (pure carbon).

And both lab and mined diamonds have unique inclusions and color variations within the stone that make them special. Lab diamonds are not all the same. The crystal grown above ground has to be cut and polished just like the rough material mined from the earth.

In addition, only super advanced equipment can accurately identify the very subtle differences in the crystal or find trace elements.

Also, all lab-grown diamonds of a certain size and up, and some mined diamonds, do have a laser-inscribed laboratory report certification number on the side of the gemstone that will identify it as mined or lab-grown. But that number isn’t visible with the naked eye.

Environmental Impact Of Lab Diamonds And Mined Diamonds

While mined diamonds have long been associated with environmental issues, early lab-grown facilities used considerable energy. Fortunately, that has been changed to limit the impact.

Benefits of Lab-Grown Diamonds:

• Lower carbon footprint
• No habitat destruction or large-scale land disruption of land areas
• Requires significant energy (especially HPHT), but renewable energy like solar panels is now used by most companies

Cons of Mined Natural Diamonds:

• Diamond mining often leads to substantial environmental degradation and the displacement of ecosystems
• Some diamond mining companies are improving sustainability through ethical sourcing and carbon-neutral mining

Ethics and Sourcing of Lab-Grown Diamonds vs Natural Diamonds

One of the most significant advantages of lab-grown diamonds is their traceability. Since they’re grown in a laboratory, customers know where they originate, eliminating concerns about conflict diamonds (also known as blood diamonds).

In response to the public outcry against blood diamonds, some natural diamond companies have started to offer “conflict-free” certifications, but traceability is much more complex and sometimes disputed.

Cost And Value of Lab-Grown Diamonds and Natural Diamonds

Currently, lab-grown diamonds are generally 60–90% less expensive than the exact same size, grade, color, and clarity of their mined diamond counterparts. While their prices have fluctuated in the past, recently the price has stabilized.

Generally, people have had to prioritize their wants when choosing a natural diamond to fit their budget. If they wanted a larger-sized gemstone, then they would have to compromise on color or clarity. With the advent of lab diamonds, customers can usually afford a bigger stone of higher quality.

As for resale value, unless you’ve invested in museum-quality jewelry, if you need to sell your items, you’ll only get about 10-20% of their value from a pawn or resale store. The idea that you can profit from natural diamonds has been one of the biggest myths perpetrated by the jewelry industry for decades.

That’s why most people pass down their jewelry and have it restyled—they simply cannot get back the value of their purchase from a resale.

So, for example, if you spend $10,000 on a mined diamond engagement ring, you can expect to sell it to a pawn shop for at best, $2000. That means you’ve essentially lost $8000. If you bought the same size lab-grown engagement ring for $1000, though, you would only be able to sell it for $200 and realize a loss of $800.

Lab-Grown Diamonds vs Natural Diamond Durability

Surprise, there’s no difference here at all! Lab-grown and natural diamonds are equally durable, making them suitable for daily wear, including engagement rings.

Diamond Certification and Grading

Both lab-grown and natural diamonds can be certified by independent diamond laboratories. Top gemological institutes include GIA (Gemological Institute of America), IGI (International Gemological Institute), and AGS (American Gem Society).

A good rule of thumb is to make sure any diamond you buy (lab or natural) is certified and laser inscribed with the certification number on the side of the stone.

How to Choose the Best Diamond For You

It really comes down to personal choice. Choose a lab-grown diamond if you:

• Want a larger or higher-quality stone for less money
• Care deeply about environmental sustainability
• Value transparency and ethical sourcing

A mined or natural diamond may be best for you if you:

• Want a traditional or sentimental value attached to the stone
• Are concerned about heirloom value
• Prefer the allure of rarity and geological history

Buying a lab-grown or natural diamond ultimately comes down to your values, budget, and preferences. Both options offer stunning beauty, durability, and symbolism, and withstand daily wear.

As with all things technical, lab-grown diamonds are rapidly gaining acceptance and popularity – and for good reason! So no matter your choice, the best diamond is the one that brings you joy and fits your lifestyle.

Lab Grown Diamond vs Natural Diamond: Frequently Asked Questions

Are lab diamonds as good as real diamonds?

Yes, lab diamonds are chemically, physically, and optically identical to natural diamonds. They have the same hardness, brilliance, and sparkle. The only difference is how they’re made—lab diamonds are grown in controlled environments, while natural diamonds form over billions of years underground.

Which diamond is best, natural or lab-grown?

The best diamond depends on your priorities. Lab-grown diamonds offer better value and are more environmentally friendly. Natural diamonds may hold higher resale value and emotional significance for some buyers. Both are real diamonds—choosing the best comes down to budget and preference.

What are the disadvantages of lab-grown diamonds?

Lab-grown diamonds generally have lower resale value, and some buyers still prefer the rarity of natural stones. They also require significant energy to produce, and not all labs are equally transparent about their environmental practices.

Why not buy a lab-grown diamond?

You might choose not to buy a lab-grown diamond if resale value, natural rarity, or long-term investment potential are important to you. Some people also prefer the symbolism of a naturally formed diamond for engagement rings or heirlooms.

Create Personalized, Lab-Grown Diamond Jewelry with Scott’s Custom Jewelers

Have questions about choosing the right diamond? Ready to create the engagement of your dreams without compromising on ethics? Let’s talk all things lab-grown diamonds.

Whether you’re updating your style, honoring a milestone, or repurposing heirloom pieces. If it’s time to redo your I-do, here are 6 ways to redesign your wedding rings into something fresh and new.

Why Should a Wedding Ring be Redesigned?

Your love may be forever, but wedding rings can change throughout your marriage. Some common reasons why a wedding ring should be redesigned include:

• The ring is too worn out or broken to repair correctly.
• Your finger size, or even an injury to your finger, requires a different style of ring.
• You’ve inherited jewelry or gemstones that you’d like to incorporate into your wedding ring
• You can now afford to upgrade your center diamond into something bigger.

6 Inspirational Ideas for Redesigning Wedding Rings

Sometimes, all it takes is a little tweak to make a big impact when redesigning your rings. Wedding bands are filled with sentiment and memories. Restyling your rings let’s you keep the gemstones, recycle your old gold mounting, and make a new chapter to your story without replacing those memories. Here are 6 different ways to redo your wedding set.

1. Upgrade or replace the center stone

Most engagement rings consist of a base, called a shank, with a separate top for the center stone, called a head. If the base of the ring is still in good shape and doesn’t need extensive repairs, simply swapping out the original diamond or gem for a larger, perhaps higher-quality one (like a super affordable, lab-grown diamond) is a stunning way to upgrade your set.

And you don’t have to use a diamond. Replacing the stone with a gorgeous colored gemstone, like a sapphire, emerald, or ruby, is a great way to add some personality to your ring.

2. Change the ring setting

Over the years, the small prongs holding the diamond or gemstone in place may wear away, making the setting unsafe. This could be a great time to change the setting style into something different.

Options include using a bezel setting to secure the stone. Bezel settings don’t use prongs, but instead surround the diamond or gemstone with a “donut” of gold or platinum. Bezels are great if you are a little harder on your jewelry or work requires you to wear gloves (those prongs ALWAYS catch on gloves!).

Another option would be to replace the setting with a diamond halo around the gem. Not only will you get to keep your original stone, but that custom diamond halo will may your center look even bigger. Always a win/win!

3. Remount everything into a new design

If you really want a totally new look, but want to keep your original diamonds (or maybe add some family stones), then remounting your ring might be the solution.

With CAD technology and 3D printers, it’s easier than ever to transform your stones into something brand new and stylish! Restyling means that you’ll repurpose your gemstones, recycle your gold, and redesign your jewelry into fresh, new pieces you’ll love to wear. And most importantly, you’ll get to keep your memories!

Maybe you want to add some more sparkle. No problem—adding colored gemstones, or upgrading your center stone to a new lab grown diamonds, available in every shape and size, can really juice up your wedding set.

4. Add personal engravings or hidden messages

Adding personal engravings to the inside of a band is a sweet way to privately change things up. You can inscribe names, dates, coordinates, or quotes on the band, kind of like a secret message.

And laser engravings can even allow for mini custom patterns to be added to the outside and inside of a band! Engravings add emotional value without changing the outward appearance too much.

5. Create a stackable ring set

A great way to update your ring is to add a stackable band to the set.

If you love symmetry, designing a custom replica of your wedding band to the other side of your engagement ring will give you more width and help balance out the rings.

Or you can add contour bands or eternity bands with diamonds or colored gems that may represent the birthstones of your children. In fact, many couples are marking each family milestone, like a child’s birth or anniversary, with a new band and stacking them all on one side. It’s like building your love story in jewelry form.

6. Change the metal color or finish

If you need to start fresh, now is the time to recast the ring in a new metal, like switching from yellow gold to white or rose gold, or even platinum. And don’t forget about mixing metals, too! Combining colors is a great way to stay on-trend and gives you many options when accessorizing your jewelry look.

Also, adding fun textures, like hammered, brushed, matte, or high-polish finishes, to a wide band will instantly and inexpensively update your wedding bands.

Pair the redesigned wedding set with a vow renewal, or surprise your partner on a milestone anniversary with the updated ring. Total win! It’s all about making new memories.

Ideas for Redesigning Wedding Rings: Frequently Asked Questions

How to redesign your wedding ring?

To redesign your wedding ring, consult a custom jeweler to discuss your vision. You can reset stones, change the setting, add new diamonds, or even combine it with another piece to create a fresh, personalized design.

Can old wedding rings be redesigned?

Yes, old wedding rings can be redesigned into new styles. Jewelers can reuse the original stones and metal to create a modern look that retains sentimental value.

What is the 3-month ring rule?

The 3-month rule suggests spending three months’ salary on an engagement ring. However, it’s an outdated guideline—modern couples prioritize budget, style, and meaning over strict spending rules.

How do I tell my husband I want to upgrade my ring?

Be honest and kind. Express that you love the sentimental value of your ring but would like to explore a design that better reflects your style today. Suggest upgrading together as a way to celebrate your journey.

How often should I get my wedding rings checked?

It’s always better (and less expensive) to head off repairs before you lose a stone. At Scott’s Custom Jewelers, we like to check your wedding rings every six months (just like your teeth at the dentist). We’ll deep clean your rings, check the prongs for wear, and look for any cracks or damage in the settings.

Ready to Redesign Your Wedding Ring? Let’s Make It Unforgettable

Whether you’re celebrating a milestone, honoring a loved one, or just craving a fresh new look, redesigning your wedding ring is the perfect way to reflect your journey. We specialize in transforming meaningful pieces into something that feels brand new—but still tells your story. Book your custom design appointment today and let’s reimagine your ring together!

Why Choose a Non-Diamond?

Why choose a non-diamond? Well, there are lots of reasons, and fortunately, lots of beautiful alternatives to a diamond engagement ring. Maybe you are looking for something unique or more affordable. Perhaps it’s the ethical or sustainability factors that have you questioning other gemstones. Or you simply want a symbolic meaning behind the ring that doesn’t fit the bill with traditional, popular choice diamonds.

The Story Behind the Diamond Engagement Ring

It all began in the 1400s when Archduke Maximillian of Austria commissioned the very first diamond engagement ring on record for his future bride, Mary of Burgundy. Before that, anthropologists believed the tradition of engagement rings originated from the Romans, where wives wore rings attached to small keys to indicate ownership. Yikes!

During the Victorian and Edwardian eras, rings with mixed metals, gemstones, and details like flowers were used for engagement rings. These pieces of jewelry were very ornate and featured lots of delicate filigree metalwork. This became the go-to look for engagement rings all over Europe and America.

It wasn’t until 1940, though, that diamond engagement rings became popular in the United States. The slogan, “a diamond is forever” was launched by the major diamond mining company, DeBeers, and diamonds became the go-to stone to signify marriage.

Consider a Non-Diamond for an Engagement Ring

Non-diamond rings offer a modern perspective on engagement jewelry. Instead of following tradition, choosing an alternative stone makes a statement about individuality, creativity, and the willingness to do things differently.

But it’s ultimately about finding something that feels right for you and your partner when you begin your journey together. And luckily, there are tons of options!

5 Non-Diamond Gemstones to Consider for an Engagement Ring

So, if you’re leaning away from traditional diamonds, what are your options? We’re so glad you asked. Here are our 5 favorite non-diamond gemstones to use in engagement rings.

#1. Sapphire Gemstone

Available in every color of the rainbow and cut in every shape, sapphires are a stunning, durable choice for an engagement ring. They’re also harder than many other gemstones (second in hardness to diamonds), making them a great option for a ring that can handle daily wear.

And if ethics and sustainability are important to you, then choosing a high-quality, lab-grown sapphire fits the bill as well. Lab-grown blue sapphires are much less expensive than their mined counterparts.

The only downside to lab sapphires is that they may look ‘too’ perfect! Since the process is controlled, man-made sapphires tend to all look alike.

#2. Emerald Gemstone

Known for its vivid, deep green hue, May’s birthstone, the emerald, can be a stunning, eye-catching, beautiful choice for a nondiamond engagement ring.

Emeralds were first mined in Egypt as early as 330 BC, but some historians estimate that the oldest emeralds are 2.97 billion years old. In fact, Cleopatra was said to cherish emeralds and even claimed ownership of all emerald mines in Egypt during her reign.

Today, couples may use emeralds as a symbol of loyalty, new beginnings, peace, and security.

However, natural emeralds require a bit more caution and care due to the natural inclusions (called “le jardin”), which are quite fragile. Fortunately, lab-grown emeralds can be a beautiful, affordable option for an engagement ring.

#3. Ruby Gemstone

Rubies are called the “king of colored stones” – and for great reason! Rubies symbolize passion and love with their rich red color. They’re also quite durable, making them suitable for everyday wear.

Ruby is also the red variety of the mineral corundum. All other colors of corundum are called sapphires, so the color is key for this royal stone!

As for ruby’s symbolism, this gemstone is the birthstone for July or is often used to celebrate a 15th or 40th wedding anniversary. Mined rubies come in all shades of red and are hearty enough to wear every day.

#4. Pearl Gemstone

While a bit more delicate, pearls have become a very popular option for a vintage style, non-diamond engagement ring. Widely known as June’s birthstone, pearls offer a soft, bespoke elegance for someone who wants a more neutral color as their gemstone.

Pearls are also the only gemstones made by living creatures. Marine animals, called mollusks, make pearls by depositing layers of calcium carbonate around microscopic irritants that get lodged in their shells. They quite literally make something beautiful from a problem!

Pearl engagement rings are not recommended for everyday wear, but on the upside, most pearls are not very expensive, so replacing them in your engagement ring isn’t too hard on the wallet when they get damaged

#5. Metal Only Engagement Rings

Sometimes, the best option for a non-diamond is…nothing!

Choosing to propose with a metal-only band is great for those who don’t want the fuss or upkeep of a gemstone engagement ring. But a metal band can still be filled with special details.

Multi-roped style bands (maybe signifying the joining together of the couple), fancy engraved bands, or even rings with special phrases embossed on the outside (and inside) can make this a very romantic, meaningful engagement ring. Plus, they can be worn without worrying about the gemstone!

Non-Diamond Engagement Rings: Frequently Asked Questions

Is it OK to get a non-diamond engagement ring?

Yes! Non-diamond engagement rings are becoming increasingly popular as couples look for unique, personal, and budget-friendly alternatives. Gemstones like sapphires, moissanite, and emeralds offer stunning beauty and durability, making them excellent choices for engagement rings.

What is a good alternative to a diamond engagement ring?

Popular diamond alternatives include moissanite (brilliant and affordable), sapphires (durable and colorful), emeralds (vintage elegance), and morganite (romantic blush tones). Some couples also opt for lab-grown diamonds or recycled gemstones for an eco-friendly choice.

What engagement ring is good for people who don’t like diamonds?

For those who don’t like diamonds, consider colored gemstones like sapphires, rubies, or emeralds, which offer rich hues and durability. Minimalist gold bands, signet rings, or eternity bands are also stylish, non-traditional choices for engagement rings.

What is the 3-month rule for engagement rings?

The 3-month rule suggests spending three months’ salary on an engagement ring. However, this is outdated—modern couples prioritize budget, style, and ethical considerations over arbitrary spending rules. The right ring is one that fits your partner’s style and your financial comfort.

Get Gorgeous Non-Diamond Engagement Rings at Scott’s Custom Jewelers

Find unique, non-diamond engagement rings that truly reflect your love story. We love to craft stunning alternative engagement rings with moissanite, sapphires, emeralds, and other brilliant gemstones. We create custom ring designs to match your style—from vintage to modern. Let’s dream up your perfect engagement ring today!

Whether you love trendy styles or timeless designs, here’s the ultimate guide to the most popular types of engagement rings for 2025.

The History of Engagement Rings

The history of an engagement ring, like pretty much everything else in life, dates back to Ancient Rome, when Roman women wore ivory, bone, copper, and iron rings “to signify a business contract or to affirm mutual love and obedience” to men, according to the Gemological Institute of America (GIA). Yikes!

However, it wasn’t until around 850 CE that the engagement ring was given an official meaning by none other than Pope Nicholas I.

He designated the engagement ring as representing a man’s intent to marry. And in 1477, the first diamond was used as the stone in an engagement ring when the Archduke Maximilian of Austria used it to propose to Mary of Burgundy. Fun fact: the ring was a diamond studded “M”.

Around the 15th century, engagement rings like we know today began to crop up as a symbol of a couple’s love, not a man’s property.

9 Stunning Engagement Ring Styles You’ll Love for 2025

Today, you don’t need to carve a ring out of bone or ivory to profess your love (but you do if that’s your jam!) Engagement ring styles run the gambit of a simple, single gemstone to elaborate designs that represent the couple’s interests and maybe even have a few “easter eggs” in it, a la T. Swift, that makes the ring extra meaningful.

Popular engagement trends for 2025 are all about choosing an engagement ring that symbolizes the couple through a design that can be worn every day. Here are nine engagement ring styles trending in 2025.

#1. Solitaire Rings

The most popular and longest-running trend in engagement ring styles is the classic solitaire engagement ring setting. Comprised of a single, stunning diamond or gemstone, set in a simple band of white gold or platinum. This is a timeless and elegant choice that allows the single diamond to be the main focal point.

Today, many brides-to-be are choosing elongated diamond shapes on a plain, 14k yellow gold band. Emerald cut, radiant cut, and oval cut stones (in super affordable, lab-grown diamonds) are mainstream, but the marquise-shaped diamond, popular in the 80s, is seeing a comeback as well (thanks, Selena Gomez!).

#2. Diamond Halo Rings

Another perfect choice is the diamond halo ring. This dainty, delicate option contains a central gemstone or diamond surrounded by a “halo” of smaller diamonds or gemstones, which amplifies the brilliance and size of the center stone.

Diamond halo designs can have scalloped, flowery edges with tons of details or can be bold and modern, with smooth channels or bezel set stones. Either way, halo engagement rings make the center stone really pop!

#3. Three-Stone Rings

Symbolizing the past, present, and future, the three-stone design features a center stone flanked by two smaller stones on each side. This classic engagement ring look is a great way to incorporate inherited diamonds on the sides, with a new, larger center diamond that signifies the joining of families.

Three-stone rings have so many style options, too. Love colored gemstones? Then try a gorgeous, oval-shaped blue sapphire in the center, accented with matching round diamonds on either side. Or use a diamond center stone and incorporate a couple of birthstones on the sides.

The possibilities are endless with this beautiful piece of jewelry!

#4. Vintage-Inspired Rings

Often filled with delicate filigree work and beaded details, vintage-inspired engagement rings have been popular for years. These rings feature intricate details inspired by various historical periods like Edwardian, Art Deco, or Victorian styles.

Vintage rings are also a great way to include fun details, like engraving the couple’s initials in the under-basket of the center diamond, small colored gemstones on the sides, or the shank of the ring.

#5. Toi et Moi Engagement Rings

Parlez-vous français? Toi et moi” is French for the highly romantic phrase “you and me.” And in jewelry, it also describes a very popular style of engagement ring.

This two-tone design features a bypass, or coiled band, with two gemstones nestled side by side where it meets around the finger. As the name suggests, toi et moi symbolizes two people meeting as one. ((Sigh))

Toi et moi style engagement rings can be two diamonds of different sizes and shapes (a great way to reuse family diamonds) or a diamond and a colored gemstone. There are really no rules with this trend— but they look stunning and definitely give off extra sparkle!

#6. Elongated Shaped Diamond Rings

Super feminine, elongated shaped diamonds are everywhere. Oval cut diamonds have been very on-trend for the past five years, but coming in hot are emerald cut, radiant, and rectangular cushion cut diamonds.

These long diamond shapes look awesome later, with a finger full of stacking bands accenting them. While traditionally, a woman would add only a wedding and anniversary band to each side of her solitaire setting.

Now they are adding bands that celebrate milestones like babies and special birthdays to the stack, creating a unique story.

#7. Colored Gemstone Engagement Rings

Some couples are opting for unconventional engagement rings with color instead of diamonds, in their engagement rings. Gemstones like sapphires, rubies, or emeralds have long been popular in European countries, and now that style is gaining steam in the States.

Colored gemstones like sapphires and rubies can withstand everyday wear and tear, like a diamond, and are a great choice. In fact, sapphires come in every color of the rainbow!

And with lab-grown varieties of gemstones also available, couples can also have an ethical, sustainable option when they crave something colorful.

#8. Cigar Band Engagement Rings

Bold is back, and the wide, cigar band style of engagement ring is having a moment! What are they? Well, as the name implies, the band itself is about the same width (or wider) as the metallic band around a cigar.

Thick, wide, 14k yellow gold bands, often with hammered and sandblasted finishes, are the showcase of this fun jewelry trend. While the band certainly makes a statement, opting for a cigar band engagement ring also gives room to double down on the size (and quantity) of the diamonds as well.

Paired with a delicate, thin diamond wedding band, this unique look is a modern take on traditional engagement rings. We love how it’s more practical for everyday wear.

#9. Bezel Set Diamond Rings

Bezels, either fully or partially surrounding the diamond, are rising in popularity because this setting style blends practicality with individuality. And while 14k yellow gold is the number one choice of metal with today’s brides, a white gold bezel can make a smaller diamond look larger as well.

This modern diamond style is ultra-secure for someone who is harder on their jewelry. The striking gold bezel design is a great option for those looking for both durability and style.

Types of Engagement Rings: Frequently Asked Questions

Which diamond shape is timeless?

The round brilliant cut is the most timeless diamond shape due to its classic appeal, maximum sparkle, and versatility. Other enduring shapes include the oval, princess, and emerald cuts, which have remained popular for decades.

What is the future outlook for the diamond industry?

The diamond industry is evolving, with lab-grown diamonds gaining popularity, increased demand for ethical sourcing, and a shift toward custom and unique engagement rings. The market is expected to focus on sustainability, transparency, and personalization in 2025 and beyond.

What is the 3-month rule for a ring?

The 3-month rule suggests spending three months’ salary on an engagement ring. However, this is an outdated marketing concept—modern couples prioritize budget, personal preference, and ethical considerations over traditional spending rules.

What is the most popular diamond shape in 2025?

In 2025, the most popular diamond shape is expected to be the oval cut, known for its elongated, finger-flattering shape and brilliant sparkle. Other trending shapes include the emerald cut, radiant cut, and pear-shaped diamonds.

Find the Perfect Engagement Ring at Scott’s Custom Jewelers

Ready to pop the question? We’ll help you create the perfect engagement ring that tells your love story. Custom-designed, ethically sourced, and made just for you. Start designing today!

Why not recycle it?

Recycling jewelry is an ethical and sustainable way to repurpose your old jewelry. This guide will walk you through all the options available to you to get the most use out of your old jewelry.

Why Recycling Jewelry Is Important

Not only is recycling old jewelry good for the environment – but it’s good for your budget too! Re-purposing broken, out-of-style pieces into new, custom jewelry helps the planet, saves you money and, best of all, retains the memories!

When you recycle your gold, platinum, or sterling silver jewelry, the jeweler will remove the gemstones, and then you can trade in the metal for the purchase of a new design. That way, everything gets reused.

Fun fact: jewelers recycle everything – even the floors of the workshop get recycled because there’s gold dust in them!

Taking your old jewelry to a custom jeweler is a great way to recycle those pieces into something that fits your style. I mean—trends change all of the time. What once was super hot (we’re looking at you, cocktail ring) is just not a thing now.

3 Ingenious Ways to Repurpose Your Old Jewelry

Okay, you’re really liking the idea of repurposing your old jewelry, but you aren’t sure where to start. Here are three unique ways to turn your diamonds into stunning new works of art.

#1: Turn a ring into a necklace.

Do you have an old engagement ring that you aren’t wearing anymore? Or maybe you’ve inherited your mother’s wedding set and want to incorporate it into a new necklace.

Something as simple as resetting a diamond from a ring into a simple pendant design will give old jewelry new life! Or add the small diamonds from a wedding ring to a chain that can be layered with all of your pieces.

#2: Make a custom bracelet from old jewelry.

Maybe you’ve run out of fingers to display those old rings, but you still want to be able to glance down and see that special stone. Why not make a new custom bracelet from your pieces?

Take your original diamond (because who wants to give up those great memories, even if you’ve upgraded to a new, larger diamond) and make a beautiful bangle-style bracelet that you can wear every day.

And don’t forget about those big, chunky, colored gemstones that your Great Aunt Gertie bequeathed to you. Clustered together, they can be made into a gorgeous statement bracelet! There are really so many options when it comes to restyling jewelry.

#3. Add small diamond earrings to your wedding band

Maybe you found a pair of small diamond earrings in that old jewelry stash. They can make great accent stones to your engagement ring, turning it into a meaningful three-stone, or past-present-future ring.

And that lone diamond hoop earring that’s just gathering dust? It can easily be reset into a new stacking band.

What To Do With Costume Jewelry

After sorting through that old jewelry, you may find some pieces that are not precious metal but are, instead, costume jewelry. They can be upcycled, too!

One easy way to showcase those vintage brooches, colored cluster style flower pendants, or large clip-on earrings, popular decades ago, is to visit a craft store and get a shadow box!

Simply outline a pattern in chalk on the fabric of the shadow box. Examples could be a wreath, a Christmas tree, or even a butterfly. Then, using small straight pins or glue, use those old gold-filled chains and costume pieces to fill in the design.

Not only will you have a one-of-a-kind piece of art, but you’ll smile every time you pass by.

Another option for costume jewelry is to donate it to your local theater program or high school, where it will be appreciated over and over again.

How to Redesign Old Jewelry

Redesigning old jewelry into fresh new designs is easier than you think! Follow these simple steps to breathe new life into sentimental pieces.

Step 1: Find a Trusted Custom Jeweler

Start by researching experienced custom jewelers who specialize in redesigning jewelry in Dublin. Look for customer reviews, portfolio examples, and ethical sourcing practices to ensure quality craftsmanship.

Step 2: Schedule a Consultation

Book an appointment with your chosen jeweler and bring in your old jewelry. Whether it’s an inherited piece, outdated design, or broken jewelry, they’ll assess what can be reused or repurposed.

Step 3: Discuss Your Vision

Share your ideas! Do you want to create a custom bracelet, necklace, ring, or earrings? Your jeweler will help refine your vision, suggest design options, and ensure the piece fits your style.

Step 4: Choose Materials and Design Details

Decide on key design elements, such as metal type, gemstone settings, engravings, or additional stones. Your jeweler may create a sketch or CAD (computer-aided design) rendering for approval before production.

Step 5: Watch the Magic Happen

Once the design is finalized, the jeweler will begin transforming your old jewelry into a stunning new piece. This process typically takes a few weeks, depending on complexity.

Step 6: Pick Up Your New Custom Jewelry

After final adjustments and polishing, your redesigned jewelry is ready! Enjoy your new, personalized piece that carries sentimental value while reflecting your style.

What To Do With Old Jewelry: Frequently Asked Questions

How to get rid of unwanted jewelry?

You can sell, donate, repurpose, or recycle unwanted jewelry. Selling to a jeweler, pawn shop, or online marketplace can get you cash while donating to charities or thrift stores helps others. If the piece has sentimental value, consider redesigning it into something new.

How to dispose of old jewelry?

To dispose of old jewelry responsibly, consider selling, donating, or recycling it. Gold, silver, and gemstones can be melted down and reused. Avoid throwing jewelry in the trash—take broken or unwanted pieces to a jewelry store or metal recycler for proper disposal.

How can I get the most money out of old jewelry?

To maximize value, get a professional appraisal and compare offers from jewelers, pawn shops, and online buyers. Selling directly to individuals through auction sites or marketplaces often yields higher returns. If your jewelry has historical or brand value, consider an auction house.

How do I dispose of old jewelry near me?

Look for local jewelry stores, pawn shops, gold buyers, or donation centers that accept old jewelry. Many jewelers offer trade-in or recycling programs. Searching online for “jewelry disposal near me” can help you find nearby options.

Work with the Best Custom Jewelers in Columbus

Just like a tailor, a custom jeweler will start with measurements. They will remove the diamonds and gemstones from old jewelry, weigh the old gold, silver, or platinum, and send it to a refiner to be reused again in new jewelry. It’s recycling at its finest!

Looking to learn more about recycling your jewelry into new designs? Call 614 336-4111 to schedule your custom jewelry appointment today, or book an appointment here.